How Grand Rapids is prepping for the next big storm

Getting rid of water that fell during a thunderstorm used to be a simple thing. The ground took its share, downspouts drained rooftops, and much of the rest found its way into gutters and storm sewers and on into the nearest body of water. The sun took care of the puddles.

That’s still the general idea, but things are more complicated today. A civil engineer, faced with a deluge from the sky, is likely to see opportunities, too – to relieve stress on sewer infrastructure, to keep it out of basements and other places where it’s unwelcome, to keep rivers and streams cleaner, even to enliven a boulevard with something other than yet another median strip covered with grass.

And there’s so much more rainwater these days, not overall, but all at once; the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency reports that “heavy precipitation” events,in which large amounts of rain or snow fall in a short period, are steadily increasing. Ask anyone in Louisiana, where near-apocalyptic rainfall in early August brought never-before-seen levels of flooding to Baton Rouge. Or ask the residents of Detroit, who were flooded by a 500-year storm in 2014 that dumped more than four inches of rain – over six inches in some areas – in 12 hours.

When that kind of rain comes down, every drop that can be diverted to a retention pond, infiltration basin or rain garden can keep a city’s sewer and stormwater system from being overwhelmed. And when that kind of rain isn’t coming down, these manmade structures keep pollutants, solid waste and other unwelcome substances out of a river or lake where a city draws its drinking water, swims or plays.

Related: Detroit banks on green infrastructure to rescue city from heavy rains

Around Michigan, municipalities are constructing so-called blue or green infrastructure, environmentally friendly installations to better manage resources and rainfall. The Detroit Future City initiative has a project to reduce runoff. Communities in northern Michigan are learning from a rain garden built in Suttons Bay, and a pavement that allows rainwater to soak through at a Meijer in Manistee. Grand Rapids and Ann Arbor, meanwhile, remain leaders in installing these features, as well as educating and encouraging the public to install their own.

Grand Rapids has separated its sanitary and storm sewers since 1991. (Combined sewers, in which stormwater and sewage run through the same pipes, can be problematic during heavy rains; when sewers fill to capacity, raw sewage can back up into basements or overflow into waterways.) Grand Rapids is nearly done with the job, said Mike Lunn, manager of the city’s Environmental Services Department. Once it was finished, he said, “An inch or two of rain didn’t change flows at the wastewater plant. We realized we didn’t have to put all that water into a pipe and run it into the river.”

So the city began work on various projects that would capture rainfall in wetlands and other, more natural settings and put it to better use.

First was an infiltration basin at Joe Taylor Memorial Park in Grand Rapids. Situated in the city’s Baxter neighborhood, it’s a modest, two-acre parcel whose major feature is a splash pad, beloved by neighborhood children on hot days. But it’s the park’s infrastructure that earned it a Frontline Parks award for excellence from the City Parks Alliance, a national advocacy group.

Unlike a retention pond, which holds water above ground, an infiltration basin like the one at Joe Taylor Park is installed underground, in this case beneath a parking lot with a porous concrete surface. The basin captures water and holds it until it can percolate down through gravel and sand and into the earth, keeping it out of sewers, refreshing water tables and cleaning it of pollutants in the bargain. The porous concrete looks like any other parking lot, perhaps a little rougher on the surface, but that surface absorbs water rather than allowing it to run off.

Lunn said porous concrete is generally not as strong as the conventional kind, so it’s reserved for parking lots and lanes, rather than pavement that carries vehicle traffic. It also needs to be vacuumed a couple times a year, so that sand and grit won’t clog the pores.

The basin under the park drains about 40 acres, and can hold 270,000 gallons of stormwater, the equivalent of the first inch of fast-falling rain.

There’s also a hydrodynamic separator nearby, a fairly new underground device that activates when storms hit, cleaning runoff before it gets into sewer lines. The separator spins, pulling solids – trash ranging from pop bottles to cigarette butts – out of the deluge and into a separate basin, where they’re removed by crews later.

“You wouldn’t believe how much we pull out of that,” said Michael Stall, civil engineer with the city. “That’s all stuff that would end up in the river if it wasn’t there.”

A statewide challenge

Even before lead-poisoning entered Flint’s water supply in 2014, Michigan wasn’t known for treating its water infrastructure with loving care. A 2009 report card from the American Society of Civil Engineers gave the state a D-plus in how it managed stormwater, noting for instance that there was no statewide inventory of its stormwater management systems. Not that most states were any better.

“Out of sight, out of mind,” said Ron Brenke, executive director of the Michigan section of the ASCE. “As long as the toilet flushes and the drinking water is clean, most people don’t care what sort of shape it’s in.”

Parts of the state’s urban sewer systems are so old that sections are made from wood, Brenke said, “but we really don’t know how much,” making it difficult for utilities and cities to accurately budget for maintaining or replacing underground pipes and basins. The state Department of Environmental Quality has a grant program to allow municipalities to develop management plans, but it requires local matching funds for all but the most economically distressed cities.

A report by Lansing-based Public Sector Consultants released in April estimated that $3 billion and likely more is needed to bring the state’s drinking water, stormwater and wastewater infrastructures up to acceptable standards (Disclosure: The Center for Michigan, of which Bridge is a part, is a PSC client). Gov. Rick Snyder has made this sector part of a comprehensive 21st Century Infrastructure Commission, formed in the wake of the Flint water crisis and charged with identifying a strategy to modernize the state’s transportation, communications, energy and water infrastructure over the next half-century.

Gardening in Ann Arbor

But leaders in Ann Arbor and surrounding Washtenaw County aren’t waiting for state solutions.

Residents “get the connection between the condition of the (Huron) River and the public’s drinking water,” said Jen Lawson, water quality manager for the city. Ann Arbor’s sewers have always been separate, so sewage overflow isn’t a problem. Ann Arbor works closely with Washtenaw County, Lawson said, to make environmentally friendly infrastructure improvements, and the map is studded with them, particularly residential rain gardens, which have been embraced by residents.

A rain garden sits on low-lying ground. During periods of low or normal rainfall, they look more like prairie-type swales than formal flower gardens. But in a deluge, they can collect thousands of gallons of runoff. Grand Rapids has three on the grounds of the city public-works building complex.

The River of Dreams Rain Garden, the second to be installed on Grand Rapids’ city-owned land, was drenched by a 4.7-inch rainfall one week after it was planted in 2008. Photos taken at the time show the garden looking like a pond; engineers estimate it took in 189,000 gallons in 73 minutes. But in two days, it had all been absorbed and all the plants survived.

In this dry year, the garden, and others like it, continue to thrive. In the otherwise dull landscape of the city’s public-works complex, a space dominated by cavernous garages and no-frills government buildings, the rain gardens are full of life, attracting bees, birds and butterflies to the milkweed, purple coneflowers and native prairie grasses growing there.

The city estimates it even saved money on the project, installing the garden for $35,000, where traditional drainage infrastructure such as underground pipes would have cost $60,000. And 1.5 million gallons of stormwater is kept out of the Grand River in the bargain, water that doesn’t have to be processed through the city’s treatment plant, either.

Climate change is generally acknowledged as one driver behind latter-day, how’s-that-ark-coming-along storms, Ann Arbor’s Lawson said. In 2014, the city adopted a “green streets” resolution, which makes stormwater defense a top priority during street construction projects. Under a green-streets model, the first inch of rainfall that would run off the impermeable surface of the road must be absorbed, if not by the road itself, then by nearby structures.

“Roads have 25 percent of the impervious area in town,” said Lawson. Add rooftops, parking lots and other hard surfaces, and around 40 percent of the city’s acreage sheds water rather than absorbing it.

Green streets attempt to reduce that runoff. A median strip, for instance, can easily be converted from a flat, grass-covered feature to a lower-lying rain garden. On Grand Rapids’ Plainfield Avenue, seven median islands between Page and Ann Streets can capture 90,000 gallons, enough to fill three backyard swimming pools.

Spreading the gospel

Property owners are encouraged to build their own features as well. Ann Arbor, in cooperation with Washtenaw County, runs a master rain gardener education program, and those who install rain gardens (or rain barrels) on private property can get a discount on the stormwater piece of their water bill, Larson said.

(The hazards of standing water aren’t a concern for these structures; they are designed to absorb even the heaviest rainfall within 72 hours, days shorter than the life cycle of a typical mosquito.)

Grand Rapids and Ann Arbor officials say the benefits and surging popularity of these structures are nudging more cities into trying such strategies. The Southeast Michigan Council of Governments publishes a manual for cities to adopt their own strategies, and the metro Detroit communities of Southfield, Sterling Heights and Auburn Hills are starting to experiment with them, said Amy Mangus, plan implementation manager for SEMCOG.

As late-summer storms rumble through the state, some dropping heavy amounts of rainfall, even small steps like rain gardens and bioswales (a similar feature with some technical differences) add up to significant improvement in overall water quality in a given watershed.

The Huron River is seeing more diverse and healthier fish and insect species, Lawson said, “caddisflies and stoneflies, in higher quantities.”

In Grand Rapids, where the city is working on improvements to its namesake feature to improve downtown, the quality of what flows through the Grand River is essential, said Staal, the civil engineer. “People are starting to get it,” Staal said. “It’s a quality-of-life issue for cities.”

About The Author

Nancy Derringer

Nancy Derringer is a Bridge staff writer and editor concentrating mainly on Detroit issues. She can be reached at nderringer@bridgemi.com

Comment Form

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Comments

Alice J. Ralph
Thu, 09/01/2016 - 3:02pm
Rain gardens are a wonderful part of the "accessible" range of things individual and public property owners can do that contribute to the necessary and urgent response to climate change impacts. Although Ann Arbor has been engaged good discussion, outreach and participation in this respect, the city is also, at last, in the middle of planning a number of what I would call 'public works' that can significantly amplify what our community has been doing as described above. The most ambitious of these is a master plan for creating a greenway in the valley where our historic Allen Creek was 'buried' decades ago. Over many decades, the creek was gradually diverted into a now-inadequate conduit that empties into the Huron River. But the valley, the floodplain, is still there and the intense rain storms now experienced make the floodplain visible in the usual ways. Water will make its way. It will be at least a year before the greenway planning process is completed. Meahwhile, some related projects are being pursued, such as garnering grant monies in support of clearing buildings from the floodway in cooperation with private land owners and developers. Additionally, a flood mitigation project would tunnel under the berm that elevates the active MDOT railroad bed between the Ann Arbor passenger station and the Huron River. The tunnel would channel flooding water beyond the berm toward the river. In good weather, a parallel tunnel will allow biking and pedestrian users to cross the Huron River to and from downtown Ann Arbor, the Argo Cascades, the Washtenaw Border to Border Trail and beyond. These projects aren't waiting for completion of the greenway master plan. They fit into several exisiting policy and ordinance clusters that, like the greenway, multiply the benefits of each completed project. Responsive policies and projects both are more and more urgently needed. In my view, all of these things really will make Ann Arbor one of the leading communities who are joining a statewide effort to integrate watershed, community and economic planning.
Barry Visel
Fri, 09/02/2016 - 4:28pm
Maybe urban planners are starting to figure out what rural planners already know...walkable and drainable may not necessarily go together. Seems like the drainage solution is pretty simple...if you build it you have to accommodate for runoff, whether that's private property, or public property, such as roads. So, to be clear, private development needs to be responsible for their drainage requirements, and the same for public infrastructure...meaning, it's not the governments (my) problem to deal with private property runoff (but government does have to handle their own runoff due to public projects).
Sat, 09/03/2016 - 9:04am
Not all is well in River City. A hundred years ago any kid knew that you pitched water away from the house and the barn. Water near the house or in the neighborhood raised the water table. These swales and water gardens do exactly that. The higher water table approaches the bottom of cellars and makes them damp and they start to breed mold; the place smells wet, the small cracks are stained with water and later other minerals and eventually the humidity causes mold in the wooden structures above, like the floors and walls of the house. Many become allergic to molds and so the house and neighborhood develop a reputation for being "sick." The higher water table prevents low areas from draining, and so mosquitoes breed, vermin, like rats and mice thrive. Of course, termites and cockroaches require water to survive. Houses sag, smell, are dirty, paint peals and the entire neighborhood becomes s slum before its time. It's unfortunate that ancient truisms have been neglected or forgotten. And I don't know about these increased rainfalls. Like so much environmental claptrap, this seems to be a statistic made to order for civil engineers trying to be important, or maybe employed.
JenM
Sun, 09/04/2016 - 8:26am
I really appreciate this well-written article on a subject that is most often either misunderstood or outright ignored. It will take a lot more of this kind of writing to educate the public on this subject. Perhaps as we continue to see an increased frequency of storms that produce 2-3 or more inches of rainfall in short periods of time, the issue with remain more top-of-mind for a greater percentage of people. As a civil engineer who used to work in Stormwater management, it's clear to me that these types of projects, as well as many other quality-of-life projects, can hardly get built fast enough. Hopefully we will see stronger political will to move these ideas forward at a faster pace in the near future.