How Snyder’s plan to fix Detroit school debt impacts other districts

In 2007, Detroit voters approved a ballot measure to ask the state of Michigan to take responsibility for the Detroit Public Schools’ debt that grew while a appointed board was in charge of the district. At the time, the debt was $213 million.

That request, made through the school board, was unsuccessful, as have been subsequent efforts to get relief through years of state oversight.

Gov. Rick Snyder now estimates more than $700 million is needed to save Detroit’s public schools, as his team pushes a series of draft bills that reorganize the schools and eventually pay off the debt, with legislation expected within days.

Snyder wants new Detroit schools legislation approved by the end of the year so that it may put into action for next school year. Bills will likely be debated for weeks and what ‒ if anything ‒ will emerge is up to the state’s lawmakers.

For now, the proposal for fixing Detroit’s schools requires public school districts across Michigan to help pay off the spiraling debt in the state’s largest school system. Snyder warns that if the state does not fix the DPS debt load soon, the cost will continue to worsen.

“A collapse would greatly affect all Michigan school districts as the state is Constitutionally responsible to cover many debts and liabilities, a figure that could be billions of dollars,” according to the statement released from Snyder’s office last week.

Among options being discussed is a bill that, if school funding levels remain the same, would require each district across the state to forgo $50 per student to help erase Detroit’s debt. Snyder said he intends to present a budget for next year that will increase the state's funding for schools so that districts statewide would not be hit with the $50 per pupil cut. Of course, all of this will require legislative approval.

Lawmakers will also be asked to make Detroit an empowerment zone. Under this plan, public schools in the city and on the fringe with enrollment primarily made up of Detroit residents, including charter schools and the 15 schools in the state reform district (Education Achievement Authority), would be placed under the authority of one board to be appointed by the governor and mayor.

There is a growing acknowledgement among educators and legislators in Lansing that the state shares blame for DPS’ debt and ultimately must figure out what to do. Since 1999, the state has run DPS for all but three years. Four state-appointed emergency managers have not been able to fix the DPS deficit since 2009.

Of course, more money for Detroit will mean less money for other districts if Snyder is unable to sway legislators to increase school funding. What will that mean across Michigan? In districts the size of Plymouth-Canton, a $50 per pupil cut would be equivalent to 16 teachers' salaries, or about $875,000. Traverse City would miss out on roughly $488,000. And the 1,700-student Cheboygan Area Schools district would receive $89,000 less under the plan, about what it pays for athletics.

The DPS deficit is $238 million district records show. DPS also owes a $121 million one-year loan it took out this year. Snyder last week put the debt at $515 million and said an additional $200 million would be needed to keep the district afloat.

The depth of DPS’ budget hole means it’s not a matter of if the state will have to dig into state coffers to pay the DPS debt, but when, said the state superintendent and a host of officials who typically disagree on school governance.

“The state broke it, the state has to fix it,” LaMar Lemmons, a member of the DPS school board which has no authority over the budget, said during a packed town hall meeting in Detroit last month.

Dan Quisenberry, president of the Michigan Association of Public School Academies, a collaboration of charter schools which competes head-to-head with DPS for students and funding, echoed that.

“Yes, the state will have to solve the deficit problem for DPS,” he said. “Though the discussion on ‘how’ the state will pay the debt remains.”

Snyder said at a news conference in Detroit last week that all of Michigan benefits from the economic recovery happening in the state’s largest city ‒ and that recovery relies in part on a stable Detroit school system.

“There is no question that Detroit children need a solid education so they can compete in a global economy but also for their city to accelerate its revitalization,” Snyder said.

New Co., Old Co.

Snyder first proposed splitting DPS into two entities ‒ a so-called “Old Co.” and “New Co.” ‒ in April, similar to the General Motors bankruptcy of 2009. The “Old Co.” DPS would exist to pay off the debt and a “New Co.” DPS would continue to conduct the business of educating students. The legislature responded to Snyder’s “New Co., Old Co.” idea in June by earmarking $50 million in the school aid budget that could be used to help DPS.

Here's how it would work:

Currently, DPS uses more than $1,100 of the $7,434 it gets in state aid for each student, or $53 million a year, to pay off bonds ‒ money borrowed since 2011 to keep the district operating. The “Old Co.” would use the estimated $69 million in education property taxes collected from Detroit businesses and rental properties annually to pay down the debt over the next decade. The elected school board and emergency manager would be part of the “Old Co.” and oversee the debt payments and have nothing to do with operating schools. After the debt is paid, the Old Co. DPS would be dissolved.

To start the New Co. DPS with a clean slate and full funding, Snyder’s idea would require funds to replace the local education property tax money that would be siphoned off to pay off the debt. Over the next decade while the debt is being paid off, the new Detroit school system ‒ which would be called the Detroit Community School District ‒ would need about $70 million a year to be fully-funded. That money would come from the state school aid fund, which pays for the state’s public schools, higher education and school employee retirement . As a result, schools across Michigan would see a reduction of about $50 per student until the DPS debt is paid in full ‒ about a decade, according to Snyder’s plan.

In a larger district such as Livonia with 14,300 students, that $50 per pupil reduction would be a $715,000 cut per year. Due to the hypothetical nature of Snyder's plan (no bills have been introduced or voted on yet), school officials are reluctant to say what they would do to adjust if they lost $50 per pupil.

“We will reserve comment at this time on the specific effects a cut such as that would mean, but it would certainly not be 'good news' budget wise as we struggle with the same financial issues other districts across the state are facing,” said Stacy Jenkins, spokeswoman Livonia Public Schools.

If approved, the New Co./Old Co. plan still could hit a big problem. While the proposal suggests a 10-year process for using Detroit’s education property tax to pay off the DPS debt, that property tax is not guaranteed. Detroit residents must vote on whether they want to continue to pay it in 2022. If voters reject the tax ‒ called the schools operating millage ‒ the the governor’s repayment plan would run out of money four years before the DPS debt is expected to be paid off.

When asked by Bridge at the news conference if he is concerned that voters could reject the tax and the plan, Gov. Snyder did not comment. However, John Walsh, his director of strategy said, “We would hope - working with local officials - we could continue the millage support.”

Empowerment zone

Snyder’s plan would make the New Co. DPS an empowerment zone run by a chief education office and a seven-member school board. Four of the board members would be appointed by the governor, three by the mayor. Each would be gradually replaced by elected school board members by 2022. The City of Detroit’s current appointed financial review commission would oversee the new school system’s finances until the Old. Co. DPS debt is repaid.

The Detroit Education Commission would be created and appointed (three by governor, two by mayor) to hire a chief education officer who would govern accountability measures and openings/closures of Detroit’s traditional public and charter schools. Currently, each charter school has its own authorizer and school board that oversee those functions.

Draft bills discussed in Lansing over the past several weeks have also left open the possibility that the 15 former DPS schools now run by the state’s reform district, the Education Achievement Authority, would be absorbed and become part of the empowerment zone.

Snyder supported the creation of the EAA in 2011. Since it opened in 2012 by taking over 15 Detroit schools, the EAA has suffered declining enrollment and leadership changes. In recent weeks, the EAA was also beset with scandal after an FBI investigation uncovered suspected bribes and kickbacks to a popular former principal of Mumford High who resigned last year. Several other school officials also are under FBI scrutiny, the Detroit Free Press reported.

Snyder’s update to his Detroit schools plan came days after the FBI scandal was made public.

In effect, if an empowerment zone is created, Detroit’s disparate school systems ‒ DPS, charters and EAA - could be re-centralized to a degree. A Detroit chief education officer and a state- and mayor-appointed school board would determine facilities, academic and accountability plans for schools in the empowerment zone.

Draft legislation also has proposed that the empowerment zone go past the Detroit border to include any schools located within adjacent districts or charter schools whose student population is made up of a majority of students from Detroit. A number of charter schools in adjacent, inner-ring suburbs primarily enroll Detroit residents.

Dan Quisenberry, president of the Michigan Association of Public Schools Academies, said he is wary that new governance for all public schools in Detroit will put too much power in the hands of one appointee. Dan Quisenberry, president of the Michigan Association of Public Schools Academies, said he is wary that new governance for all public schools in Detroit will put too much power in the hands of one appointee.

Quisenberry, president of the Michigan Association of Public Schools Academies, said he is wary that the empowerment zone structure puts too much power in the hands of one appointee. The move would mute the power of the colleges and universities that authorize charter schools, he said.

“This education manager is not the city taking back its schools; it’s a new entity taking them away from neighborhoods and community leaders,” he said. “All those functions under one person is an overreaction.”

What does it mean for schools outside the Detroit area?

Bills drafted and discussed around Lansing for weeks also have proposed that other school districts around the state could be made into empowerment zones, too, according to a House Democratic Policy Staff analysis of draft legislation dated Sept. 22.

Under this idea, the state superintendent or the state school reform office could create an empowerment zone if a school is not financially viable and is unable to educate pupils in the school district; a district school board could adopt a resolution designating itself as a an empowered district or residents could approve an empowerment district.

Gerald Peregord, director of the School Equity Caucus, which includes about 200 districts across Michigan, said agreed that the state needs to resolve DPS’ debt. But, he said, the proposed fixes do not address two problems ‒ Detroiters’ disenchantment with the lack of an elected, empowered school board that answers to the public, and declining enrollment in the city, which leads to less money and more deficits. DPS has lost more than 100,000 students and the state aid each brings over the past decade.

There’s no guarantee a “New Co.” DPS will be solvent; it may need even more funds at the expense of others schools in the future, Peregord said.

“They have not addressed the core problems. We could end up right back here,” he said.

Retire retirement costs

Detroit’s retirement costs have been a significant part of the discussion. Draft legislation has left open the possibility that the new Detroit school system could hire a private management company to provide a superintendent and teachers, the House Democratic Analysis contends. That could lead the district’s employees to be removed from the union as well as the Michigan Public School Employee Retirement System, which handles pensions.

There is precedence for this structure. In Michigan, most charter schools contract with management companies that in turn hire school staff. Those educators are employees of the companies, not the school, and most are not part of the state pension system.

Currently, DPS is behind on pension payments and owes $99 million, state records show.

But if DPS’ 6,200 workers were removed from the pension system, the remaining school districts and workers in the state would have to make up for the loss of payments those workers brought in so that the pension system wouldn’t be underfunded.

“While there would certainly be a negative funding impact to the system resulting from loss of those payments, it is difficult to comment or predict on what may or could happen,” said Kurt Weiss, spokesman from the Department of Technology, Management and Budget, which includes MPSERS.

“Detroit’s net pension liability as of Sept. 30, 2014 is $872,735,996, so this is the amount the other schools would need to make up over the remaining amortization period,” of 23 years, he said.

Removing Detroit educators from the pension system has been discussed but appears for now to be a long shot ‒ the governor denies that the pension system will be impacted, by his DPS fix.

David Crim, a spokesman for the Michigan Education Association, the state’s largest teacher union, said any plan that affects the pension system will hurt the city’s chances to retain teachers and will cost schools across Michigan that are struggling to pay pension costs.

“This is not an improvement,” he said. “In fact, it is going to hurt the kids and teachers, not just in Detroit but across the state because what happens in Detroit affects the rest of the state. The legislature will understand how it’s going to hurt out-state districts as (the plan) gets put down on paper.”

To be sure, the new DPS fix could take months to sort out. And the clock is ticking – interest on DPS loans continue to accrue and the fiscal year for the 2016-17 school year effectively begins July 1.

Fixing the fix

Regardless of what residents and legislators around Michigan feel about spending state money to fix the Detroit schools debt, this much is true: a decade of state intervention has seen the district’s deficit snowball out of control. And math and reading achievement on the National Assessment of Educational Progress test, known as the Nation’s Report Card, has been the worst in the nation.

The resolution of Detroit’s bankruptcy case last year did not provide a road map for resolving the city’s education debts. The state is on the hook for school debt payments so a bankruptcy for DPS is unlikely.The state constitution Article 9 Section 16 says, if for any reason any school district will be or is unable to pay the principal and interest on its qualified bonds when due, then the state shall lend it to the district.

If DPS were to declare bankruptcy, the process would take the DPS decision-making process out of the hands of the state, which Snyder does not want.

“The state would be responsible for the debt. And, in bankruptcy, a judge would make decisions about how or when the debt is repaid,” said David Murray, a spokesman for Snyder. “Those are decisions that we want to make as we take into account academics as well as finances.”

Brian Whiston, the state schools superintendent, said he hopes the governor and legislature will minimize impact on schools statewide by taking some of the money DPS needs out of the state’s general fund and not the state school aid fund.

And a fix needs to happen sooner, rather than later, he said.

“The bottomline is we have to pay off the debt. That’s a big pill to swallow,” said Whiston. “If we don’t do it today and we wait … it will be a much larger pill to swallow.”

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


Chuck Fellows
Tue, 10/27/2015 - 10:20am
Do not form another state level panel, management group, knight on white horse, silver bullet solution to a problem the current state controlled system of education, the MDE and the State Board of Education created. Petition the Executive, US Treasury and the Congress to compel the Wall Street Banks and the Moody's rating agency to return the $500 million the State Treasury invested in Lehman Bros. based on the Moody's triple A rating. Next, turn the management of the individual buildings over to the staff at that building with guidance and support provided by the MDE when requested. End all standardized testing in the district immediately. Suspend the MDE's control over content, curriculum and pedagogy and only provide assistance to individual building staff when requested. MDE responsible for health and safety only. Based the funding for each building on the aggregated need of each individual child. Use the State's general fund revenues to fund this.
Tue, 10/27/2015 - 10:22am
As if the schools in this state haven't been Why take money from other districts to fix this? How about taking back some of the corporate tax cut of a few years ago...
Tue, 10/27/2015 - 10:44am
The ripple effect of this decision is much more than financial......and I certainly hope there will be lots of debate and creative thinking before the final plan is made. I won't argue that DPS was forgotten by the MDE. I won't argue that this has been a trainwreck seen for miles (and years) ahead. But when the solution involves burdening EVERY SINGLE system and student in the state, can anyone see the potential for a lot of bitterness and hate? Talk about planting the seeds for racist banter. I do believe that we are as strong as our weakest link, but in this case the general fund of the state of Michigan and every business that was given tax relief need to weigh in on the solution, not just burden every student in the state. If we all need to bail out mistakes of the past (and I suppose we do), then we ALL need to bail out mistakes of the past. Even every legislator needs to see a cut in his salary, or a reduction in his staff. School districts can't be expected to cut budgets more and pension funds should not be drained as the first fix to a huge problem.
Wed, 10/28/2015 - 11:43am
Well said. It would be hard to accomplish with the current system, but I agree that the burden should be shouldered by all residents in the state, not just shifting around money in the school aid fund which is already stretched too thin.
David Santos
Tue, 10/27/2015 - 10:52am
You know what's coming, right? Snyder and his folks will then say fine, you don't want to help, we'll send these kids flooding into your districts (which has been taking place to a degree with vouchers). Republicans are playing with fire because one of the dangers they face is angering a sleeping bear known as parents of kids in many suburban schools who are tired of seeing some of these kids come in that do not take advantage of their opportunity (and I don't care what groups like Great Lakes Education and the Mackinac Center say, the vast majority of these kids never improve no matter what is done to help them and they hurt our schools!). Not to mention the vast discipline problems that happen and we then have to worry about being put on some Federal "watch-list" for disciplining these kids. Of course Snyder and many of his fellow Republicans don't care because their kids attend private schools (or are homeschooled). Their children will never be impacted by these decisions. Many of suburban schools are great schools because of LOCAL control and we are tired of the social experiments some people are trying for various political and economic gain. Enough is enough!
Tue, 10/27/2015 - 12:14pm
The source of the problem is with the Michigan Constitution, that it sticks the local government's and school district's debt on the State in the event that they fall into financial difficulty. There's no real penalty nor discipline (except to the state's tax payers). The only solution is to change the constitution so locals can face their own music and really go bankrupt. Without this we'll have a revolving door of our state's sub-government basket cases coming to the aid window sucking up state funds forever.
Not Crazy
Thu, 10/29/2015 - 6:47am
Complaining that the state shouldn't be on the hook for DPS's debt would be a lot stronger argument if not for the fact that the state was in control of DPS pretty much since 1999, and ran up the debt. When the state took over, the district had a surplus.
Thu, 10/29/2015 - 10:24am
If it weren't for the constitutional issue which I refer to, there would be no reason for the state to step in instead of letting the entity just going bankrupt. The fact of ultimate state assumption (legally forced) of the debts In my mind gives the state to right to do so.
Tue, 10/27/2015 - 1:30pm
The state created the debt. The state refuses the elected board's demand for an audit. Restore the democratically elected board to control. Conduct an audit. Chicago caught Barbara Byrd Bennett and she's on her way to jail for what she did there. She was brought to DPS first by one of the four EMS and she is the tip of the corruption iceberg under EMs running DPS. People should go to jail for the stealing that has gone on under EMs dictatorial, unchecked governance. Snyder and his EAA demonstrate the governor's corruption when it comes to education
Bill Perkins
Tue, 10/27/2015 - 1:48pm
I think the most Interesting part of the article is the chart that shows the per pupil amount paid to districts by the state. The way I see it my kids district subsidies the 8 thousand and 9 thousand dollars per student districts. If we had gotten 8 thousand dollars per student the whole time they were in public school that would have been 6 million dollars. A school can do a lot with 6 million dollars. I sat through the engineering orientation at U of M and listened while the students from Birmingham asked what language they would be programing computers in while my guys said well we can make a power point which just lointed to the huge diffefence in what classes differently funded districts can offer. There is absolutly no equality in school funding in Michigan and nobody wants to talk about it.
Sun, 11/01/2015 - 10:28am
I agree! Inequality of funding is the root of the problem with education in the state not just Detoit. We are not serious about education in Michigan. If we were our legislators would make school funding a priority. Why does Massachusetts spend approximately $15.000 per pupil? Because they value educating their children. Could that be why they are ranked no. 1or 2 in the country.
LaMar Lemmons
Tue, 10/27/2015 - 8:53pm
LaMar Lemmons shared For Harriet's video. 25 mins · Edited · . There is a long history of experimentation on Black children in America. Today they are poisoning our children's bodies and minds. Whether with lead in the water poisoning or substandard education with the State controlled experimental school districts of DPS and EAA, they believe we are desensitized to these experiments. The people are quiet as the State has controlled our school district for nearly 17 years. They are railroading our children from school to prison. Are we desensitized to the over experimentation on Black people? Meanwhile, President Obama and the Federal government has sent 100 million dollars to our poor Black unemployed city only to have Mike Duggan illegally collude and divert that money to White out of town companies in a Bid rigging scheme and Nobody goes to jail. Are we not good enough to tear down our own houses in our own community?
Wed, 10/28/2015 - 5:46am
I am currently employed in a well run-structured charter school within the city of Detroit. However, I am not paid like a DPS teacher because we are non-union. This is in effect an effort to union bust the largest district in the state, and make the state less accountable for providing benefits. I am not paid like a DPS teacher, not wish to be because there are other things my school does right. We have supplies, our neighborhood is safe, and we have smaller class sizes than a public school would have. If you turn me into a DPS school not by choice, should I not get paid like one? What makes them think that all of a sudden this plan will work? Why not invest the money needed to turn the schools around, lower the class size, attract good qualified teachers by giving them what they need to be successful. People who fail to see that fixing the schools is a part of fixing the city are naive, but it doesn't start by eliminating the debt, or union busting, it starts by giving the teachers what they need to be successful.
Wed, 10/28/2015 - 11:39am
Just after I read this, I read the following: I read that "Candidates and independent committees reported raising and spending roughly $134.6 million in 2014 elections, up by more than 25 percent compared to 2010." and "Political speech is the most protected form of speech, and we need more people participating at higher levels," McNeilly said. "We should applaud anyone who is leading on that dimension and try to encourage greater participation in our great American experiment." I wondered... If these people can afford to spend $134.6 M in a SINGLE year just for political elections, why can't they afford to help reduce the debt of Detroit Public Schools with a similar amount over the next few years, so that Snyder doesn't have to ROB Peter to pay Paul to FIX the debacle he helped to create there? How much do we REALLY value educating the children of our State?
Wed, 10/28/2015 - 1:34pm
Detroit "bankruptcy" well done...NO more back Bills or add-ons The date has past.. not happy.... have the appionted" Expert".for the schools .give back there salaries etcetc. / here is a simple solution : induvidual lottery TICKETS that tell /show for what the money is going for ! .schools have a school pictuer/roads have a car picture.etcetc we want to know where a bying /roads we want our money to go too. NO extra paperwork, voting or mailing on all . Taxpayer free to pay?choice where our money goes. no more paying / rembursing Insurance Companies with taxpayer money the autismfund that is dry! An finally LEGALIS marijunau and save our Young men/women from dyeing of STREET drugs daily more then 3-5 people daily from hometown each across michigan . Also it bring in new rewvue COLORADO $ 60 million Save live.used your Brains !in case you donot believe me check out the hospitals and funeral home they are back-up!
Wed, 10/28/2015 - 1:45pm
Governor Granholm promised each schoolchild a computer: new school teaching: Each classrom geta 20x10 tv screen and all children will have the same program to see/learn ,teaches from U/colleges to teach each subject uptodate.(we can no longer accept TEXAS schoolbooks testes by a single Dentist) after the TV ;question and answer etc etc after hour studyclasses /learnibg how to use Computers etc etc. our children need education Now ..the testing will be done by the same system that control our voting machine information/schoolwork in out come the 3day home work for the teaches to correct or children to study.
Thu, 10/29/2015 - 9:39pm
The racial divide in this state will probably make this plan more difficult to get through the legislature than even road funding.
Fri, 10/30/2015 - 10:33am
I have read all the comments above. The corrupt and uninformed management of Detroit Schools coupled with the declining tax base is a very sad situation. As a former teacher, I am disturbed by the constant failings and mismanagement of this district by elected and appointed managers/officials. The State allowed the problem to escalate out of control. Don't penalize other districts that have done their best to manage education funds; don't drag them down for other's mistakes. What happened to giving all the Lottery money to education? Or has that been appropriated to other things? Can that money help solve this problem?
Sat, 10/31/2015 - 6:55am
The lottery never contributed very much to education and the latest stat I read is it is now around 4% of the state education budget, a big part of the problem is that casino gambling has taken a lot of the business away from the state lottery.
Sun, 11/01/2015 - 12:57am
Mr. Governor, please kindly use the state income tax on pensions that you used to give business tax breaks to pay off the DPS debt created by the state. Sir, I humbly recommend you cease yet another experiment on Detroit's children. These mistakes have a colossal impact on our children in some cases are irreversible harm. What kind of education do our children deserve. The same education I want for the children in my family's home all attend private school or suburban schools. The constant change and Multiple EM's have not proven to be successful. Give the schools back to the community. They were more effective under local control. Build capacity and skills by investing in professional development in the leaders and teachers. Shared leadership at the building works with solid effective guidance and support. Find a way to pay th teachers a competitive wage so you can attract well trained teachers. Run the state, fix the roads and create some jobs.
Sun, 11/01/2015 - 5:53am
The lotto money is a joke . They take from one pot and put in another. It hits the people who can least afford it the hardest. The six percent sale tax was going to solve this, Ya RIGHT Alpena still gets about $7000 per student. Schools of choice at least in Alpena has always been a choice. How do people in Detroit get their children to Warren or Bloomfield Hills to school? Get more and more done with the families and prenatal and early childhood education and we may have a chance. Monitor homeschooling and Charter Schools. Wake up Mi. or it will be too late for all of us.
Thu, 12/03/2015 - 6:51pm
I just got moy property tax bill for Winter 2015. It jumped 20% from last winter! It has nothing to do with my TEV - there are two new taxes on the bill that weren't there before a) Roads2 (a duplicate of Roads) - effectively doubling my tax to pay for roads. But the big hitter was "School Debt" - nearly $400 that I didn't have to pay in the past. Which schools am I paying extra for? I am NOT happy to see such a big tax increase!