Suburban leader wants Dana Nessel to probe $20M to help ex-GOP chair

Developers Schostak Brothers & Co. want to build residential and commercial buildings on 560 acres in Salem Township. Legislators have awarded the township $20 million in 2017 and 2018 to help install water and sewer lines.

Feb. 12: Whitmer changes course, blocks $10M grant that helps former GOP chair
Feb. 1: Gov. Whitmer rips Republican pork deals, but won’t block them
Update: Arlan Meekhof takes credit for steering grants to help ex-GOP chair’s firm

A Washtenaw County leader on Thursday called for a state investigation into $20 million in taxpayer grants that will aid a private development tied to Bobby Schostak, a former Michigan GOP chairman.

Ken Schwartz, supervisor of Superior Township, labeled the grants “crony capitalism” and said state officials need to provide more details on which lawmakers backed the grants and why they are necessary.

Schwartz is the top elected official of a community directly south of Salem Township, which has received $10 million in grants with little documentation in 2017 and 2018 for water and sewer lines that will benefit development planned by Schostak’s company, Schostak Brothers & Co. of Livonia.

Related: Michigan lawmakers award $10M for project benefitting former GOP chair
Related: Michigan laws shield details of $10M grant to help ex-Republican chair

Superior Township Supervisor Ken Schwartz blasted grants that will benefit land owned by a former GOP state chair as “crony capitalism” and said he intends to seek a state probe into the deals.

The grants are unusual because they were added to budget bills without legislative sponsors or even support from Salem Township. The most recent $10 million grant came on the last day of the lame-duck session of the Legislature on Dec. 21 and was signed by former Gov. Rick Snyder, a Republican, on one of his final days in office.

“This is the time with a new administration that they can take and review it,” said Schwartz, a Democrat, referring to new Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and Attorney General Dana Nessel, both Democrats.

He said he’s spoken with local lawmakers and intends to soon formally request investigations from Whitmer and Nessel.

Their representatives did not return messages seeking comment Thursday from Bridge Magazine.

State Rep. Yousef Rabhi, D-Ann Arbor, said he would welcome a review of the process that put state tax dollars behind private development.

Michigan lawmakers complete “special grant proposal” forms after they approve grants explaining who sponsored the measure and why the funding is necessary. A 2017 form allocating $10 million for water and sewer lines in Salem Township, however, listed no sponsor. The lines will bring utilities to land owned by Schostak Brothers & Co., whose CEO, Bobby Schostak, is the former chairman of the Michigan Republican Party. The project got another $10 million in December from the state with no documentation.

“We shouldn’t be finding ways to benefit an individual or a private developer or a private project,” said Rabhi, the Democratic floor leader. “Our dollars should be going toward helping everyone.”

The latest $10 million grant was the largest of $113 million in “enhancement grants” for statewide community projects approved in December. Other projects paid for such projects as dam and road repairs and school safety, while none would directly benefit a private project.

The grants were part of a larger state spending bill that Rabhi opposed. He said the process was rushed and lawmakers couldn’t compare the value of each project.

“There were so many pet projects built in and a lot of horse trading,” said Rabhi, the Democratic floor leader. “I tend to feel that’s not the best way to run government.”

Schostak was chairman of the Michigan Republican Party from 2011 to 2015. His family’s political action committee had donated hundreds of thousands to candidates and political parties, mostly to Republicans. The top leaders of the GOP last session, including Snyder, all received donations from the PAC.

According to a published report in 2016, the Schostak company had a real estate portfolio of nearly a $800 million. It owns property in 24 states and operates more than 100 restaurants including Applebee's, Del Tacos and Olga's Kitchens.

In Salem Township, Schostak Brothers & Co. Inc. has spent 15 years assembling 560 acres near M-14 and Gotfredson Road, public records show.

That land comprises about a third of the Salem Township’s “urban services district,” which has received $20 million in state grants to extend water and sewer lines.

Schostak plans a subdivision and commercial development on the land, which requires water and sewer services.

The project has proved controversial: Salem Township has insisted private developers should pay for the utilities, while neighboring communities fear the development could strain their municipal services.

Schostak has defended the grants as appropriate to spur development and create jobs. He told Bridge Magazine this month he spoke with state officials about the grants but didn’t identify whom.

“We raised (the grant) as an option with state policy makers and appreciate their support for this kind of infrastructure and economic development project that can help strengthen the community and support families and schools,” he wrote Bridge in an email sent earlier this month.

Bridge Magazine on Thursday revealed it is rare for grants like the ones headed to Salem Township to have no legislative sponsor.

Schwartz, the Superior Township supervisor, said more transparency is needed.

“A little sunlight on the project would be beneficial,” he said.

Rabhi criticized the Salem Township money as “beyond the scope of government” because it seems intended to benefit one company.

He said the grant was part of the wheeling and dealing done in the last days of the session, a process that should change to allow more oversight.

“There were so many pet projects built in and a lot of horse trading,” said Rabhi, the Democratic floor leader. “I tend to feel that’s not the best way to run government.”

An official for the Michigan Township Association said developers typically underwrite the cost of bringing public utilities to a site. Before the 2009 recession, some communities agreed to borrow the money on behalf of developers, with tap-in fees covering those costs.

“It’s a private benefit. It’s not a public benefit, water and sewer,” said Larry Merrill, executive director of the Michigan Township Association.

The cost to bring water and sewer to the Salem Township property is estimated at $30 million, said Gary Whittaker, the Salem Township supervisor.

The Schostak company had asked the township to borrow the money on its behalf with developer fees paying back the loan. The township declined, Whittaker said.

He said township officials have feared the community would have to absorb costs of the utility expansion if the development failed.

In nearby Sylvan Township, west of Ann Arbor, all property owners are paying 4.75 mills each year for a water tower and water system that were built for a housing project that was stalled for over a decade.

Salem Township does not levy any local property taxes; tipping fees from its landfill cover most township costs, Whittaker said.

Like what you’re reading in Bridge? Please consider a donation to support our work!

We are a nonprofit Michigan news site focused on issues that impact all citizens. In an era of click bait and biased news, we focus on taking the time to learn both sides of a story before we post it. Bridge stories are always free, but our work costs money. If our journalism helps you understand and love Michigan more, please consider supporting our work. It takes just a moment to donate here.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Bernadette
Fri, 01/25/2019 - 10:16am

If you look all around the state The Schostak company signs are everywhere. Mr. Schostak should take his own money and make the improvements necessary to build on that land. This is obviously "politics as usual under the previous administration."

I would hope there are ethics laws passed under this administration that open up the governors office and the legislative branch to review. Michigan is in the bottom half of the states when it comes to all the important indicators making MI the kind of state where people don't want to live(thus the drop in population).

Dr. Robert Sapolsky, neuroendocrinologist, has focused his research on issues of stress and talks about how stress affects a decrease in health of one part of the population, but actually decreases the health of the entire population of that region. Below is a link to a podcast talking about this. Michiganders need to educate themselves on the health effects of this political polarization on our state.

https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/vox/the-ezra-klein-show/e/58359498?auto...

John
Fri, 01/25/2019 - 10:39am

Yes, the Superior Township Supervisor is correct. The grants made to Shostak smell to high heaven and it is clear that whoever sponsored the bill smells too. Wonder what legislator or legislators got from Shostak for the "free" $10 million? It needs to be investigated by the Attorney General.

Don Coddington
Sun, 01/27/2019 - 8:41pm

I bet every one of the lawmakers received campaign contributions from Schowstak

Beth Anne Gruizinga
Fri, 01/25/2019 - 11:36am

Corporate corruption MUST be stopped!!Our people, our land , our water and our wildlife are being destroyed by greed!!

Susan
Thu, 01/31/2019 - 11:41am

I'm fairly confident Ms. Nessel will get to the bottom of this in relatively short order...