Detroit offers $50 a shot to people who bring residents for COVID vaccines
Detroit is sweetening the deal to boost the city’s COVID vaccination rates, offering $50 per shot to people who bring city residents to vaccine sites, Mayor Mike Duggan announced Wednesday.
The incentives are handed over in $50 Mastercard debit cards — $100 for a two-dose vaccine — and there’s no limit to how many residents a person can bring in for shots under the Good Neighbor program.
- COVID is fading, but racial gap in deaths is back with force in Michigan
- ‘A personal choice.’ Michigan GOP leaders balk at COVID vaccine incentives
- Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer links easing COVID rules to vaccines
- As Michigan COVID vaccine rates ebb, pop up clinics and casino cash appear
- CDC: Michiganders vaccinated against COVID can ease outdoor mask use
- Michigan GOP pushes to ban vaccine passports, university mandates
“Take it, spend it wherever you like, it's yours,” Duggan said at an afternoon news conference. “You will be handed it on site as soon as the person with you gets their shot.
“Then, if you come back for the second shot, you get another $50 card. So just bring them back.”
In a city with the state’s lowest vaccine rates, Duggan called the program “uncharted territory.”
The “neighbor” who stands to financially benefit does not need to be a Detroit resident, but the person brought in for a vaccine must live in the city, under the terms of the program.
“We’re going to see if we can't prove to the country that the people in the city will watch out for their neighbors,” he said.
A $3.4 million state grant set aside to cover vaccine-related costs will fund the program, and there’s enough in the grant set aside to vaccinate 68,000 Detroiters, according to city spokesperson John Roach.
Detroit is not alone in “grappling with how to get people vaccinated,” said Nick Derusha, president of the Michigan Association for Local Public Health, which represents the state’s 45 health departments, including the city of Detroit’s.
As public health and other officials have watched vaccination interest wane in recent days, incentives are being offered to nudge the state toward reaching herd immunity from the virus. Wayne State University is giving students a $10 credit on student accounts for those vaccinated and, in the private sector, you can get free donuts. A Michigan casino offered casino cash, and some employers are considering incentives for employees.
This week, West Virginia announced it will offer a $100 savings bond to each person from 16 to 35 years old who gets a COVID-19 vaccine.
But Derusha said Wednesday he knows of no government or health department in Michigan that has offered cash incentives — and certainly not unlimited $50 cards.
“In all honesty, I’ve heard a lot of brainstorming to get people in” for vaccines as demand for vaccines abates, Derusha told Bridge Michigan.
“In a perfect world, putting the pandemic behind us would be incentive enough to be vaccinated.”
Joel Stracz, health officer in Bay County, said he wasn’t surprised by Detroit’s offer.
“That’s going to happen more and more,” he said, adding that Bay County officials are considering incentives, but he said they should also be given to those who have already chosen to get vaccinated as well. Even though he said tax dollars can’t be used, county officials may have to find the money — or carrot — somewhere else to lure people in for vaccines.
“If it’s a material thing, so be it,” he said. “That’s what we have to do.”
If there’s any concern beyond budget constraints, said MALPH’s Derusha, it’s that adding incentives might appear to those skeptical of vaccines as undue government pressure — something Duggan seemed sensitive to in his Wednesday announcement.
“I am not a believer that the city of Detroit writes checks for people to get a vaccine. I just think it's the wrong thing to do. You're paying people to save their own lives,” Duggan said.
It also might appear that the city is “pressuring, I don't want to do that,” he said.
But there was this reality, he said: The city already was offering rides, through a transportation service, IntelliRide. Each trip cost the city $35 to $50, even though residents were charged just $2. The Good Neighbor program redistributes the money into local residents’ pockets instead, he said.
The city was one of the nation’s hardest hit during the first wave of the pandemic. Yet many African Americans, in Detroit and elsewhere, have expressed reluctance to get a vaccine, or have found it more difficult to reach vaccine clinics.
So Detroit has been creative in its efforts to boost vaccine rates.
Earlier this year, when the state only made limited supplies of vaccines available to residents 65 and older, Detroit offered vaccinations to anyone — regardless of age — if they brought an older resident to a vaccine site.
The “take rate” went “way up,” Duggan noted Wednesday.
But when eligibility opened to nearly everyone for the vaccine, “nobody had to be a good neighbor,” he said. “And when that happened, in particular, we saw the senior vaccines start to dip. We no longer had nearly as many people reaching out to our elderly and saying ‘Let me take you to get your shot.’”
Detroit currently has by far the state’s lowest vaccination rate — 19.2 percent of residents age 16 and older are fully vaccinated. Statewide the percentage of eligible people who are fully vaccinated stands at 35.9 percent. Some counties listed with lower rates — such as Menominee, Cass and Monroe — likely have higher rates than they are given credit for because many of their residents crossed borders to Wisconsin, Indiana or Ohio to get vaccines, which are not reported back to Michigan.
Duggan said the neighbors program has rules to protect against fraud, including:
- Those who sign up as “good neighbors” must be registered and appointments must be scheduled by calling 313-230-0505.
- One “neighbor” is allowed per carload, but they can bring in up to three people at a time for vaccines, netting them $150 per trip.
- The people being vaccinated must be Detroit residents.
- A Good Neighbor will be paid for a resident’s second dose only if he or she were present and paid for the person’s first dose as well.
- There’s no limit to how many people you bring to be vaccinated. But any amount collected over $600 must be reported to the Internal Revenue Service on 2021 taxes.
- Only appointments starting Monday and at the following locations qualify for Good Neighbor reimbursement; TCF drive-thru from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m.; Northwest Activities Center, 18100 Meyers Rd., from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m.; Straight Gate Church, 10100 Grand River Ave., from 9 a.m. to 7 p.m., and Saturday sites for which details are listed here.
We’ve been there for you with daily Michigan COVID-19 news; reporting on the emergence of the virus, daily numbers with our tracker and dashboard, exploding unemployment, and we finally were able to report on mass vaccine distribution. We report because the news impacts all of us. Will you please support our nonprofit newsroom?