Detroit makes it easy to switch schools. So parents do. Frequently.

Jamarie Samuel attended seven schools by eighth grade, enrolling mid-seventh grade at Bethune Elementary-Middle School, which like many schools in Detroit has chronic problems with students switching schools. (Bridge photo by Anthony Lanzilote)

One Detroit mom said she moved her son to four schools by the third grade because he kept getting bullied.

Another said she transferred her daughter to three different schools by the sixth grade in hopes of finding a better experience.

Her child’s first school “couldn't keep a teacher for her class the whole school year,” she said. The second one “was completely unorganized.”   

Other Detroit parents who responded to a survey conducted by Chalkbeat and the nonprofit news service Outlier Media offered a mix of answers for why they moved their children from one school to the next. Their reasons: academic struggles, issues with school discipline, and personal upheavals that forced them to find a new home.

But, overwhelmingly, Detroit parents said they moved their children to new schools because they wanted better for their child — a safer school, a cleaner school, the kind of school where their children could thrive.

Chalkbeat and Outlier, together with our partners at Bridge Magazine, conducted the survey over three weeks last spring to better understand the forces behind what some educators say is the largest hurdle blocking academic success in Detroit: The fact that students don’t stay.

Across the city, a recent study found that 1 in 4 students change schools every year. In elementary schools, the rate is 1 in 3. And many students make those moves during the school year.

All of that movement — fueled in part by state policy in Michigan that has given Detroit one of the most robust systems of school choice in the country — has created a level of instability with serious ramifications for children and schools. It brings down test scores, drives up dropout rates, and exacerbates behavioral problems.

But while studies have clearly documented the effects of students moving from place to place, there’s not much research on why parents make so many moves.

Ben Pogodzinski and Sarah Winchell Lenhoff, two Wayne State University professors who have spent the last year analyzing data on student transience in Detroit, found that only about 40 percent of children who changed schools between the 2014-15 and 2015-16 academic years had changed their address to a different ZIP code.

Chalkbeat and Outlier set out to identify the other reasons. We surveyed 100 Detroit parents using a text messaging platform called GroundSource that enabled us to reach a representative sample of parents across the city, asking respondents how often their children had changed schools — and why.

Roughly half of the 100 parents who responded to our survey said their children had made at least two school transfers beyond routine moves, like moving from middle to high school. That includes 30 parents whose children had made at least three non-routine moves and nine who said their children changed schools five or more times.

In all, the parents we surveyed moved their children 197 times outside of routine moves, with roughly 40 percent of those moves taking place during the school year.

And their reasons were varied:

  • 30 percent of moves were attributed to school performance issues, such as the quality of instruction. That includes a sizable number of parents who said their children have disabilities that were not being properly addressed by their schools.
  • 25 percent of school transfers were related to family moves.
  • 15 percent were related to the school environment, including concerns about crime and safety.
  • 10 percent said they moved their children because of logistics such as a new job that put a child’s school in an inconvenient location.
  • The rest said their children left for other reasons, including school closures or students being pushed out for academic or behavioral reasons.

It’s easy to switch schools in Detroit because parents here enjoy far more school options than their peers in other parts of the country.

Detroit parents can choose from more than 100 district schools and 88 charter schools in the city. Or they can cross the city border to one of many suburban district or charter schools that accept out-of-district kids. Since Detroit and many of its surrounding communities have significantly more school seats than children, many schools in the area have space available for nearly anyone who wants to attend.

That means parents who aren’t happy with their local school, who don’t think it’s safe, or who discover that a new job or a new shift makes a school’s location or schedule impractical for the family are free to go somewhere else.

It’s a luxury for which many parents are grateful.

“When it comes down to it, I’m looking out for the best interest of my kids,” said Lyjuan Smith, who had two children at Detroit’s Bethune Elementary-Middle School last year but planned to move them to a charter school this year because she thought they would get a better education there.

Randy Liepa, who heads the county educational agency that supports school districts in Wayne County, including Detroit, said most of the districts in the county see students coming and going as parents explore their options.

“It’s definitely grown over time,” Liepa said. “Mom and Dad will think, ‘He needs a new environment,’ so they move him, and then that doesn’t work, and then they wind up back where they started. Then they try another option.”

In the Chalkbeat/Outlier survey, a majority of parents, 66 percent, said they thought switching schools made it easier for their child to succeed in school.

Only 11 percent said they thought switching schools made things harder.

Some research suggests that moving from low-performing school to a higher-performing school can benefit students. But in Detroit, very few schools are considered high performing.

The main Detroit district has the lowest test scores in the nation, and charter schools in Detroit are not much better. A recent analysis found that the vast majority of Detroit children — 70,000 of the 85,000 attending public school in the city — are in schools that don’t meet the state’s basic criteria for performance. And many cash-strapped schools also struggle to maintain their buildings and give children enough support to prevent fights and behavioral problems.

That means that while families keep moving, continually looking for something better, the odds are that they’ll find similar problems at their next school and have to move yet again.  

And the cycle will continue, making things more difficult for each child with each move.

About this project

This story is part of a series, “Moving Costs: How students changing schools hurt Detroit classrooms,” a joint project by Bridge Magazine and Chalkbeat. Erin Einhorn is Detroit bureau chief of Chalkbeat, a national education news site. Chastity Pratt Dawsey is a Bridge reporter.

Like what you’re reading in Bridge? Please consider a donation to support our work!

We are a nonprofit Michigan news site focused on issues that impact all citizens. In an era of click bait and biased news, we focus on taking the time to learn both sides of a story before we post it. Bridge stories are always free, but our work costs money. If our journalism helps you understand and love Michigan more, please consider supporting our work. It takes just a moment to donate here.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Matt
Tue, 10/02/2018 - 8:27am

As stated many of the poor live in a life of constant chaos, often self inflicted and not recognized as anything but the norm. If stated I didn't notice but as with most things a relatively small percentage of the population is likely responsible for a super-sized percentage of, in this case, the moves. Second we are looking at kids who are likely already struggling academically and changing the school isn't the solution therefore doesn't solve the issue. The biggest driver of this problem i'd suggest is our insistence to prioritize egalitarian objectives over academic achievement. If kids had to qualify to gain admittance to a given school they desired to attend the atmosphere would be totally different. In our current approach they all sink.

Jarrett Skorup
Tue, 10/02/2018 - 9:02am

From the article above: "The main Detroit district has the lowest test scores in the nation, and charter schools in Detroit are not much better. "

From the link supplied in that sentence presumably to back up the evidence: "[Detroit] charter schools provide essential examples of school-level and system-level commitments to quality that can serve as models to other communities." It notes that the majority of students see significantly improved educational results after going from district schools to charters with almost none doing worse after switching.

Chastity
Tue, 10/02/2018 - 2:14pm

Hi, Jarrett. Thanks for reading. The Wayne State University research shows that Detroit charters experience the same level of churn, student mobility and enrollment instability as district schools. If charters were significantly better, the enrollment would be stable. However, on average, charters perform slightly better than district schools with a majority of charters testing in the bottom quarter of all schools in the state.