Michigan legislation would help homeowners pay for failing septic systems
In Michigan, the state estimates there are more than 330,000 failing septic tank systems. They could be contaminating lakes, rivers and groundwater. State government agencies don’t have the authority to do much about that. And many homeowners don’t have the money to do much.
Cindy Krohn and her husband are on fixed incomes. Five years ago, they were in the process of buying a home in Linwood, a small unincorporated community on Lake Huron’s Saginaw Bay.
This article is part of The Great Lakes News Collaborative, which includes Bridge Michigan, Circle of Blue, Great Lakes Now at Detroit Public Television, and Michigan Radio. It unites newsroom resources to report on the most pressing threats to the Great Lakes and drinking water supplies, including pollution, climate change, and aging infrastructure. The independent journalism is supported by the Charles Stewart Mott Foundation.
“We noticed there was some drainage coming out from the crawlspace. The inspector found that and they then drained and cleaned out the septic tank, and we thought that was everything that needed to be done because then it was fine for a few months,” Krohn said.
- Rising cost of water in Michigan leads to affordability problems
- Reduce flooding from backed up sewers? There’s an app for that in Michigan
- Climate change grips trout streams across the nation: How anglers are responding
But then, they noticed a sewer smell every time they did the laundry.
The system is failing. At a minimum, it will cost $10,000 and up to $20,000. Krohn said they don’t have that kind of money and can’t afford a loan. All they can do is have the septic tank pumped out every few months.
“That's $250 each time they come out,” she said.
This kind of story is frustrating to some of those in the septic system business.
“Why we have governments that can't protect these things, and can't work together enough to protect our waterways, just baffles me. I don't understand that,” said Rick Throop, president of the Michigan Septic Tank Association.
He runs a septic service company in Macomb County. There the county requires a complete septic system inspection before a house is sold and the seller has to fix any problems.
“So if you put a point-of-sale program in place, those things don't happen. Houses don’t slip through the cracks. People don't get screwed in the long run because the problems are found before the property transfers,” Throop said.
Very few counties or health departments require that. There was legislation a few years ago to try to require that statewide and find money to help people or communities that need the help. That legislation was blocked.
Among those opposed was the Michigan Realtors Association. Brad Ward, vice president of public policy and legal affairs for the organization, said Realtors support an inspection system, just not one at the point of sale because the group does not feel it’s efficient or fair.
Here’s the argument: Let’s say you’ve lived in your house for 20 years. The house next door has sold three times in the last 15 years.
“Your septic system has never been inspected where mine has been inspected three times in that same 15-year period,” Ward said.
The Realtors think a law requiring regular inspections every five or ten years makes more sense.
For most Michigan homeowners, none of this is a concern. They’re hooked up to a municipal sewer plant. They pay a monthly fee. Not only is their wastewater cleaned up, it’s disinfected before it’s released into the environment.
Owners of septic systems don’t really think about the cost as long as the drain doesn’t back up. Few put aside money for when their system might fail. A failing septic system threatens public health because its wastewater is not disinfected. Pathogens such as e. coli bacteria and viruses can get into sources used for drinking water.
In a worst case scenario, homeowners who cannot afford septic tank system repairs will pipe it to nearby ditches or make illicit connections to storm drains.
Current legislation in Lansing would not implement statewide inspection regulations. Instead, it would contemplate using some American Rescue Plan money to help fix the immediate problem: those septic systems that are failing right now.
State Sen. Rosemary Bayer, a D-Beverly Hills, said it amounts to $140 million and “includes revolving loan funds for individual homeowners. It includes grant funds for communities under 5,000 residents.”
That sounds good, but of that $140 million, $35 million is for failing septic system loans. That falls far short of the at least $3.3 billion needed to fix just the current failing septic systems. That estimate is based on the 330,000 failing septic systems in Michigan each requiring $10,000 in repairs. The more likely scenario is a much, much higher amount.
But Bayer said the state has to start somewhere and there is bipartisan support. It’s part of a sweeping package of bills senate Republicans proposed and Democrats supported to help fix many of Michigan’s water and wastewater problems.
“We did approve funding in the Senate,” she said, noting there is “still a negotiation going on with the House.”
But even if it’s approved and the governor signs it, it doesn’t really solve the problem for Cindy Krohn. She said even a low-interest loan seems out of reach and she knows other people in Michigan are in the same place. She said she’s searched the internet for help and called every office she can think of for advice.
“There needs to be some kind of program, because (the) majority of people don't have $20,000-plus to repair a septic system. Most people don't have that. And it's something that you have to have. You can't just put it off for years. And nobody has any answers. And we just don't know what to do.”
Beside the revolving loan program, the legislation, if it’s passed, could give counties grant money to assist homeowners in repairing septic systems. It will still leave those homeowners to come up with thousands of dollars or even tens of thousands, depending on how much work is needed to fix the septic system.
Michigan Environment Watch
Michigan Environment Watch examines how public policy, industry, and other factors interact with the state’s trove of natural resources.
Michigan Health Watch is made possible by generous financial support from:
Our generous Environment Watch underwriters encourage Bridge Michigan readers to also support civic journalism by becoming Bridge members. Please consider joining today.
We’ve been there for you with daily Michigan COVID-19 news; reporting on the emergence of the virus, daily numbers with our tracker and dashboard, exploding unemployment, and we finally were able to report on mass vaccine distribution. We report because the news impacts all of us. Will you please support our nonprofit newsroom?