Oakland County ‘ground zero’ in fight for control of Michigan House
Nov. 4 update: Republicans flip Democratic seats, keep majority in Michigan House
LANSING — Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer isn’t up for re-election, but she’s been back on the campaign trail this fall trying to help fellow Democrats flip the state House.
Whitmer has a clear motivation: After two years of fighting with Republican majorities in Lansing over gas taxes, budgets and the state’s response to COVID-19, the governor wants to have at least “half of the Legislature that’s going to have my back,” she said at a recent campaign stop for Rep. Sheryl Kennedy, D-Davison.
“We can pick up four more seats,” Whitmer said.
- How to vote early in Michigan
- Election Tracker: The latest news on elections, campaigns and politics
- Fact Squad: What ads are true, and which aren’t
- Bridge’s complete election 2020 coverage
- Michigan elections fact guide
- Have questions about the election? Let us know.
That would give Democrats their first majority in either legislative chamber since 2010, when Republicans flipped the House and continued their vise grip on the Senate, which they’ve controlled since 1984.
The GOP currently has a 58-52 seat advantage in the House, where all 110 House seats are up for grabs. The state Senate, where Republicans hold an edge, 22-16, is not up for re-election until 2022.
Democrats hope for a blue wave propelled by presidential nominee Joe Biden, but Republicans may hold an advantage because of district maps that a court found are the result of a “political gerrymander of historical proportions."
Two years ago, for instance, Whitmer defeated Republican Bill Schuette by nearly 9 points. Democrats gained five seats in the state House, but Republicans still returned a six-seat majority, with 58 out of 110 members.
Democrats expect big things in Oakland County, where at least three seats could be up for grabs. But Republicans continue to build strength in northern Michigan and other rural areas, including a Bay County seat where they are hoping for a flip of their own.
Late last week, with less than two weeks left before the Nov. 3 election, Bridge Michigan asked some of the state’s leading political consultants and pollsters to size up the battle for the state House.
Races to watch
Top Democratic targets:
- 38th District, Oakland County: Novi City Councilwoman Kelly Breen, a Democrat, is considered a slight favorite in her race against Republican Chase Turner for a seat held by term-limited GOP Rep. Kathy Crawford, who narrowly defeated Breen in 2018.
- 39th District, Oakland County: Incumbent Rep. Ryan Berman, R-Commerce Township, faces Julia Pulver of West Bloomfield, a nurse who built up her name ID in a 2018 run for state Senate, which she narrowly lost.
- 45th District, Oakland County: Democrat Barb Anness, a member of the Rochester school board, faces Republican Rochester City Councilman Mark Tisdel to replace term-limited GOP Rep. Michael Webber.
- 61st District, Kalamazoo County: Democratic Kalamazoo County Commissioner Christine Morse faces business owner Bronwyn Haltom in a district that is trending Democrats but is currently held by term-limited GOP Rep. Brandt Iden.
- 104th District, Grand Traverse County: Democrat Dan O’Neil lost to incumbent Rep. Larry Inman by 349 votes in 2018. Inman survived federal bribery charges but cannot seek re-election due to term limits. O’Neil is running again, this time against Grand Traverse County Republican Party Chair John Roth.
Top Republican targets:
- 96th District, Bay County: Two-term Democratic Rep. Brian Elder of Bay City won re-election by 13 points in 2018 but is battling shifting dynamics in this Thumb seat, which Republicans are spending heavily to flip. GOP nominee Timmy Beson is a Bangor Township school board member.
- 19th District, Wayne County: Democratic Rep. Laurie Pohutsky of Livonia won this seat by 224 votes in 2018, flipping an open seat that had been held by current Michigan Republican Party Chair Laura Cox. This time around, Pohutsky faces Martha Ptashnik, a teacher in Livonia Public Schools.
‘A nightmare brewing’ for GOP in Oakland County
Adrian Hemond, a Democratic strategist at the Grassroots Midwest consulting firm in Lansing, said he gave Democrats a 1 in 3 chance of flipping the House at the start of the year.
“But now? If somebody wanted to take the action, I would absolutely put money on the House Democrats flipping it,” Hemond told Bridge.
“No one’s voting in this election because of who’s running for state representative, to be blunt,” he said. “They’re voting in this election because of how they feel about [President Trump.] They like him, or they don’t like him. It’s a turnout game at this point.”
Democrats have opportunities elsewhere, but Oakland County is “ground zero” for efforts to flip the House, Hemond said.
Juila Pulver of West Bloomfield is one three Oakland County Democrats competing to flip GOP seats.
Through Oct.18, she had nearly doubled incumbent Rep. Ryan Berman in fundraising, but the House Republican Campaign Committee is giving Berman major air support: more than half a million dollars in ad spending.
“Republicans just got brutalized in Oakland County in 2018, and everything that we’re seeing now — whether that’s polling data or digging into the absentee data about how has actually sent ballots back already — that there’s a nightmare brewing for the state GOP in Oakland County,” Hemond said.
Democrats are playing defense in the 19th District, where Rep. Laurie Pohustky of Livonia narrowly flipped a GOP seat in 2018 and is running for re-election against Republican teacher Martha Ptashnik. Whitmer knocked doors with Pohutsky, and a political action committee linked to the governor has put $10,500 into the race.
But Hemond wrote off GOP attempts to unseat Pohutsky as “kind of laughable” given the president’s poor polling numbers in western Wayne County.
The GOP has a better shot against Democratic Rep. Brian Elder in Bay County, where “the president is not as toxic as he is” in more affluent areas of the state, Hemond said.
Democrats path still ‘very challenging’
“There could be a path [for Democrats to flip the House,] but I think it will be very challenging,” said Jenell Leonard, a Republican consultant at the Marketing Resource Group in Lansing.
When Leonard first started working in the state House in 2006, the GOP was focused on flipping Democratic seats in northern Michigan, but those are “strongholds now,” she said.
“When both caucuses have to look at the map to see where they can play, they need to look at not just where they have traditionally held seats, but also look for new opportunities.”
One of those new opportunities is Elder’s seat in Bay County’s 96th District, Leonard said, noting the national political headwinds appear to favor Timothy Beson.
But those same national trends appear to favor Democrats in areas like Kalamazoo and Oakland counties, she said. The latter “has a lot of traditional establishment Republicans that may not be in line with the national trends right now — the Trump administration.”
A ‘wave’ wasn’t enough in 2018
There’s certainly a “possibility” that Democrats flip the state House, said Greg Bowens, a Democratic consultant with Bowens & Co. in Grosse Pointe.
But he noted that didn’t happen in the “last blue wave” just two years ago, when Whitmer coasted in the gubernatorial race but Republicans still returned majorities to the House and Senate.
Despite their gains, Democrats still struggle “big time” outside of metro Detroit and other larger cities, he said.
But Bowens said he’s buoyed by “glimmers of hope” in traditional GOP areas: He pointed to the recent retirement of a Christian Reformed pastor in Holland, who said he stepped away from the pulpit last month because of the church’s broad support for Trump.
“I've not seen this much enthusiasm and effort to try and push the straight Democratic ticket in a long time,” Bowens said.
A 55-55 split could force shared power
GOP consultant John Sellek pointed to another possible scenario: A 55-55 tie in state House seats, which would usher in the chamber’s first period of split power since 1993-94, when Democrat Curtis Hertel and Republican Paul Hillegonds served as co-speakers.
Even if Republicans lose three seats in Oakland County, if they keep a contested seat in Traverse City and maybe even flip a Democratic seat in the Livonia or Bay County regions, “then Republicans could pull something off or end up in a tie,” he said.
Sellek said Republicans also are posing solid fundraising numbers, running TV ads in key races and still benefiting from districts that they drew in 2011.
“Even if it’s 10 years old, [the districts] still favor Republicans,” Sellek said.
See what new members are saying about why they donated to Bridge Michigan:
- “In order for this information to be accurate and unbiased it must be underwritten by its readers, not by special interests.” - Larry S.
- “Not many other media sources report on the topics Bridge does.” - Susan B.
- “Your journalism is outstanding and rare these days.” - Mark S.
If you want to ensure the future of nonpartisan, nonprofit Michigan journalism, please become a member today. You, too, will be asked why you donated and maybe we'll feature your quote next time!