Michigan inmates may lose college funding. That’s bad news for the rest of us.

Ex-inmate Kristi Fraga on what college in prison meant to her: “It’s changed my life.” (Courtesy photo)

In his three years in prison, Robert Elliott has made the most of his time.

He boasts a 4.0 grade point average for a series of courses he’s taken through a local college in Jackson.

Eligible for parole in 2021 on a pair of Kent County drug dealing convictions, Elliott, 35, expects to be close to a bachelor’s degree through the federally funded college program when he gets out. He’s got his eye on a possible job in construction management.

Michigan inmate Robert Elliott, serving time for drugs, says that the college coursework he’s taking has him eying a job in construction management.

“I really want people to know that this college thing is huge to the people in here,” he told Bridge Magazine in a phone interview. “It’s not being abused. We are all looking forward to a future because of this. It can really change lives.”

The evidence says Elliott is right.

A 2016 study by the RAND Corporation found that inmates who participated in education programs had 43 percent lower odds of re-entering prison after release than inmates who did not. Largely as a result, the study found, prison education saves five dollars for every dollar spent.

That’s not surprising, given that education remains the greatest predictor among adults in general of future employment and earnings. And with an average annual cost of incarcerating Michigan inmates at about $36,000, the potential savings to state taxpayers from prison education seems considerable. Michigan has just under 40,000 state prisoners.

But as of now, the state puts no money toward college prison education. And the federal program that allows some Michigan inmates, like Elliott, to take college classes is slated to run dry in 2019. It’s anybody’s guess if it will be renewed.

Even with the current funding, state prisons enroll just over 600 inmates ‒ less than half the nearly 1,500 college slots authorized by the federal grant for educating Michigan prisoners.

“Without the ability to pay for it, I don’t know how it would be sustained,” said Bobby Beauchamp, who directs the state’s largest prison education program from nearby Jackson College. It’s funded through the federal Second Chance Pell pilot initiative, which extends college courses to inmates at seven Michigan prisons and a federal prison in Milan.

Based on the federal program, it would cost the state roughly $9 million a year to replace the Pell program’s authorized Michigan slots. That’s less than 1 percent of the total state prison budget of about $2 billion ‒ an investment that one state prison reform advocate says Lansing would be wise to make.

“The economic reasons for doing this are as important as the moral reasons,” said former Holland GOP Rep. Joe Haveman, who is running for the state Senate seat vacated by outgoing Senate Majority Leader Arlan Meekhof.

Asked if he would push for the state to fund prison college programs if federal money fell through, Haveman said: “I can only speak for myself. But 95 percent (of inmates) will come out one day. Why wouldn’t we want to give them all the tools they need to succeed the second time around?

“It’s that ounce of prevention and pound of cure. Prison is the pound of cure. Why would we want to do that pound of cure a second time?”

One clue to its future resides in the office of U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos, a long-time Michigan Republican activist. Her department has authority over the federal Pell program and has renewed it until the summer of 2019.

In a February conference call, DeVos said extending Pell grants to prisoners was "a very good and interesting possibility,” while adding that "obviously the department is not real involved with criminal justice reform issues."

Her brother-in-law, Doug DeVos, wrote a guest column in Bridge in March voicing support for state prison reform measures, pointing out, like Haveman, that most prisoners will eventually be released: “We should help them find confidence and meaningful work to support themselves and their families, rebuild lives, and contribute to the well being of our community.”

The issue of inmate education is coming under scrutiny for federal prisons as well.

In May, the U.S. House overwhelmingly approved rehabilitation measures – including education and job training – for inmates so they are less likely to commit crimes after their release. Backed by senior White House adviser Jared Kushner, the so-called First Step Act would earmark $50 million a year for five years to expand those opportunities. But that would apply only to a small share of 184,000 federal inmates – which are in turn a fraction of nearly 2 million prisoners in state prisons or jail. Some reform advocates say it falls short of broader reform measures announced in 2016 by the U.S. Department of Justice that has since been tabled by the Federal Bureau of Prisons.

Until the 1990s, Congress funded college for more than 20,000 U.S. inmates through Pell grants, part of the same program that helps low-income students across the nation afford an undergraduate degree. The prison program offered through Jackson College grew to be the largest in the nation.

But in 1994 – amid fear over rising crime rates – Congress killed the prison portion of Pell funding as part of the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act. As one congressman put it at the time: “Law-abiding students have every right to be outraged when a Pell grant for a policeman’s child is cut but a criminal that the officer sends to prison can still get a big check.”

According to the Washington Post, funding for inmates comprised less than 1 percent of $5.3 billion in overall Pell funding in 1994.

President Obama reversed that ban in 2015 with an executive order authorizing grants for up to 12,000 inmates nationally through 67 approved colleges and universities. That included Jackson College, Delta College near Bay city and Mott Community College in Flint. With authorization for 1,475 inmates, Michigan was behind only Texas at 5,544 inmates.

Qualifying inmates must be within five years of their earliest release date and with no disciplinary record within the past six months. The maximum individual yearly grant is $5,920.

In addition, in 2012 the G. Robert Cotton Correctional Facility in Jackson established a self-funded program of college courses for inmates who could pay tuition fees. It enrolls another 75 inmates.

Yet another college program, a privately-funded collaboration between Calvin College and Calvin Theological Seminary in Grand Rapids, pays for enrollment for 20 inmates a year at a prison in Ionia. (link to Calvin sidebar)

Of course, college course work is not the only road to success after prison.

In 2016, the Michigan Department of Corrections opened a skilled trades program called Vocational Village at the Richard A. Handlon Correctional Facility in Ionia. It offers training in trades such as auto repair, plumbing and carpentry for about 180 inmates chosen from prisons around the state. It opened a similar training program in 2017 at a prison in Jackson. Prisoners qualify if they are  within two years of their earliest release date and free of misconduct citations.

Prison officials say many of these skilled trade inmates walk out of prison and into a job.

Bobby Beauchamp, the Pell program director at Jackson College, also teaches in the prison program, which offers an Associate of Arts, an Associate in General Studies and a Business Administration Associate in Applied Science.

“I can testify firsthand how serious they are about getting the top grades they can get,” he told Bridge. “At one point, we had 80 percent on the dean’s list.”

Bobby Beauchamp

But with about 575 students in the Jackson prison program, Beauchamp said it is filling less than half of the state’s 1,305 authorized Pell slots for a variety of bureaucratic reasons.

Pell grants generally require that recipients register with Selective Service for a potential military draft, Beauchamp said. That trips up inmates who never did so before they were incarcerated.

“They can appeal that. But it’s a lengthy process,” he said. “It may take anywhere from three to eight months. It’s frustrating.”

Beauchamp said other prisoners have problems because they have no Social Security card or don’t know their number or entered prison under an alias. Still others incurred student debt before they entered prison. Pell regulations require that they arrange a payment plan before they can be accepted into the program – which can lead to further delays.

Still, as Jackson College works through these issues, Beauchamp said he expects to push enrollment to more than 1,100 inmates by early next year.

“Now that we’ve ironed out the wrinkles, we’re expecting to grow,” he said.

Former inmate Kristi Fraga said prison education has given her a second chance at life.

Fraga, 42, was imprisoned at Women’s Huron Valley Correctional Facility in Ypsilanti in 2011. She had been convicted of assault, stealing property and fleeing police, stemming from an incident that year in the Upper Peninsula that Fraga said was tied to persistent drug use. She was paroled last year.

While in prison, Fraga took a series of college courses that she said transformed how she viewed herself.

“I didn’t think I was that smart,” she said.

“I was getting A’s in all the classes. I was kind of surprised.”

Fraga completed her associate degree at Jackson College earlier this spring, and is now working part-time as a tutor in microeconomics and macroeconomics for its Hillsdale campus, as well as a waitress. She hopes to transfer this fall to the University of Michigan-Dearborn in a program that offers financial assistance and support for nontraditional adult learners. Eventually, she said, she’d like to work in the field of criminal justice reform.

“Something clicked in my mind when I was taking those classes,” she said. “It’s changed my life.”

Like what you’re reading in Bridge? Please consider a donation to support our work!

It takes time, money, and hard work to inform Michigan readers and leaders with substantive, in-depth, future-oriented news and analysis. If you value our journalism, please consider a one-time donation or a monthly contribution. It takes just a moment to donate here. Please join the thousands of Bridge readers who are helping grow and sustain our nonprofit, in-depth public service journalism in Michigan.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Matt
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 8:31am

In a our world where half those with college degree end up in jobs that require don't them (and even many of those that say they do require one could be debated) leaving us with with a doubtful investment of time and money let's be careful. Our economy is desperate for craftsmen who know their trade. Everyone should be in favor of individual improvement especially for our ex-cons, but please don't make the sole definition of preparation for your future obtaining a bachelor's degree as we've done for high school.

David Waymire
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 11:09am

Matt, you are completely wrong. Lumina Foundation estimates that in the next 18 months Michigan will need 171,000 new college grads -- and 126,000 persons without a four year degree -- to fill needed jobs. If Michigan needs more "craftsmen" (noting that you left out half the population, which may be a reason why we are short of filling some jobs), then the state's employers should offer more money. The average electrician in our state makes about $60,000, according to the data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which is provided by employers. The average nurse, with a four year degree, earns about $70,000. That's the facts. I wonder how many CEOs are telling their children "don't go to college...become a welder (average pay $38,000)." My bet: Not a single one. Now, if someone wants to be a welder, electrician, etc, then more power to them. But let's not continue with the misinformation campaign saying you are better off NOT going to college if you are capable and interested.

Yvette Baffield
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 9:16am

If they are afforded a college education while in prison on the taxpayers' dime, then why should my daughter and I and countless others have to pay back our loans.

Surely law abiding citizens should receive the same courtesy. Heck, I'll go a little further...why not forgive the educational loan debt of citizens like its forgiven with politicians?

mary therese lemanek
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 9:30am

Pell Grants are not loans. They are grants that do not have to be repaid by anyone, incarcerated or not unless:
You withdrew early from the program for which the grant was given to you.
Your enrollment status changed in a way that reduced your eligibility for your grant (for instance, if you switch from full-time enrollment to part-time, your grant amount will be reduced).
You received outside scholarships or grants that reduced your need for federal student aid.

Pell grants are income based. If your family income qualified her, I hope she too applied.

Steve Williams
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 9:38am

Yvette, I understand your point of view, but I believe you are mixing apples and oranges. The prisoners are getting Pell grants, if the article is accurate. They are not getting a free ride to the extent that college costs more than the Pell grant amount. If you or your daughter qualified for Pell grants you would have been treated the same. Forgiveness of student loans is a different topic.

mary therese lemanek
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 9:22am

Cutting the funding does a tremendous disservice to the inmates and to the larger community. If all you care about is $$, it is far more cost effective to provide education and training before someone is paroled than after. Incarceration should not mean the loss of all rights and supports particularly when society demands that these men and women become responsible, contributing members upon release.

Kevin Grand
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 10:02am

"Michigan inmates may lose college funding. That’s bad news for the rest of us. "

So, let me get this straight: Most Michigan Colleges are pricing themselves out of the reach of their customers.

Those who can still afford it either have done so either through their parents saving enough since before they were even born or by personally taking on an amount of debt that essentially negates any benefit of attending college in the first place provided they find a well-paying job in their field of study (if not, then its much worse).

With a trade school, students fare better without the massive amount of debt.

But if you steal, deal in drugs or assault someone (just for starters), we're supposed to be happy that the government will step in and essentially pay their full freight?!?

If there is any "bad news" in this story at all, it's the fact that this program even exists in the first place.

David Waymire
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 11:13am

Kevin, you should know that colleges are raising tuition because the state has dramatically cut its support for college students. In 2000, the state invested about $1.9 billion in higher education. If that had been increased by inflation, it would be about $2.7 billion. Instead, we are at $1.6 billion. So you can see, $1 billion of the higher tuition charges are due to tax cuts and their related cuts to the state budget, particularly for higher education, imposed by lawmakers and governors. Tax cuts have consequences.

Kevin Grand
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 7:58pm

I cannot help but wonder how it was that colleges survived for as long as they did before they pulled themselves a seat up to the public trough.

Case in point: U of M existed at least 20 years before Michigan even became a state. I'd be more than happy to cite other examples where colleges and universities pre-dated the states which they now call home.

And regarding the cuts to "their" funding, it was no huge secret that "their" funding was going to get cut after Granholm tanked Michigan's economy.

If they couldn't (wouldn't) adjust their spending in that time-frame with the information readily available to everyone, they have no one else to blame but themselves.

So, David, precisely WHAT tax cuts are you referring to?

My income tax wasn't decreased. My gas taxes had gone up. Ditto for plates.

My property taxes didn't get reduced very much (thank you creative assessors), and the last time I checked, the sales tax hasn't changed.

So where is this mysterious "tax cut" to which you refer?

Doug L
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 10:44am

We spend a ton of money to incarcerate people, at a rate higher than the rest of the world. It's foolish not to spend enough to help rehabilitate. We all gain.

Erwin Haas
Tue, 07/10/2018 - 6:57pm

There are factors here that artificially increase the cost and availability of college credits and degrees in Michigan's prisons.
They are not allowed internet access. All of the teaching has to be done in person, by instructors, guys from Calvin who go out to Ionia and enter one or another of their half dozen prisons. Not economical.
An alternative is internet access linking to any of the MOOCs. Try Harvard or MIT.
Or the classes could be on storage devices and loaded onto computers in labs where students could work at their own pace and take exams supervised by standard CLEP protocols at intervals during the year.
So the cost impediment could be overcome by using some imagination and maybe technology. If some think it worthwhile, they should pursue these other avenues.

Adeline M
Wed, 07/11/2018 - 1:49pm

Education is transformative! Programs like this should continue to be funded.