Michigan income growth hindered by lack of college graduates

The incomes of Michigan workers took a big hit during the Great Recession. Incomes have recovered somewhat in recent years, but Michigan has not returned to its high-wage reputation during past decades of manufacturing might.

The state’s workers once made substantially more than the average American household (6 percent more in 2000); they’re now making almost 10 percent less – or about $425 a month less. The cause: loss of nearly 300,000 manufacturing jobs, many well-paying. And the jobs that have been created have largely been in the service sector and pay just over two-thirds, on average, as what a factory job pays.

Still, Michigan incomes have started to grow again during the multi-year recovery after the Great Recession. Total statewide personal income ($424 billion) and per capita income ($42,812) in 2015 were both about 13 percent higher than in 2010.

Re-shaped jobs market: From 2000 to 2016, Michigan lost nearly 300,000 manufacturing jobs while adding lower-paying service jobs. The radical reshaping of the state economy helped drop median household income. In Michigan, it's now $5,125 below the national median of $57,617 in 2016, or $427 a month less

Michigan Lags in College Grads

In the United States, 31.3 percent of adults have a bachelor's degree or higher, a level of education that typically brings hundreds of thousands of dollars of additional lifelong income. Michigan's rate, 28.3 percent, has it ranked in the bottom third of the country.

Rank and percent with bachelor's degree or higher

#1 District of Columbia (56.8%)

#2 Massachusetts (42.7%)

#3 Colorado (39.9%)

#4 Maryland (39.3%)

#5 Connecticut (38.6%)

#36 Michigan (28.3%)

Source: U.S. Census 2016 American Community Survey data.

Path forward

Other states with more diverse economies have been able to embrace the information age and take advantage of the higher-paying jobs in technology and financial and professional services.

Take Massachusetts and Minnesota. Both have far more educated workforces compared to Michigan and the nation. Nearly 43 percent of Massachusetts adults have a college degree, as do nearly 35 percent of adult Minnesotans. In Michigan, the number is 28.3 percent, well below the national figure of 31.3.

(For perspective: If Michigan’s had the same college grad rate as Minnesota, the state would have 439,000 more college grads; if it had Massachusetts’ rate, it’d have nearly a million more grads.)

Here’s how that plays out: While Michigan’s median household income was $5,000 below the national average of $57,627 in 2016, Minnesota’s was nearly $8,000 higher. Massachusetts’ is nearly $18,000 higher. Michigan is now ranked 34th in income, down from 24th a decade earlier.

Related economic coverage from our 2018 Michigan Issue Guide

That’s because Massachusetts and Minnesota have far fewer factory workers and more in service-oriented jobs like finance, an industry where average weekly wages in Massachusetts ($2,500) and Minnesota ($1,673) are far higher than that same sector commands in Michigan ($1,298 a week).

Job losses, stagnant wages triggered a poverty increase

The impact extended beyond those working, many of whom were working for less money, to pushing many more into poverty. The poverty rate in Michigan soared from 13.2 percent in 2005 to more than 17 percent in 2011 (Massachusetts and Minnesota never climbed above 12 percent). The Michigan poverty rate remained above 16 percent in 2016.

Beyond the poor and unemployed, the working poor grew markedly. According to the United Ways of Michigan, the percentage of working families who struggled to meet the basic costs of living grew substantially. More than 950,000 Michigan households have wage earners, but are considered working poor with few assets and constrained incomes.

Pain, progress not evenly distributed

Across the state, the minority population was harder hit by the Great Recession. The poverty rate among African-Americans, already high, climbed to more than 36 percent in 2012. That has seen a ripple effect in a number of larger cities, including Detroit, Flint, Muskegon and Saginaw, which have larger African-American populations.

In Detroit and Flint, more than half of children under 18 live in poverty and more than a third of all residents. Median household income in Flint was $24,863 and it was $25,764 for Detroit in 2016, according to the U.S. Census’ American Community Survey. Yet in other parts of the state, incomes are far higher, like in Ann Arbor ($55,990), Grand Rapids ($40,355) and in Metro Detroit suburbs like Plymouth ($75,949), Warren ($43,523) and Bloomfield Hills ($172,768).

Again, education is a factor: In Bloomfield Hills and Ann Arbor, more than 70 percent of adults have a college degree; in Plymouth, it’s 54.4 percent and in Grand Rapids it’s 31.6 percent. But in Detroit just 11.5 percent of adults have a college degree and in Flint it’s 9.7 percent.

KEEP DIGGING: MORE INFORMATION ON MICHIGAN INCOMES:

Explore the Facts & Issues Guide:

At A Glance

Slideshows…

Education & Talent

Economy & Prosperity

Quality of Life

Government & Reform

Who We Are & The Facts on Our Facts

Comment Form

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Matt
Tue, 01/23/2018 - 3:29pm

Once again .. Does a more prosperous growing economy produce and retain more college grads or does having more college grads lead to a prosperous economy? This is a significant distinction. The author seems to imply and support policies cranking out diplomas without evidence to support which side of the cart he has hitched his horse.

Jesse
Sun, 01/28/2018 - 11:08am

That is the question that should be asked. I'm a business owner and find that college degrees really don't mean much to my company in the end. Colleges have become diploma mills producing automatons that can regurgitate some professor's personal beliefs, but doesn't have a clue as to how to work in manner or form. They can tell you that they want 60K to start very easily, but ask them to get to work on time...and they believe you're asking just too much....and let a snowflake fall and you can watch them drift inexorably toward California....Colleges have oversold themselves in an effort to become bigger and more powerful in garnering more money from gov't in order to graduate more students with less understanding of the real world. You list Minnesota as an example of how things should be done...Minnesota has more economic problems than you can shake a stick at...taxation is horrid there....So the gov't pays out incentives to retain and attract companies....Look a little deeper at their economic condition than just a superficial review and things begin to look much darker...Michigan just doesn't have a friendly environment for anything. All one has to do is dodge the potholes on the roads to see how this state has been ruined in the last three or four decades....And look at any city in Michigan to see the mess that we have now. Michigan Economic Development is a joke...There is no need to ask what has it accomplished?? The answer is all around us. The proper questions have not and will not be addressed by either political party.