Jail official: State funding for mental health will reduce crime and save money

Troy Goodnough is a 28-year veteran of the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office, where he is Major of Jail Operations

The lack of mental health institutions in the State of Michigan continues to deliver a devastating blow to citizens who suffer from mental illness. The absence of sound judgement can lead people to commit crimes and end up in our local jails, which are ill-equipped and lacking the necessary resources to provide quality care to people suffering from mental illness. The influx of these inmates causes overcrowding, significantly limiting the number of beds available for more violent inmates, and challenging jails’ ability to provide a safe and secure environment.

Having over 27 years of experience in law enforcement with the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office and currently Major of Jail Operations, I see firsthand the effects that a lack of adequate mental health treatment has on our inmate population and recidivism.

Related: Snyder’s Michigan: Fewer prisoners, less prison spending 
Doug DeVos: Criminal justice reform is the right thing to do, for all of Michigan​

I’ve seen examples where inmates with mental health challenges damage jail property and disrupt the tranquility of their housing unit; at times, this has led other inmates to assault these prisoners. The lack of long-term treatment facilities also has forced inmates to remain in jail for a significant amount of time while waiting for a bed at a long-term treatment facility due to the lack of funding or additional beds, limiting the available bed space for inmates who are a threat to society.

Three decades in the making

What led us to the epidemic we face today?

Historically, the State of Michigan was responsible for operating the mental health institutions designed to treat members of our community who suffered from serious mental health illness. However, beginning in 1990, the state began closing state-run mental health institutions to balance the budget and changed the model for treating mental illness.

As a result, the people who relied on state-run facilities to treat their illness lacked access to treatment. Compounding the lack of access to institutional care, the state failed to fully support alternative, local services via county mental health organizations. This lack of mental health treatment caused some people’s health to deteriorate to the point their ability to differentiate between right and wrong was challenged and they committed crimes, which caused them to enter the criminal justice system. As an example, an inmate named John, who suffers from mental illness, was released from the Monroe County Jail only to be arrested again three months later after committing another minor crime. In the time between his release and his most recent arrest, his mental health declined significantly from a lack of long-term treatment.

Following adjudication and incarceration, these inmates are released back into society,  without a treatment plan or the resources to meet their basic needs such as housing or transportation. Ultimately they reoffend and end up back in jail, and the cycle repeats itself.

A program with promise  

In 2015, the Monroe County Sheriff’s Office partnered with the Monroe County Community Mental Health Authority and secured a grant to pilot a mental health jail diversion program. The grant provided $125,000 (raised to $247,000 by 2018) and allowed us to hire a clinician and peer staff support to carry out these seven steps:

  • Identify inmates with mental health illness through a series of questions asked during the booking process.
  • Provide these inmates with treatment while incarcerated.
  • Provide the inmates with the coping skills necessary to be a productive member of society upon their release and not a burden on society.
  • Ensure continuity of care for their mental illness after their release.
  • Ensure housing upon their release.
  • Ensure their transportation needs are met upon release.
  • Develop a mental health court.

During the first six months of the pilot program, over 2,500 inmates were booked into the jail, with 990 of the 2,500 (40 percent) indicating they suffered from mental illness, which allowed them to receive some form of treatment while incarcerated.

An early, positive trend

Prior to the pilot program, the recidivism rate was 32 percent. After the first year of the pilot, recidivism declined to 29 percent. While this is promising, the lack of long-term treatment facilities continues to challenge our efforts to reduce recidivism and preserve beds for the most violent inmates.

In 2015, the daily cost to house an inmate in a Michigan prison was $96.30 a day or $35,149 a year (In our jail in Monroe, daily rates run about $62). For this mental health program to pay for itself, we would need fewer inmates to reoffend, to the tune of 10 fewer jail beds a year.

Michigan can break the cycle by establishing a best practice model for utilization by all local corrections institutions. The model must include collaboration and team building among law enforcement, the judiciary, community mental health and most importantly the governing body of each local jurisdiction and the state.

As it stands, the State of Michigan plans to reduce funding for our jail diversion program in 2019. The initial program was only slated for three years. At this time no legislation is being proposed for an extension, but I am encouraging my local legislators to pursue the idea of continuing funding and even increasing it so all 79 local jails in Michigan can take advantage of this diversion program.

We need your help to resolve the mental health epidemic facing citizens in your community and inmates in our correctional institutions. These people are your neighbors, friends and family members. Call your local legislators and encourage them to support funding for mental health jail diversion programs in every jail across Michigan. Tell them to reopen psychiatric institutions to treat our loved ones who suffer from mental illness and prepare them to be productive members of society rather than a burden.

Bridge welcomes guest columns from a diverse range of people on issues relating to Michigan and its future. The views and assertions of these writers do not necessarily reflect those of Bridge or The Center for Michigan. Bridge does not endorse any individual guest commentary submission.

If you are interested in submitting a guest commentary, please contact Monica WilliamsClick here for details and submission guidelines.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


George Tanner
Wed, 12/20/2017 - 12:44pm

Very important towards an even greater need to find corrections for mental ill people. Its a start!

Denise Brooks
Wed, 12/20/2017 - 1:23pm

Great article.

Wed, 12/20/2017 - 7:22pm

Thank you! This is a topic that has been shoved to a back burner or completely ignored for far too long. People need to realize not addressing this issue does not make it go away. We have to change the system or we all suffer the consequences.

Thu, 12/21/2017 - 10:08am

Great article. Will share and get the word out.

Mon, 12/25/2017 - 5:21am

This is a good program, but the mental health laws in Michigan are the REAL problem. There's such bad corruption in the monopoly system with authorities embezzling funds that the problem will persist until competition is opened and indigent patients can get care. Jackson/Hillsdale's Mental Health authority has lost millions for years now on bad real estate investments, then got an illegal millage that illegally extended their contract another ten years then bought an ADDITIONAL huge junk building that will lose millions more. The state won't stop them, and patients have been denied care by the hundreds for years now, with more and more executives and travel taking place of direct patient care. It's enforcement against mental health authorities that is REALLY needed. They closed psychiatric facilities for the same reason, patient abuse, abuse of funds, and the need to scrap it rather than fix it since it got THAT out of control. This state is disgusting, they don't watch the agencies that care for the vulnerable, and taxpayers are simply getting robbed, just like what's going on in the VAs throughout this country.