September 11, 2018
In the race for Michigan governor, there are sharp differences between GOP Attorney General Bill Schuette and Democratic former Senate Minority Leader Gretchen Whitmer on the Affordable Care Act, Medicaid expansion, Medicaid work requirements and other health issues. Here are the highlights:
Related Michigan Obamacare stories:
- Wobbly but upright, Obamacare still standing in Michigan
- Truth Squad | Does Bill Schuette care if sick people can get insurance?
- Timeline: President Trump’s efforts to repeal, dismantle Obamacare
- Opinion | Reports of Obamacare’s demise are greatly exaggerated, especially in Michigan
- Truth Squad | Michigan Democratic Party attacks Bill Schuette on health care
- Health care in rural Michigan communities suffering, despite Obamacare
AFFORDABLE CARE ACT
Bill Schuette
As Michigan Attorney General, Bill Schuette has steadfastly opposed the Affordable Care Act, marshalling the resources of his office to file suit against the law, often in tandem with conservative attorneys general from other states.
- In 2011, Schuette joined a suit to block Obamacare, saying: “I will fight Obamacare tooth-and-nail to protect our citizens from this constitutional overreach."
- In 2013, Schuette opposed Michigan’s expansion of Medicaid known as Healthy Michigan ‒ a facet of the Affordable Care Act. His spokesperson said: "He believes that the federal government is not a reliable or steady funder and the long term fiscal costs of government expansion of health care is not sustainable and will result in huge costs to Michigan taxpayers."
- Schuette reaffirmed his stand against the ACA in March with a tweet: “The Affordable Care Act violated the very first principle of medicine: Do no harm. When I'm governor we will work to repeal & replace Obamacare.”
But since vanquishing his Republican primary rivals in early August, his campaign has been more restrained in its rhetoric, including being more equivocal about his previously stated opposition to Healthy Michigan.
Asked by Bridge Magazine on Aug. 23 if Schuette would sign a bill repealing Healthy Michigan, campaign spokesman John Sellek declined to answer the question directly. Instead, Sellek stated: “As governor, Bill will review all spending programs that are currently enacted under Michigan law.”
Gretchen Whitmer
Whitmer is an unreserved supporter of the ACA. She issued this statement to Bridge: “Everyone deserves access to quality, affordable health care and the ACA established guaranteed coverage for pre-existing conditions and expanded essential coverage benefits that many people didn't have before.”
- While the Trump administration has cut back federal funding to market and help consumers navigate health care options, Whitmer said she’d consider strategies like that of New York, which invested $7 million in ads for Obamacare and boosted enrollment by 4.2 percent: “As governor, I would be open to using marketing strategies like information campaigns to make sure Michiganders know where to purchase affordable health coverage that protects pre-existing conditions.”
- Whitmer joined 11 Democrats and eight Republicans in 2013 in voting to expand Medicaid for low-income Michigan residents under the ACA. She told Bridge in a statement: “As Senate Democratic Leader, I worked across the aisle to expand Medicaid to over 680,000 Michiganders through Healthy Michigan. As governor, I'll take on Schuette, Trump and Republicans who threaten our health coverage, protect people with pre-existing conditions and work to make healthcare more affordable for all Michigan families.”
COVERAGE FOR PRE-EXISTING CONDITIONS
Enactment of the ACA brought with it the guarantee that people with pre-existing medical conditions could obtain health insurance coverage.
Bill Schuette
- Schuette has said, going back to at least 2014, that he supports coverage for individuals with pre-existing conditions and allowing children to remain on their parents’ insurance until age 26 ‒ both popular elements of the ACA.
- His (mostly Democratic) critics accuse Schuette of hypocrisy, however, arguing that he repeatedly tried to strike down the ACA without presenting a concrete plan for protecting chronically ill patients had the law been swept aside.
- Truth Squad: Michigan Democratic Party attacks Bill Schuette on healthcare
- It’s worth noting that Schuette opted not to join 20 other states in a more recent federal suit that argues the ACA forces “an unconstitutional and irrational regime” on the states and should be invalidated. In June, the Trump administration weighed in on the lawsuit and argued that as of Jan. 1, 2019, protections for people with pre-existing conditions should be struck down.
Gretchen Whitmer
Whitmer’s backing of the ACA underscores her support for its mandate that insurance companies may not discriminate against those with pre-existing conditions.
MEDICAID WORK REQUIREMENTS
Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder signed a measure in June requiring certain Medicaid recipients in Michigan to work a prescribed number of hours or risk losing coverage.
Bill Schuette
Campaign spokesman Sellek said: “Bill supports Medicaid work requirements for able-bodied people.”
Gretchen Whitmer
Whitmer opposes Medicaid work requirements, stating: “This legislation will take health care away from tens of thousands of Michigan families, which will hurt our whole economy. By supporting this shameful legislation, Bill Schuette has made it crystal clear that he's not on the side of working families.”
OPIOID CRISIS
Bill Schuette
- Called for a combination of drug awareness programs, resources for addicts and families, aggressive law enforcement and strong treatment plans, in a 2017 guest column for the Detroit Free Press.
- Joined other state attorneys general in urging health insurers to support alternatives to opioid treatment for pain including non-opioid medications, physical therapy, acupuncture, massage and chiropractic care.
- Backs retail stores hosting state disposal boxes collecting unused prescription drugs as a new tool to fight the opioid epidemic.
Gretchen Whitmer
- As governor, Whitmer said she would issue a state of emergency over the opiate epidemic. In a November policy speech, she said she wants to “develop the best opioid treatment centers in the country” and called for greater funding for hospitals and medical centers in northern Michigan, where rural counties have been hit hard.
- She also advocated for public awareness initiatives and greater mental health funding, and asked pharmaceutical companies to lower prices for newer, less addictive opiates.
She said she would partner with law enforcement and pharmacies to expand drug take-back programs and support investment in drug treatment courts to “make sure that people with addictions could get connected to treatment, instead of going to jail.”
Comments
I must have missed Libertarian major party candidate Bill Gelineau’s contribution to this exposition. I’m running for Michigan’s 26th senate district so have my own platform which I suspect tracks Bill’s closely.
The Affordable Care Act is above all, not affordable. It was written by the insurance, hospital and pharmaceutical industries to insulate themselves from the marketplace. Costs have skyrocketed.
First, the insurance coverage which has purportedly been extended to an additional 30 million Americans. But the premiums for most Americans have skyrocketed and push many families into poverty or bankruptcy. The most telling observation is that the newly insured and those forced to buy insurance for coverage that they could never use, are unable to get medical care because they can’t afford the co-pays. These-now constructively cut off from medical care-are never counted because the victims suffer in silence and exposing their numbers might cause the political elites and their media lapdogs discomfort. I propose that 50 million Americans have lost medical care in the net. Dispute my numbers if you dare.
Second, the hospitals continue to buy up physician practices, drug and medical equipment outlets and smaller rivals. They use these monopsony and monopoly powers to dominate their market places. They use arcane billing codes to defraud private payers, medicare and medicaid and even insurance companies, and that ain’t small potatoes.
Third, drug companies’ prices have become insane. Allopurinol was around when I was in medical school in the 60s. It cost 10 dollars a month in the 80s. I just noticed that in now costs 57 dollars a month. Usually making something for 50 years becomes cheaper.
I recently heard about “T CAR” the latest thing in cancer treatment. It has an astonishing cure rate, but 40% of folks die of the treatment, it costs 500,000 per person and the patient’s immune system is destroyed. They need immunoglobulin shots for life and are subject to lethal infections caused by brewer’s yeast or even bread mold.
McCain, T. Kennedy, Paul Henry lived an extra 6 months with brain cancers- steroidal, headachy, confused, and constantly in their doctor’s offices and hospital. Where is the joy?
What has boosted this price except the power of the drug company to charge what the insurance companies, the ones that have no reason to worry about costs, will pay?
I will note that Obama care came into full force in 2013 and that the US lifespans dropped for the first time the next year; they have continued to decline. Free medical care, so dear to the hearts of our betters, is killing us.
We Libertarians take the long view. Medical care costs (You’ll have to dig around this long but very detailed article) were low and were about 4% of the GDP in 1965 and people liked what they got. Then came Medicare and Medicaid and costs went into the stratosphere, 8.4% in 1983 and now approaching 17% of GDP after Bush 43’s drug bennies and Obamacare. Enough people were angry enough to eject the ACA perpetrators in 2016.
I’m running for Michigan’s 26th Senate and Bill for governor and we are not as inert as the Democrats and Republicans here seem to be. There are things that we can do to cut medical costs (the only real goal here) at the state level.
Medical Certificate of Need regulations add 10% to costs and should be abolished. We can also encourage insurance companies from out of state to compete here. The auto insurance rates include health insurance with the most outlandish benefits forcing our insurance rates in Michigan to be the second highest in the land. We can open up competition for delivery of medical care by allowing all sorts of paraprofessionals to practice medicine.
But good luck in passing these reforms; the monied interests will try to destroy us. They already own Schuette and Whitmer and channel the conversation at Bridgmi into the wasteland of what should not be a concern of our government in the first place.
Libertarians continue to live in fantasy land where soulless corporations are good actors and the free market solves all...
Your article does not include information from all the Governor candidates.
Bill Gellineau and Jennifer Kurland are also on the ballot.
I, too, was more than disappointed that Third Party candidates were omitted. Jennifer V. Kurland is the Green Party of Michigan nominee and supports health care for all. As the Greens' candidate for State Board of Education, so do I. "Poverty is the biggest obstacle in education," and that includes no real access to adequate food and clean water, much less health care. The U.S. Constitution states that a purpose of government is to "promote the general welfare," (before "welfare" was made to be a negative word). A healthy population makes for a strong country.
The opiate crisis will continue to explode as long as the Republicans control the White House and Congress. What has been done since Trump was elected? Nothing. First it was Jared's job (once he brought peace to the Middle East) now it's Kelly Ann Conway's job (!?).
Ironic since many Trump supporting states have the biggest opiate populations - Trump and the GOP don't care really but like ignorant people to think they're doing something.
Schuette will do nothing and the crisis will continue to grow.
Hey Bridge,
If you havn’t heard yet, there are more than 2 candidates/2 political parties making a serious run to be Michigan’s next Governor. You claim to be in search of the “truth” when it comes to these candidates. Why do you continue to ignore the other alternatives that Michigan voters have in 2018? The blatant omission of Bill Gelineau from your coverage makes me think you are more corporate than you would have your readers believe.