Guest commentary: EAA won’t answer simple questions about its finances (UPDATED)

By Rep. Ellen Lipton

Files released

Rep. Lipton's office reports that the EAA has responded to her FOIA request. The 31 documents released by the EAA can be viewed at

As I watched House Republicans rush to expand the experimental Education Achievement Authority statewide last month, I wondered if legislators who supported House Bill 4369 remembered their high school science classes. Particularly, I wondered if they recalled the scientific method — the process of developing a hypothesis, testing it and drawing a rational conclusion.

High school science classes teach us that when you follow the scientific method, you're more likely to arrive at solid, evidence-based knowledge. Ignore the scientific method, and there's no telling what kind of mess you might make.

Since the start of this school year, 15 schools in Detroit have been operated under the EAA, a board of hand-picked gubernatorial appointees enabled to make sweeping changes in these schools. Without waiting to see how the EAA performed in its first year, Republicans are declaring the experiment a success and are ready expand its authority.

Who knows what kind of mess that will make?

Who knows, that is, except the children attending these EAA schools? While Republican lawmakers forged ahead to expand the governor's authority, I took time to listen to students.

What I heard concerned me.

At Detroit's Mumford High School, students said their school has become a prison. Computers replaced teachers and unchallenging software programs replaced books. Classroom discussion is virtual nonexistent and many special needs students may not be receiving extra help and accommodation to ensure a good education. Kids no longer felt safe in their environment.

I took the next step to get more facts about the EAA to share with members of the Senate, before they rush to judgment, as well as with the public. I filed a Freedom of Information Act request. In it, I posed simple and straightforward questions, such as:

-What is the EAA’s budget?
-How many millions of dollars is it getting from private sector foundations?
-If the EAA is expanded, is there a plan to ensure that the new schools brought into the EAA have access to the millions of dollars over and above the regular state support that goes to other public schools?
-If not, what will happen to those schools?
-Who is teaching at the EAA?
-How many teachers are considered “highly qualified” by state standards?
-How many have master’s degrees?
-How many have certification in the areas in which they are teaching, as required by state law?
-How much turnover has there been already?
-What is the enrollment of the EAA, and how has that enrollment changed from day one?
-What is the enrollment of special education students, today compared to the beginning of the year?
-Are special education students receiving all the services that they need?
-What is the student-teacher ratio in various classes?
-How many counselors and social workers does the EAA have in each school?

The EAA has delayed for more time and demanded that I pay for getting answers to these basic questions. I’ve started that process, because even if the leadership of the House of Representatives isn’t interested in these facts, I am.

The Michigan Senate deserves this information before voting on giving the EAA authority to take over more schools. Let’s get the facts, so we all can judge whether the EAA is a solution to education problems, or yet another top-down bureaucratic exercise that leaves our students worse off than they are today.

The EAA experiment hasn't yet ended, but so far, there's little to suggest the ending will be a happy one. I hope that others in the Legislature will join me in the search for strategies that work. Our children deserve it.

Bridge welcomes guest columns from a diverse range of people on issues relating to Michigan and its future. The views and assertions of these writers do not necessarily reflect those of Bridge or The Center for Michigan. Bridge does not endorse any individual guest commentary submission.

If you are interested in submitting a guest commentary, please contact Monica WilliamsClick here for details and submission guidelines.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


Stephen Boyle
Mon, 04/22/2013 - 5:39pm
Perhaps EAA could find the financing to handle the requests by reducing their advertising budget. Although perhaps those advertisements are sponsored as a gift from certain investors. Even as gifted services it would be appropriate to know how much money is floating through this experiment in education.
Tue, 04/23/2013 - 4:55am
Can you file a FOIA (Freedom of Information Act) to get some of this information?
Tue, 04/23/2013 - 7:21am
What do you mean by having to pay to get your questions answered?
Tue, 04/23/2013 - 8:13am
Institutions charge a fee for responding to FOIA questions. It is a great way to discourage the questions.
Kim Hunter
Tue, 04/23/2013 - 11:52am
I assume author is referring to having to pay to process FOIA requests.
Tue, 04/23/2013 - 1:45pm
The Bridge has posted an important guest column by Rep. Ellen Lipton. Thank you for talking to the current students; your questions are fair, wise, and objective. Please report back to the Center for Michigan if you receive the answers to your questions.
dan lobert
Tue, 04/23/2013 - 5:26pm
please let me know how much money is needed and we will begin the work of fundraising immediately
Chuck Jordan
Thu, 04/25/2013 - 9:23am
I'm sorry, but I think the only relevant questions are whether these students including special needs students are receiving the kind of broad based education they deserve and are they doing better (not just on high stakes tests) in these schools than their old ones. If so, let them show it and continue. If not, try something else.
Thu, 04/25/2013 - 11:20pm
Maybe I misunderstood, but it doesn't appear that the FOIA documents are posted (yet) on Rep. Cogen Lipton's publications page. I do see the back and forth with the EAA around the FOIA requests, and that by itself is pretty interesting. Am I missing something or is the link pointing to the wrong location?
Chuck Jordan
Sun, 04/28/2013 - 6:43pm
If you haven't, you should look at Michigan Radios 3 part reporting of this issue. I heard an interview with Rep. Lipton on Michigan radio and it broke my heart. Those poor students. Being taught and tested on Of Mice and Men without actually reading it, is not teaching.
Earl Newman
Tue, 04/30/2013 - 10:55am
It used to be that if someone wanted information about school spending and other performance data all one had to do was contact the local school district offices, where they were obligated by law to disclose such data to the public. Alternatively, one could call on the state department of public instruction, charged by law with collecting and disseminating essential data. Now it looks as though state public education policy is to hide as much data as possible in separate agencies, and to make it as hard as possible for anyone to find out what is going on. Representative Lipton alone, as it seems, among our elected representatives has stood up for the public's right to know. She deserves our thanks and our support.