MSU trustee defends Engler hire despite past differences with governor

MSU Trustee Dianne Byrum offers her first extended interview on some of the board’s controversial decisions in the wake of the Larry Nassar sexual abuse scandal at the school.

On a normal day, Michigan State University trustee Dianne Byrum said she might get an email or two or her MSU email account.

These days, it’s more like a hundred.

“I don’t really count,” Byrum said of the emails, which range from brusque “You-should-resign” missives to constructive ideas for how to move MSU forward from the Larry Nassar sexual abuse scandal.

Related: MSU Interim President John Engler was dismissive of sexual assault claims as governor

In her first extended interview since the scandal produced high-profile resignations at MSU, Byrum, a Democrat, said she stands by John Engler’s hiring as interim president. This despite revelations by Bridge that Engler, as governor, in 1998 discounted sexual assault claims by some Michigan women prison inmates as “baseless” and “without merit.”

More than a decade after Engler rejected the validity of the claims, the State of Michigan paid out $100 million as part of a class-action that had grown to include 500 abused prisoners.

“I disagreed with his decisions. He was wrong on that,” said Byrum, a former Democratic state representative and senator who came into office at the same time as the Republican governor in 1991, and went on to become the first female Democratic House caucus leader. She and Engler were on opposing sides of many issues throughout the 1990s.

Still, Byrum added: “I do believe at this point in time that John Engler will serve the university well as interim president. I think he can help make some of the changes necessary.”

If not, Byrum said, she will speak up.

“I am serious about culture change on campus. If I disagree with John Engler, I will be vocal about it.”

Bridge Magazine reached out to the seven other MSU trustees asking for comment on Engler’s appointment, but did not hear back from six. Trustee Brian Mosallam declined comment to Bridge.

But Mosallam publicly expressed some misgivings about Engler even though he voted for him.  

Mosallam told a crowd of hundreds of MSU students and faculty Thursday he did not agree with the board's decision to select Engler as interim president. But he said he voted for him "for the sake of unification, I agreed to vote with the majority."

According to accounts, one attendee yelled, "You're a coward."

A graduate student addressed Mosallam and said that Engler had "refused to allow investigators of sexual assault at women's prisons."

"You had a choice on the matter. 'Yes,' 'no,' or 'abstain.' And you chose to vote 'yes.' I'll never look at you the same again."

In a unanimous vote earlier this week, the embattled board turned to Engler as a steadying figure to steer the university amid rising criticism that MSU had failed to protect girls and young women from sexual abuse by MSU sports doctor Nassar, even after some girls complained about Nassar’s treatments.

Nassar was sentenced Jan. 24 to 40-to-175 years in prison, after more than 150 women and girls said in court he sexually abused them over two decades. The same day, MSU President Lou Anna Simon announced her resignation and, two days later, athletic director Mark Hollis stepped down.

(Nassar is back in another Michigan court this week, where an additional 65 women were scheduled to speak against him at his sentencing hearing.)

“He said there would be more transparency, better accountability,” Byrum said of Engler. “That’s what we are looking for to put Michigan State University on course.”

Byrum said she also disagreed with the former governor’s support for a measure to block prisoners from seeking civil rights protections under state law.

In late 1999, Engler and the Legislature successfully pushed through an amendment to the state’s Elliott-Larsen Civil Rights Act that would preclude prison inmates from seeking state civil rights protections, a move the ACLU noted made Michigan the only state in the nation that stripped inmates of such rights. Byrum voted against it. The law was later struck down as unconstitutional.

Byrum said that while she supports Engler’s appointment, she regrets waiting so long to recommend Simon step down as MSU president.

Byrum was the second trustee to do so, four days after Mitch Lyons said Simon should go. Simon would announce her resignation hours after Byrum called for it.

Before she went public, Byrum said she was convinced she could work from the inside to persuade other trustees and the president herself there was no other choice but for Simon to leave.

“I was trying to work internally to bring the board and the president along to the realization that she should resign. I learned from that mistake.

“I was trying to work internally when I should have been much louder publicly.”

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


Sun, 02/04/2018 - 1:32am

I'm sorry for the Board Members who refuse to accept that Engler has two strikes against his leadership record as being unfair to the women in Michigan.
First he cost Michigan $100 million in the class action lawsuit finding for Michigan Female Prisoner sexual abuse then he passed a law forbidding prisoners their legal rights to protest sexual abuse by prison officials. Later a judge found that law unlawful - that's strike 2 !!!

How blind and incorrectly political can the Board be before they must all resign as part of the ongoing Michigan State University problem???
What father and mother would send their female child into this continuous cauldron of shame for the entire State of Michigan and the Nation's poor and worsening viewpoint for a sick college being made worse by the worst choice of Engler to right the floundering sinking ship?

Bob Dunn
Sun, 02/04/2018 - 9:41am

I believe the Board needs to request Mr. Engler to step aside. The University and all the aggrieved people need someone who has unquestioned integrity. In this hiring the Board reacted too quickly nor did they do their homework.
MSU alumni

Sun, 02/04/2018 - 1:41pm

Ms. Byrum is of the same generation who just swept things under the rug and is now being challenged for its lack of transparency. Politics has destroyed any sense of decency in this state and in this country. I don't know what Ms. Byrum is trying to achieve in this article. Byrum says: “He said there would be more transparency, better accountability,” Byrum said of Engler. “That’s what we are looking for to put Michigan State University on course.” This statement is so out of touch with reality, it is hard to imagine the competency of this woman.

Byrum has not been paying attention to Michigan politics. Michigan ranks in the bottom of the states as far as transparency and accountability, and she is in a position to do something, but has chosen to be "politically correct".

The Board made a mistake and should admit to it. Alumni, parents, students and faculty will win the day on this.

Resign now and save MSU and the state of Michigan any more embarrassment on this issue.

Cindy M.
Sun, 02/04/2018 - 4:01pm

What is wrong with people. This man hates public school education, including secondary education. Has he changed? Think not!

Pat Shalhoob
Fri, 02/09/2018 - 7:01pm