Experts fear Michigan may not have enough hospital beds for coronavirus

Michigan has 25,400 hospital beds, but there are more per capita in southeast Michigan than there are in other parts of the state. (Shutterstock photo)

 

Imagine a hospital where so many patients have flooded the hallways that a doctor has to decide who gets treatment and who doesn’t.

Who gets a ventilator, who doesn’t. Who lives and who dies.

Those decisions — common on a battlefield — have also occurred in China and Italy in the last two months as the new coronavirus spreads worldwide.

And those would be the sorts of decisions that the health care community in Michigan would have to take if its 25,000 hospital beds aren’t enough to handle the anticipated crush of victims of coronavirus, formally known as COVID-19.

Hospital preparedness experts at the University of Michigan are calling for Michigan hospitals to make nearly 8,000 beds available for critical care victims — 50 percent more beds than the state’s plan to handle mass casualty events and other disasters.

In New York City, Mayor Bill de Blasio on Monday called upon the medical community to identify all potential health care facilities, saying the need will be unlike any seen before in the city. In Ohio, Gov. Mike DeWine’s staff has recommended people cancel elective surgery.

In Michigan, the state hospital association has implored its members to prepare for “surge capacity,” which may mean cancelling elective surgery and moving patients eligible for care in a less intense setting.

“This is unprecedented in size, scale and scope,” Dr. Vineet Chopra, chief of hospital medicine at the University of Michigan’s academic medical center, wrote in an email to Bridge. 

Every resource we have is being constrained and pushed as we prepare to take care of a large number of COVID patients.”

Already, U-M’s medical center has canceled elective procedures, Chopra said. He and a colleague have suggested hospitals begin planning to make nearly a third of all beds available. 

That may mean canceling surgeries, turning single rooms into doubles and discharging patients as soon as it’s safe to do so, he said.

Currently, the state disaster plan calls for having 20 percent of all beds available during a surge. Chopra feels the anticipated coronavirus surge requires more beds. 

Chopra said preparations must occur now, before a potential wave of patients hits, so health care professions “don’t have to make hard decisions or major shifts in operations on the fly.”

Those “hard decisions” are spelled out in state of Michigan guidelines on dealing with scarce health care resources. Among them, is to consider the conditions of all patients and make decisions on who has the best chance to survive.

Hospitals, according to a state “toolkit” on preparedness, should have committees of health care workers, including doctors, nurses, an ethicist and an attorney, to weigh several factors when critical resources are limited.

In the end, if the hospital cannot get, for example, a ventilator from another unit or a nearby hospital, it can decide to take it from one patient and give to another if the recipient has “a greater chance of survival, based on objective clinical parameters.”  

Those heart wrenching decisions could be fewer if the virus’ infection rate is slowed by the restrictions being placed on schools and businesses.

That’s why hospitals cheered Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s actions to restrict large groups, said Ruthanne Sudderth, a senior vice president with the Michigan Health and Hospital Association. If the state’s actions slow the rate of infection, then hospitals might have the capacity to treat everyone.

“They are the things we need to take early on to prevent a spike in the [infection rate] curve,” Sudderth said. It is the Italian experience that has everyone worried. “That’s the spike we don’t want here.”

While Michigan’s 25,400 hospital beds is equivalent to 2.5 for every 1,000 people, there are more beds per capita in southeast Michigan than there are in west and northern Michigan.

In some parts of west and northern Michigan, the rate is 1.9 beds per 1,000. Only metro Detroit and parts of the Interstate 75 corridor have rates above 2.5 per 1,000 (the U.S. rate is 2.4 beds per 1,000).

RELATED:

But in Italy, one of the hardest hit places in the world, there are 3.2 beds per 1,000 — 28 percent more than Michigan — and that was insufficient because so many people got sick at the same time, swamping a modern and well-equipped health care system.

Some blame Italy’s high infection rate on its slow move toward limiting travel and social contact. It was only after a couple weeks of rising infections that the country shut down almost all activity.

But infections there have still risen 3,000 a day and deaths have climbed to nearly 400 a day as doctors and other health care workers are putting in 24-hour shifts.

As facilities were quickly overloaded, inflatable tents were propped up to screen patients and hallways were lined with beds because of a dearth of rooms.

That’s why Whitmer and other governors have taken action to limit gatherings and hopefully slow the rate of infection.

Because it’s not just the COVID-19 victims: The fear is there will be so many their treatment will affect the outcomes of other patients, like those who have had a heart attack or stroke or been in a car crash.

Michigan leaders “are doing the responsible thing,” said Brian Peters, the CEO of the Michigan Health and Hospital Association.

MHA officials said members of regional hospital coalitions are working together to identify critical equipment, such as respirators, especially important in fighting COVID-19, and personal protective gear.

Lynn Sutfin, a spokeswoman for the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services department, said hospitals and the regional coalitions are constantly preparing for major events.

“Hospitals routinely exercise medical surge scenarios as part of their preparedness activities,” Sutfin said. “Strategies for diversion are regularly implemented at the local level.”

Michigan Health Watch is made possible by generous financial support from the Michigan Health Endowment Fund, the Michigan Association of Health Plans, and the Michigan Health and Hospital Association. The monthly mental health special report is made possible by generous financial support of the Ethel & James Flinn Foundation. Please visit the Michigan Health Watch 'About' page for more information

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Donald
Tue, 03/17/2020 - 8:19am

With the backing of Michigan Governor and the Dept of Health Ferndale, MI is having a un tested for the viruses contractors UMS 844-741-6248 going from house to house to replace 3 year old RF water meters and to inspect our homes without a warrant!!!
To spread the coronavirus virus?
Both my wife and I are 70 Years old and have health problems. I am a disable veterans. And was in the hospital for 18 days last fall with clasped lungs! I am on two inhalers to help me breathing. This was told to the Ferndale water Dept. and ask them to postpone the inspection until the national emergency is over!! They do not care they need to inspect my home to make sure I am not stealing their water!!! (248) 546-2374
I was told that If we did not let them in to change the water meter and to inspect my home they would turn off our water and condemned our home!
And it seems that Ferndale has the backing og Michigan’s governor, health Dept!!! Flint all over again!!!!

PLombard
Tue, 03/17/2020 - 11:25am

Hospital beds per 1000 people using 2016 data published by OECD:
 Japan 13.3
 South Korea 10.9
 Russia 9.1
 Germany 8.3
 Austria 7.6
 Hungary 7.0
 Lithuania 7.3
 Czech Republic 6.7
 Poland 6.6
 France 6.3
 Slovakia 5.8
 Belgium 5.9
 Latvia 5.8
Hong Kong 5.4
 Luxembourg 5.2
 Estonia 5.0
  Switzerland 4.7
 Slovenia 4.6
 Greece 4.2
 China 3.3
 Finland 4.9
 Australia 3.7
 Norway 3.9
 Netherlands 4.2
 Portugal 3.4
 Italy 3.3
 Iceland 3.2
 Israel 3.1
 Spain 3.0
 Ireland 2.6
 United States 2.9
 Turkey 2.7
 New Zealand 2.8
 Denmark 3.1
 Canada 2.7
 United Kingdom  2.8
 Sweden 2.6
 Chile 2.2
 Colombia 1.5
 Mexico 1.4

PLombard
Tue, 03/17/2020 - 11:34am

Hospital beds per 1000 people using 2018 data from Kaiser Foundation:
South Dakota 4.8
District of Columbia 4.4
North Dakota 4.3
Mississippi 4
West Virginia 3.8
Nebraska 3.6
Wyoming 3.5
Montana 3.3
Kansas 3.3
Louisiana 3.3
Kentucky 3.2
Arkansas 3.2
Alabama 3.1
Missouri 3.1
Iowa 3
Pennsylvania 2.9
Tennessee 2.9
Ohio 2.8
Oklahoma 2.8
Indiana 2.7
New York 2.7
Florida 2.6
Maine 2.5
Illinois 2.5
Michigan 2.5
Minnesota 2.5
United States 2.4
Georgia 2.4
South Carolina 2.4
New Jersey 2.4
Texas 2.3
Massachusetts 2.3
Alaska 2.2
Delaware 2.2
Nevada 2.1
Virginia 2.1
Vermont 2.1
Wisconsin 2.1
North Carolina 2.1
Rhode Island 2.1
New Hampshire 2.1
Connecticut 2
Idaho 1.9
Hawaii 1.9
Arizona 1.9
Maryland 1.9
Colorado 1.9
California 1.8
Utah 1.8
New Mexico 1.8
Washington 1.7
Oregon 1.6

Barry Vvviil
Tue, 03/17/2020 - 7:44pm

Hey Bridge, could you please provide an overview of the laws that allow government officials to override our liberty and freedom as citizens of Michigan and the United States? It seems like we just assume our governor and president have the right to restrict our liberty. Is that true? Details please.

Robyn A Tonkin
Tue, 03/17/2020 - 8:17pm

Why isn't anyone mentioning the 30 or 40 year push to make every surgery an outpatient surgery that the health insurance giants have engaged in? I would suppose everyone has had the experience of being shoved out of the hospital before they were well enough to go because health insurers did not want to pay for a longer hospital stay. Having a baby used to mean a two or three day stay, now having a baby means being kicked out right away. Having joint replacement meant at least an overnight stay. Now joint replacement is outpatient, unless Medicare is involved, then you get an overnight stay. They got rid of hospital beds, and they got rid of small rural hospitals. There is the remains of a nice hospital in Phelps, Wisconsin, that sits there with a caved in roof. Too bad it's not sitting there ready to accept Covid 19 patients. The drive to eliminate hospital beds and rural hospitals is turning out to be a public health disaster.

Jerry Keyes
Wed, 03/18/2020 - 7:19pm

The recommended number of beds is 3.2 per 1000. Michigan has 2.8 per 1000. It is time to give up the archaic Certificate of Need process.

Anonymous
Thu, 03/19/2020 - 6:21pm

We are #1.

Anonymous
Thu, 03/19/2020 - 6:24pm

People should take Trump to court because he failed to protect the American people from the Corona virus spread. He thought it was a hoax at the beginning.