For weary Michigan seniors, a retirement in name only

Cam McClure, left, chairman of Oakland County Senior Advisory Council, jokes with volunteers at the Waterford Senior Center. (Bridge photo by Dale Young)

At age 62, Linda Braden felt like someone had wrenched her life from her — her home, her career as an accountant, and her circle of friends.

Forced to retire years before she’d planned, Braden returned to the home where she was raised in Waterford to care for her aging parents — her father, a former repairman for office machines, and her mom, who worked as a phlebotomist and later at a temp agency. Both lived into their 90s. 

“I didn’t want to disrupt my life, but I didn’t feel like I had a choice,” said Braden. She spent five years cooking, cleaning and laundering for her parents, juggling their medical appointments and, at times, struggling to help them to their feet after falls. 

“My mother would tell people ‘We don’t know what we’d do without her,’ so I know they appreciated it,” said Braden, now 72.   

“But it was hard. It could get lonely.”

Related:

When it comes to caring for loved ones, Michigan seniors carry a heavy load.

A recent survey of residents aged 60 and older found nearly 3 in 10 provided “unpaid care to an adult relative or friend” with a physical ailment or illness. That’s more than triple the estimate of aging caregivers since a similar survey in 1987 — 161,000 then compared to 685,000 in 2019. 

With nearly 400 Michiganders turning 60 each day, aging caregivers are but one barometer of how the state’s graying population is altering lives and presenting challenges for state policymakers. Drawing from numbers from the AARP Public Policy Institute, the authors of the Michigan report value unpaid care by seniors in the state at $8 billion a year.  

“We’re getting old and we’re not dying,” said Cam McClure, chairman of Oakland County Senior Advisory Council. “We’re getting heart surgery and hip replacements and vaccinations,” he noted, adding dryly: “They’ll probably be doing brain (replacements soon). 

“So we’re going to be around for a while.”

Retirement without kicking back  

For the fortunate, retirement brings a special kind of peace for a job well done, with days no longer dictated by time clocks and deadlines or school schedules. But for many in Michigan, there is the betrayal of aging bodies, the loss of their spouse or close friends, a limited income and greater social isolation. 

And, as Braden learned, more responsibility for loved ones rather than less. 

Of the 600 seniors surveyed, about 1 in 20 (representing some 120,000 grandparents) said they were living with or raising grandchildren. That’s more than twice as many as in 1987, when the survey suggested roughly 58,000 grandparents were with their grandchildren.

Possible reasons for the increase include military deployments and  interventions by the state because of allegations of abuse or neglect, said Alicia Guevara Warren, director of the state’s Kinship Care Resource Center at Michigan State University.

 

These new responsibilities can overwhelm seniors, as they negotiate legal and other obstacles that come with taking care of a parent or a grandchild. 

“Grandma and Grandpa may get the kids in the middle of the night and it’s:  “What do we do now?’” Warren said.

The seniors survey, the first of its kind in over a generation, was commissioned for the state’s Area Agencies on Aging, a collection of 16 federally-funded agencies that coordinate services for seniors. It examined the concerns people 60 and over face as they try to stay independent, connected and active in a state graying faster than the rest of the U.S.

As Bridge has reported, 21 Michigan counties now have a median age of 50 years old or older, the most of any state. Michigan’s median age of 39.8 is the nation’s 12th oldest. As recently as 1990, the state’s median age was younger than that of the nation. Meanwhile, the number of new births is at its lowest level since 1941, with deaths in the state expected to overtake births by 2030

And those who remain are living longer. In 1990, Michigan men lived on average to 71.8 years — that grew to 75.4 year by 2018. Michigan women went from 78.1 to 80.3 over this same period.  

For Thomas Jankowski, associate research director at Wayne State University’s Institute of Gerontology, the state’s aging trends raise critical policy issues, including: How will Michigan fund services for seniors while protecting local and state budgets? How important are resources like senior centers and elder-friendly health care systems?  

“They’re important questions — not just for the seniors, but for entire communities,” Jankowski said.

Jim McGuire, director of research, policy development and advocacy at the Area Agency on Aging 1-B in Southfield, knows how draining caregiving can be for seniors pressed into caregiving duty. 

In addition to the emotional and physical toll, there are complicated legal and medical decisions to navigate. Research shows caregivers of any age face higher rates of depression, anxiety and stress.

In some ways, the shift is expected in a rapidly graying state: “As we age, caregiving follows,” he said.

Waterford resident Linda Braden, 72, deals cards at a euchre table in the Waterford Senior Center. (Bridge photo by Dale Young)

In caring for her parents, Braden said she had to call 911 for help lifting her parents after falls. She recalls searching through her parents’ health plan to find a podiatrist willing to come to their home. Family members sometimes pitched in. 

Braden said she found a support group at the Waterford Senior Center, where she still occasionally meets friends for games of euchre.

“Every situation is different,” she said. “But there are surprising similarities, too — the social isolation, the question of how to tell your parents they should no longer drive.” 

There’s another dramatic caregiving shift at play in Michigan: an increase in grandparents raising grandchildren, the Area Agency’s McGuire noted.

The new seniors survey underscores other concerns and policy decisions for an aging state:

  • About 1 in 5 of the respondents said they don’t have enough social contact
  • About 1 in 10 said they faced serious challenges managing health and medications
  • More than 1 in 10 said they didn’t visit a doctor when they thought they should have gone 
  • About 15.8 percent reported dental problems, and slightly more said they didn’t visit a dentist even though they thought they should 
  • About 4 in 10 had concerns about their home environment, ranging from a need for minor to major repairs

Talk and food go together at the Waterford Senior Center, which offers seniors not only a safe place to gather, but also help in areas ranging from taxes to insurance to transportation to home-based care. (Bridge photo by Dale Young)

There were some bright spots in the report, too. For example, nearly 7 in 10 older Michiganders rated their emotional and mental health is “excellent” or “very good.” Nearly 2 in 3 reported no health concerns at all.

Of course, needs and resources differ across the state, said Jonathan Mead, president & CEO of the Upper Peninsula Commission for Area Progress, or UPCAP, the aging agency coordinating services for Michigan’s largely rural Upper Peninsula.

He noted, for instance, that transportation needs appeared to be less acute state-wide than in 1987. But not for everyone. Mead noted that he used to drive more than 300 miles round trip from his home in Escanaba to pick up his parents in Grand Marais to take them to a clinic in Newberry.

He said his situation is hardly unique and that many seniors have no one at all to turn to. Even for those that do, “maybe the friend’s car is old, or it can’t accomodate a wheelchair.”

In the woodshop at Waterford Senior Center, Neal Smith puts a new blade in the scroll saw.  (Bridge photo by Dale Young)

The state ignores the needs of its seniors at its own peril, said 72-year-old McClure, of the Oakland County Senior Advisory Council. 

“Everybody assumes that they’re invincible,” he said, “until one day they’re not.”

Michigan Health Watch is made possible by generous financial support from the Michigan Health Endowment Fund, the Michigan Association of Health Plans, and the Michigan Health and Hospital Association. The monthly mental health special report is made possible by generous financial support of the Ethel & James Flinn Foundation. Please visit the Michigan Health Watch 'About' page for more information.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Matt
Mon, 02/24/2020 - 7:35am

Somehow this is seen as a new thing? It was always very common, since the dawn of time, for elderly parents to live with adult children in their later years if not before. Maybe they didn't live quite as long then but it's all relative with life expectancy. Not new at all. What's newer is the number of dysfunctional parents dumping their kids with their older parents while they do something else … rehab, prison, who knows what. The list is long of what and why this has happened but parenting is at least part of the cause

Keith
Mon, 02/24/2020 - 9:10am

A disappointing article, merely a collection of well known factoids and anecdotal evidence.

Nothing new here and I got to the end with the thought of “and so what”? Many of the needs talked about used to be handled by tight knit neighborhoods and church families. Both long gone.

We are now experiencing the results of decades of neglect in our faith and relationships.

Tina
Tue, 02/25/2020 - 11:08am

Hit the nail on the head Keith!

Jonah 212
Mon, 02/24/2020 - 11:01am

My comments are directed to Matt and Keith who don't have a clue about what occurs in old age and families caring for families. Churches and neighbors did very little to help other families. You both have a distorted and imagined view of what old age was like in previous years and in current years.

I recall acting as a care giver for elderly grandparents. My mother and brother and I did the work. There were no neighbors or church people who assisted and I never saw that. Now, in my old age, I care for a wife with Alzheimer 's and we are fortunate to have sufficient funds to pay for an aide six days a week and my decent physical being to care for her.

Matt and Keith, you both have a heck of a lot to learn but with your "knowledge" I am afraid, though, that you will never learn about caring giving in old age whether by children or spouses. And, if either of your spouses develops dementia, Alzheimer's or whatever serious illness, you would probably abandon them as too many men have done already.

Grow up and learn from the article! It just might do you or your spouses some good.

Matt
Mon, 02/24/2020 - 8:35pm

Sorry Jonah apparently you didn't associate with people and organizations that I was fortunate enough to have. Yes we took care of elderly widowed parents who lived for years with us and non elderly parents who died of terminal illnesses at far too young of ages all while receiving the help and support of not only family immediate and extended but caring members of community and our churches. While I can't comment on your individual situation, I have learned that rather than blaming others, the reasons for this lack caring people in our lives usually resides within ourselves and our own making. Whether it's too late I can't say.

Regina
Mon, 02/24/2020 - 3:22pm

The biggest thing that causes lost a lot of grief is Medical and we get no relief on our property taxes and our car insurance is outrageous that's the big three they are killers

Max Andersen
Mon, 02/24/2020 - 6:20pm

Thanks for your input
:)

middle of the mit
Wed, 02/26/2020 - 2:39am

Thank you for reminding the rest of MI what really matters!

Property taxes and car insurance rates!

Or in other Biblical terms.....Mammon!