Michigan poll: Coronavirus break hurts kids, but don’t order more school

Half of surveyed Michigan families say they’ve lost household income because of time spent helping children with remote learning. (Photo courtesy of Courtney Snede)

Nearly two-thirds of Michigan parents say they’re concerned about the negative impact school shutdowns are having on learning during the coronavirus crisis, according to a poll conducted by Bridge Magazine and Public Sector Consultants.  

But not concerned enough to support forcing their children to spend additional time in school when classrooms reopen. Only 34 percent of parents of K-12 students polled listed mandatory summer school or a longer school year as their top choice for mitigating academic damage caused by the pandemic school closures.  

The poll, of 800 parents, also found families offering mixed reviews on the quality of remote learning being offered to students. And half of households surveyed lost income to spend time helping their children with homebound assignments.

Still, an overwhelming majority of parents surveyed supported Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s decision to close schools for the remainder of the school year in an effort to slow the spread of the potentially deadly coronavirus. That support was consistent among Democrats, Republicans and Independents. 

The poll, conducted April 13-20, offers an in-depth look at how families view the state’s classroom closures, remote learning and options for learning in the fall. The poll has a margin of error of between 2.5 percent and 3.5 percent.

After seeing the poll results, Pamela Pugh, a Democratic member of the State Board of Education, said in an email to Bridge, “it is understandable that parents are concerned that the instruction delivered, using unprecedented measures during this time of an unprecedented crisis that is impacting so many, will not be comparable to that delivered in a normal school setting. 

“I share in the hopes and prayers of these parents that our children can return to their normal school environments starting in the fall,” Pugh said. “I too know that our first priority must be the health and safety of our children."

The Bridge-PSC poll found that parents and guardians of Michigan K-12 students are taking the pandemic — and the resulting school closures — seriously. Among the findings:
  • Six in 10 parents are concerned or very concerned about the health of their families due to the coronavirus pandemic; 17 percent were not concerned.
  • Seven in 10 agree with Whitmer’s decision to close K-12 classrooms for the remainder of the school year and switch to remote learning; just 8 percent disagreed.
  • Though a majority agreed it was a good idea to close schools and switch to remote learning 64 percent are concerned about the negative impact school closures have on learning; 18 percent said they weren’t concerned.
  • Parents are split on the quality of learning taking place at kitchen tables around the state. About 37 percent said the quality of learning was lower than in classrooms, with 37 percent saying it was similar and 25 percent saying it was better.
  • 45 percent said someone in the household had reduced their hours of employment as a result of children being home during the school closure; 50 percent said their household income had declined.
  • One in 10 families said a K-12 student in their household had not received any remote learning material at the time this survey was taken, five weeks after schools closed. Eighty-one percent said their children were getting at least some learning online, and 38 percent received at least some printed materials from their schools.

School leaders are huddling across the state to strategize how to mitigate the anticipated learning loss from being out of classrooms for six months. The Bridge/PSC poll suggests policymakers may have a heavy lift winning public support if they attempt to boost classroom hours when schools reopen. 

Given four options to boost student learning when schools resume, 34 percent supported some form of mandatory additional education. The breakdown: 

  • 48 percent prefer a normal school year starting in the fall; 
  • 22 percent support extending the next school year by 15 days (to 195 days instead of 180) to make up for learning loss from school closures; 
  • 16 percent support optional summer school;
  • 12 percent want mandatory summer school

Some other results from the poll: 

  • When parents were asked to pick their top choice from among five remote learning options, there was one clear response: Parents don’t want their kids to “play hooky” during home learning. Just 4 percent of poll respondents said they would prefer schools not provide school work for their children during the pandemic closure.

Among other choices:

  • 21 percent of parents want remote learning homework graded, and an equal percent wanted schoolwork, but didn’t want grades given during homebound remote learning. 
  • 24 percent said they wished schools would offer as many hours of remote learning instruction as offered in classrooms (work varies by district, but elementary-aged students typically receive 1-3 hours of remote instruction).

  • 19 percent wanted instruction less focused on academics, and more emphasis on the emotional needs of children during the pandemic.

  • There are large disparities in remote learning among local school  districts, both in how remote learning is presented (online or in printed packets), and whether assignments are receiving grades. Those differences raise concerns among some education leaders about the possibility of learning gaps growing in the six months between the March shutdown and September’s traditional reopening.

Parents, though, don’t seem to want a state-imposed solution. Forty-eight percent of surveyed parents prefer remote learning be developed by local school districts rather than the state, compared to 14 percent who said they’d prefer standardized remote learning guidelines established by the state.

Dan Quisenberry, president of the Michigan Association of Public School Academies, which represents the state’s charter schools, said it’s important for educators to understand the experiences parents are having with remote learning. 

“This kind of information going forward will help inform educators how best to educate kids and keep them safe,” he said.

 “As schools plan for next fall, given all the unknowns, providing the highest quality education possible will continue to be the priority,” Quisenberry said. 

“Safety is also a priority. So, once schools can decide to reopen buildings, hearing parents’ concerns and communicating safety protocols will be very important.”

RESOURCES:

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Mark
Wed, 04/29/2020 - 5:09pm

The Hysteria has got to end. Data shows that Children getting sick of the Coronavirus is statistically Zero.

99.99% of All Americans under the Age of 85 remain Standing from the Peak of the Coronavirus.
The Median Age of Death will end up being in the Mid 80s
The Average Age of Death will be near 80.
The overall Vast Majority of Deaths have underlying conditions.

Pres Trump said today (Wednesday) that the White House Task Force will be "easing up" on the Federal Social Distancing Guidelines that Expire tomorrow. The 30 Days to "Slow the Spread" Guidelines will mostly not be extended.

Time to move on Safely. Freedoms must prevail. Liberate Michigan.

Kim
Wed, 04/29/2020 - 7:01pm

Or you could move to Georgia. Did you not see the Michigan polls? Do you not read the articles?

Kevin Grand
Wed, 04/29/2020 - 8:09pm

And how were these polls conducted?

The methodology is curiously "missing".

Water Smitty
Wed, 04/29/2020 - 9:12pm

I think he saw the poll. It appears he is arguing for our elected leaders to do the right thing. There is indeed a lot of irrational fear out there, being stoked by the the disaster porn media and power hungry elites. Polls can be taken. But to have courage to do the right thing and put in place rational, reasoned, and well thought out policies- that's what I believe this person was arguing for.

Kim, I love the fact though that your first response was to banish someone who you disagree with. I'm glad to see you've moved on from threatening harm on those who disagree with you, as you have done in other posts.

Mark
Thu, 04/30/2020 - 5:16am

Kim- Do you not analyze or read the Data....not articles or polls Honey.

Michele
Fri, 05/01/2020 - 8:55am

Except these polls are pretty much in line other polls showing broad approval for stay-at-home orders. Face it, many of us would rather avoid unleashing a disease that kills between 1% and 15% of adults (depending upon your age) because we realize that would be devastating to not only our health, but our economy as well.

Michele
Fri, 05/01/2020 - 8:44am

The number of children who are killed by CV-19 would be relevant if children lived and went to school isolated from adults, but they do not. They often asymptomatically spread the virus readily to at risk populations. Sounds like you don’t mind Michiganders dying as long as you can pretend that the majority of deaths in those over 65, or the 19-50% of folks with pre-existing conditions don’t “really” count. But it looks like many Michigander do think those deaths count.

Anonymous
Fri, 05/01/2020 - 5:50pm

Michele, you make a great point. Children who live with those over the age of 65 who have health conditions should probably rely on alternative forms of schooling and not go back to school. All others should be allowed back. Great suggestion- 90% of kids can go back to school now.