Study to measure cost of education unlikely in election year
With stark divisions in Michigan over how to best fund public schools, one solution adopted by most states is to fund an “adequacy study.” Such studies are intended to determine how much it costs per pupil to offer all students a quality education.
For now, however, funding an adequacy study in Michigan appears to be a political non-starter this election year. Such studies tend to be supported by Democrats and education groups, and opposed by Republicans, who contend the studies invariably conclude that states need to spend more on education.
House Bill 5269, widely backed by Democrats, calls for an adequacy study to determine the cost per pupil to provide an education that would enable a student to meet state standards on the high school Michigan Merit Exam, which includes the ACT college entrance test.
The bill languished in the House education committee until sponsors pushed to get it discharged. It was referred back to the education committee last month. There it sits, with no support from Republicans such as Rep. Bill Rogers, a key voice on school aid.
When Rogers was first elected in 2008, he asked the very question that would seem to be addressed by an adequacy study: How much does it cost to educate a child in Michigan? He said he is still waiting for an answer.
But that doesn’t mean the state should approve the adequacy study bill and have to pony up money to pay for data collection, he said. Rogers said the Legislature should be able to get that answer from Michigan educators.
“Why do I want to pay for a study from outsiders when the information could be there right at the ready at the schools?” Rogers said.
Experts estimate such studies have cost other states from $500,000 to $1 million to carry out.
Rogers argues that term limits, not the absence of an adequacy study, probably present the biggest political barrier to reforming school funding in Michigan. The proposed 2015 school aid budget is the fourth one Rogers has worked on as chair of the House appropriations subcommittee on school aid, making him the longest-serving lawmaker to serve in that capacity. Term limits prevent him from running again this fall, so his replacement will have to tackle the issues.
“Election year, people get a little tentative on both sides of the aisle,” Rogers said. “It takes a while to get to the longer-term, real fixes. It’s not from lack of effort. As soon as you understand things, you’re gone and it starts all over.”
We’ve been there for you with daily Michigan COVID-19 news; reporting on the emergence of the virus, daily numbers with our tracker and dashboard, exploding unemployment, and we finally were able to report on mass vaccine distribution. We report because the news impacts all of us. Will you please support our nonprofit newsroom?