With city in limbo, Benton Harbor prepares new pitch to save its high school

Benton Harbor high school poster

Uncertainty over the fate of the high school, and the entire district, is adding to the tension in the west Michigan town of Benton Harbor.

Update: New Michigan school superintendent: Keep Benton Harbor High open

BENTON HARBOR—The crowd was sparse and subdued Thursday night at Benton Harbor High School, perhaps three-dozen parents, teachers and ministers munching on cold cuts and cookies while officials quietly professed determination to save the community’s sole high school.

It was a notable contrast from previous meetings in Benton Harbor since Gov. Gretchen Whitmer threatened in May to close the academically struggling high school following the upcoming school year. In those past meetings, hundreds packed the school’s auditorium, clapping to the school fight song and cheering fiery speeches.

But two months into the battle to save its high school, Benton Harbor seems less on fire than in limbo. Veteran teachers are fleeing the district for schools that aren’t in danger of closure. School officials are hatching plans to try to slow the hemorrhaging of student enrollment to surrounding charter schools they fear will accelerate with the current uncertainty. And negotiations with the state over the fate of the high school – and the entire district – have slowed to a virtual standstill.

“The parents I talk to don’t know what’s going on,” said the Rev. Steven McCoy of McCoy Memorial Church of God in Christ. “When you’re in limbo, you make bad choices.”

The Benton Harbor Area School Board is putting the finishing touches on a plan to save the high school. Their goal is to give the proposal to Whitmer and state officials in the coming days, board vice president Joseph Taylor told the gathering Thursday.

Taylor did not offer details of the plan. But Daniel Martin, a Grand Rapids attorney representing the board, offered a broad outline to Bridge.

The board’s plan tentatively calls for a four-year period to improve test scores and reduce the district’s $18 million debt.

That’s far longer than the state’s most recent proposal, crafted three weeks ago, which gave the district one year to meet academic goals; if those goals weren’t met, the high school would close.

Benton Harbor’s latest proposal would guarantee the high school remains open for four years, with goals for academic growth and debt reduction each year over that period. Each year that goals were met, an additional year of goals would be added, creating a rolling four-year improvement plan.

Despite fiery rhetoric from some in Benton Harbor, Martin said he believed the state was negotiating in good faith, and that the district and the state are not far apart on improvement metrics for the district.

Whitmer administration officials could not be reached for comment Thursday night. Earlier Thursday, Whitmer spokesperson Tiffany Brown said only that “discussions are ongoing.”

In May, Whitmer and the state treasury department released a plan to close Benton Harbor High School, with the students dispersed to 10 nearby traditional and charter high schools beginning in the 2020-21 school year. Benton Harbor would be converted to a K-8 district.

If the board didn’t agree to close the high school, Whitmer said in May she would ask the Legislature to dissolve the district completely.

The district has been one of the lowest academically performing districts in the state for years. No junior in the past five years was considered “college ready” by scores on standardized tests. Six years after graduation, just 6 percent of the class of 2011-12 had earned an associate’s degree or higher – one sixth the state average.

The closure plan caused an uproar in the low-income, majority-black community. What was characterized as a framework of an agreement reached June 26 would have kept the high school open if the district improved academic outcomes and paid down debt. State officials believed they had a deal, but the board rejected the agreement July 3, leading to a flurry of accusations from both sides.

In the 17 days that followed, the two sides have met just once.

The impasse and the uncertainty it has created has chipped away at an already fragile school district. As many as a half-dozen veteran teachers, many with more than 20 years of experience in Benton Harbor schools, have fled the district this summer, further hollowing out a district that already uses long-time substitutes to lead 42 percent of its classes.

“These are teachers who know our schools and our community,” said Acting Superintendent Patricia Robinson. “They’re leaving because of uncertainty about their jobs.”

The district currently has 33 unfilled teaching positions – about one third of its total teaching staff – and two vacant principal posts.

“We’ve weathered other storms before,” Robinson said. “We’ve handled other challenges.”

At Thursday’s meeting, community leaders discussed plans to go door to door to try to persuade families to send their children to Benton Harbor schools. Currently, fewer than half of the city’s children attend its public schools, with the rest attending charter schools or surrounding public school districts.

“If we are going to save not just the high school, but our district, it has to be a community effort,” McCoy said.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


Ken Tokarz
Fri, 07/19/2019 - 9:01am

A successful plan will need to include the following:
·          Transitional funding in the amount of $500,000

·          Pre-K transitional funding in the amount of 325,000

·          The State will make an exception and provide State Aid Note funding  to BHAS on a monthly basis from June 31, 2019 through September 31, 2025

·          The state will forgive the 18/19 pupil student count adjustment on July 1, 2023,  contingent upon BHAS having no outstanding debt

·          A Transition Manager will have full control of the district from July 1, 2019 to August 31, 2021

·          A Transition Manager will report to the State Treasurer through June 30, 2021 and the FRC beginning July 1, 2021

·           A Transition Manager will gradually relinquish control back to the school board at the Transition Managers discretion from September 1, 2021 to June 30, 2023 and oversee a structured transition to full School Board control

·          The State will relinquish full control back to the School Board on July 1, 2023

·          Any change in the Transition Manager will void this agreement

·          A Transition Manager may close up to three buildings with the exception of the high school

·          The Transition Manager will eliminate all programming ( music, art, CTE, etc…) that is not required by the state between the hours of 6am and 2pm. Instruction during these hours will be limited to core curriculum by certified teachers under an updated wage schedule.

·          Music, Art, CTE, Robotics, Technology, Scouts, Culinary, etc.. would be taught by  part time teachers as part of a wrap around after school program

·          Tutoring would be available from 2-7pm and wrap around services would include dinner

·          Transition Manager will eliminate the use of all school buildings and properties to outside groups including rentals

·          Operations costs at BHAS are double the state average, the Transition Manager will cut costs by 40%

·          The district will implement an energy conservation program and reduce utility costs by 25

Sat, 07/27/2019 - 3:10pm

In other words the Republican controlled congress NEEDS to fund the schools as required by law and NOT the charter scholls who are getting over 30% of the public schools money!!! ILLEGALLY!!!

Sherry A Wells
Fri, 07/19/2019 - 9:30am

The high school is near the waterfront. "Development" wants that land and cares nothing about the residents. When the water dept. was decimated by Whirlpool et al developing a new one to serve the water depts. outlying customers, that cut the city's base. When a charter school was allowed to remove at least $1,500,000 dollars in student allotments, that hurt the school district budget. And again, the Governor, by our State Constitution, is "ex oficio." The State Board of Education is in charge. (And it needs to look at this Partnership Agreement--Benton Harbor's led by Whirlpool--because it's not sincere.)

Fri, 07/19/2019 - 11:01am

That is not true. There is plenty of prime property across the street from the river that has more value and is for sale or going up for tax auction at the end of this month. It is not about the property, Benton Harbor school board has failed those kids from having great education. Ask them where they send their kids or grand kids to school.

Fri, 07/19/2019 - 12:52pm

This rumor has persisted for far too long. Look at a map - the high school is 1/2 mile away from the river! It's nowhere near the lake! Hardly "waterfront" or even "near waterfront" property. This aspect has absolutely no bearing on the academic and financial crisis of the school. It's merely a distraction technique!

Fri, 07/19/2019 - 3:58pm

Using the students to pen a letter is the new low for the school district. If the district wants to keep the school open, then they'd hire someone better to run it! Instead of mismanaging the school, they'd do better to optimize the monies provided to hire better teachers, and principle to ensure all students get the education they need. Yet they failed to do so, leading to low exam turnouts. It's no wonder why they are hemorrhaging students when the parents were smart enough to transfer their kids elsewhere for better education!

Mon, 07/22/2019 - 7:32am

Please tell us that wasn't the HS valedictorian who did that sign.

Jackie Syms
Sat, 07/20/2019 - 4:40pm

Our Governor sucks. She ain't done one thing to help it improve Michigan yet. Your school is in limbo. Our jobs have been in limbo at the Caro center since she took office.

Sun, 07/21/2019 - 10:46am

You obviously missed the memo... shes only been in office for almost a year and she's at fault? They have been troubled for a while now, long before her tenure! So place the blame where it belongs.... the school administration and Rick Snyder's administration!