MI government removes bureaucratic mumbo jumbo from benefit renewal form

State officials expect new benefit renewal forms for 2 million recipients to cut down errors and benefit terminations. (Photo by  Marisol Dorantes Silva)

After streamlining the longest public assistance application form in the nation two years ago, Michigan officials announced the rollout Wednesday of simplified renewal forms for some 2 million recipients of food stamps, cash assistance and other benefits.

At a glance

Here’s how many Michigan residents received public assistance in July from five programs administered by the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services: 

    Food assistance (SNAP): 1,234,935

    Cash assistance (Family Independence Program): 58,076

    Child care (Child Development and Care): 67,722

    Medicaid: 1,838,716

    State Emergency Relief: 6,428

Source: MDHHS 

“We are committed to making the process of getting help as easy and simply as possible,” Robert Gordon, director of Michigan’s Department of Health and Human Services,” told Bridge Michigan. 

“Michiganders face incredible challenges right now and getting state help shouldn’t add to those challenges.”

Earlier this year, MDHHS tested the revamped renewal forms – which are shorter and written in plain language – in field offices in Monroe and Oakland counties.

The result: Ninety-six percent of clients completed the new forms versus 73 percent who finished the old forms. There were 60 percent fewer errors and 50 percent fewer office visits related to the forms ─  a reduction that puts fewer clients and field office workers at risk from interactions that could spread COVID-19.

While alterations to a bureaucratic form may strike some as much ado about nothing, another state official said they’re more than changes on a piece of paper. He foresees they will help thousands keep benefits to which they are entitled, but might otherwise lose.

“It means they are going to be able to feed their family and shelter their family and provide for the health care needs of their family,” said Terry Beurer, a senior deputy director at MDHHS.

MDHHS official Terry Baurer said that making forms clearer to clients “means they are going to be able to feed their family and shelter their family.” (Courtesy photo)

“By doing that, they are able to concentrate on other things like moving to work, concentrating on self-sufficiency.”

MDHHS contracted with Detroit nonprofit design consultant Civilla to redo the renewal forms, just as it had to rework the bulky application form 1171 required for most forms of public assistance in Michigan. As Bridge first reported in 2018, the old version of the 1171 forms stretched nearly 40 feet if laid end to end, encompassing 42 pages, more than 18,000 words and 1,200 questions. 

The old form took hours to complete; spawned countless errors, office visits by frustrated clients and approval delays ─ in general, gumming up a public assistance system that one -third of Michigan’s residents will turn to at some point in their lives.

Civilla managed to pare the form to a much leaner and more digestible 18 pages.

Some 86 percent of users were able to complete the form in less than 20 minutes. Clients turned in applications at a 94 percent clip, up from 72 percent before.

Harvard University recognized the project to revamp the MDHHS application as among the top 25 government innovations in 2018.

Civilla CEO Michael Brennan told Bridge on Monday that MDHHS’s renewal forms were marred by similar problems, which so frustrated some clients they simply gave up.

“It often caused people to just set it aside. They would never get it done,” he said.

A seemingly small but significant hang-up: The old renewal forms headlined the application as “redetermination” ─ a term that may have resonated within some bureaucratic cubicles but mystified many clients.

“They really didn’t know what that meant,” Brennan said.

The old “redetermination” form followed that notice with more than a half-dozen bullet points and upwards of 150 words of instruction.

In contrast, the top of the revised renewal form reads in large, bold letters, “Renew your benefits.”

Robert Gordon

“Michiganders face incredible challenges right now and getting state help shouldn’t add to those challenges,” said MDHHS Director Robert Gordon. (Courtesy photo)

Just below: “Here’s what you need to do,” followed by three, simple, numbered steps.

MDHHS launched the refashioned renewal forms statewide last month, allowing those approved to receive food stamps, cash assistance, Medicaid, state emergency relief and child day care.

Brennan said the group fashioned the new forms with considerable feedback from clients and field workers on perceived flaws in the old forms, as well as how they could be corrected.

MDHHS Director Gordon said his agency has more work to do, adding that it is looking to revamp the entire benefit renewal process, from how field workers respond to calls to simplifying correspondence with clients so that its language is “clean and simple.”

“The work continues,” he said.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Paul Jordan
Wed, 09/02/2020 - 9:44am

The application form is an example is an excellent example of how, when they are in power, people who oppose public social welfare benefits can use bureaucratic processes to erect barriers to minimize those benefits. The most vulnerable, least able applicants are those who suffer most because they just can't master those barriers.
Anti-government Republicans didn't have the votes during Snyder's administration to eliminate state social welfare benefits, but as long as they were in power in DHHS they could reduce them through the hidden, underhanded means of complicating the application process.
This application revision is also a good example of how such barriers can be minimize when the powers-that-be actually want to get people help.
Elections matter., and we've got another one coming up in just three months. Vote smart.

Louise
Wed, 09/02/2020 - 12:01pm

The days of making everything so complicated with ted tape and made to discourage good people down on their luck and puts a smile on the born with a silver spoon in their mouth type are over everybody that actually care has had enough of the nonsense!