Michigan’s deer season could scatter COVID-19, health leaders say

As hunters meet up in search of the trophy buck or a fat doe for the freezer, health officials worry about coronavirus spread in deer camps. (Shutterstock)

Buddies, beer, cramped cabins, packed bunkhouses, card games and shared pots of food are beloved traditions of Michigan deer camps for many of the more than half-million hunters during deer season.

 

But they’re the stuff of nightmares for state and regional health officials battling to contain the fast-spreading new coronavirus. The 15-day firearms season starts Nov. 15, and already license sales have surged ahead of last year’s pace. 

“You’re not going to stop it,” said Mark Ebener, a fish biologist and resident of Sugar Island near Sault Ste. Marie.

Ebener and his friends will meet this year at a Wisconsin deer camp. They’ve been getting tested for COVID-19 for a variety of reasons — a routine medical procedure, among them, and Ebener said they’ll do their best to keep a social distance, he said.

But to cancel the trip altogether?

He shakes his head.

“It’s the chance to get out, get with the guys, and get away,” he said.

The problem isn’t hunting itself, which is often a solitary activity in wide-open spaces.

 

“The higher risk is people from different households gathering indoors,  especially if they are eating or drinking,” said Dr. Josh Meyerson, medical director of health departments covering the 10 northernmost counties in Michigan’s Lower Peninsula.

Compounding the problem: After camp, hunters will scatter to their own communities, gathering for the holidays, said Mike Snyder, health officer in Delta and Menominee counties in the western U.P.

He worries that hunters are “not going to change deer hunting plans, they’re not going to change Thanksgiving and Christmas plans, and they’re not going to mask up.”

Still, some hunters interviewed said they take pandemic safety protocols seriously.

Marty Cotanche kneels with dog, Tyler, with his wife, Valerie Cotanche, standing behind, along with six regulars from the Traverse City area at the Cotanche's 920-acre hunt camp in Baraga County. The Cotanches called off this year's hunt because of COVID-19 that could be spread in close quarters. The youngest hunter is 57 years old. (Photo courtesy of Marty Cotanche)

Marty and Valerie Cotanche have owned a 920-acre hunting camp near Covington in Baraga County for 30 years and annually hosted a group of friends from the Traverse City area.

In April, with much uncertainty about the future of the pandemic, they notified their six guests that for only the second year in the last 30, they would cancel the 2020 hunt. (A blizzard in 2014 that dumped as much as five feet of snow forced the other cancellation.)

“We just  looked at the risk factors and couldn’t sustain a group like that with all the guys sleeping in close quarters in a sleeping loft,” Marty Cotanche said. “They’re all guys from 57 to 70 and I didn’t want to be the one to create an additional risk factor.”

A retired partner in a small auto parts manufacturer in Traverse City, Marty Cotanche has hunted big game and birds across the world. But he prefers Michigan deer and bear hunting and bird hunting with his labrador, Tyler.

About the upcoming season at the camp, he said: “They’ll miss it. I’ll miss it, but hopefully we’ll all be around to do it next year.”

At the historic Turtle Lake Club, founded in the late 1800s and covering 44,000 acres is several northeastern Lower Peninsula counties, none of the approximately two-dozen members will be permitted to bring guests this year, reducing the number of hunters by about two-thirds, said Wayne Sitton, the club’s longtime manager.

The members will get meals boxed or delivered, rather than eating in a dining room, Sitton said. 

“We’re going to have take-out. We’ve been working to keep everyone safe and still have a hunt,” he said.

This is the scene of a dinner after a past year’s deer hunt at the Beaver Lake Hunt Club in southwestern Alpena County, where more than 20 hosts and members passed shared plates, sitting elbow to elbow. The club's meal service and lodge with bedrooms will be closed this season, but members may still hunt the vast property. (Courtesy of Todd Reilly, club manager)

At neighboring Beaver Lake Hunt Club, manager Todd Reilly said he believes he’s taken one of the most aggressive pandemic-related steps among the various camps in a part of Michigan long known as hunting “club country.”

“We decided to shut down the lodge and the kitchen,” Reilly said Wednesday. “But the hunters can still hunt, and I’ve added electric hookups outside the pole barn and told our guys they can bring their own campers or stay at a motel.”

Reilly said he considered requiring masks and social distancing and keeping the lodge and kitchen open, but decided he didn’t want to play bad cop with the hunters.

Regardless whether Michigan sees evidence of hunters infecting friends and relatives at camp, one thing is virtually certain as Michigan heads toward the opening day: more hunters.

Through Oct. 26, 2020 hunting license sales were up by about 50,000 or 12 percent, from the same time a year ago, said Dustin Isenhoff, a Department of Natural Resources research specialist. More than 400,000 deer license sales have been reported — about a 15 percent increase over this time in recent years. 

Last year, about 540,000 Michigan hunters killed about 364,000 deer. Typically, a huge surge in deer licenses occurs the week leading to the Nov. 15 firearms opener.

“My biggest theory is that lack of time and lack of access have been the biggest reasons for the past decline. Because of COVID, that may have changed,” Isenhoff said. “The acquisition of meat (venison) is likely a component, too.”  

Meanwhile, the DNR eased regulations this year that should increase the odds of success for some hunters, Chad Stewart, the agency’s top deer specialist, told Bridge Michigan in an email. The changes weren’t motivated by the pandemic “but rather due to the long term hunter declines that we expect to persist in the future," he said.

Changes in the 2020 deer hunting regulation include allowing hunters to kill antlerless deer (does and fawns) with their regular or combo licenses in the Lower Peninsula. Typically, those licenses are restricted to bucks only during the firearms season.

Also this year, private land hunters throughout Michigan can purchase up to 10 antlerless permits to help them better manage deer on their  property. In 2019, the limit was 10 but only in areas where chronic wasting disease, a major concern for the state's deer herds, was present. This year, Stewart said, the higher limit applies statewide to create uniformity.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Mike
Sun, 11/01/2020 - 2:31pm

I'm surprised Whitmer hasn't cancelled deer season.

Jerry
Tue, 11/03/2020 - 12:24pm

You mean to get the GOP legislature back to work? What do they do all day?

Nutty
Sun, 11/01/2020 - 4:07pm

This is the kind of nonsense that is driving people to vote for trump. Is covid real, yes, but not this kind of hysteria. The public is understanding covid cases don't equal deaths or even severe sickness unless your old and unhealthy or have underlying conditions which makes you unhealthy or compromised then you need to be careful with any respiratory virus not just this one and the flu.
What the people are understanding is public officials that seem to be anti trump are using it to shutdown your business or place of employment, take away your income and make you a prisoner in your own home even if you are a healthy person something never done before in the way it is being used now.

I call BS
Tue, 11/03/2020 - 12:26pm

I know, now that Trump killed our economy, we need t hunt for food. If you don't like what you see, vote for Biden Harris! Trump is in way over his head.

Anonymous
Sun, 11/01/2020 - 9:32pm

This could be REALLY bad if aerosolized viruses spread through hunter farts.

Duh
Tue, 11/03/2020 - 12:28pm

How do you think it spread at the White House? You can't eat all that KFC and Big Macs without the consequences.

Peggy Mooney
Mon, 11/02/2020 - 9:24am

I believe that your paper and the democrats will not stop until you have stolen every tradition that we hold dear. Deer hunting in Michigan helps put meals on the table and several deer are donated to feed the hungry. Michigan has already raised the price of a license so high no one even wants to come here and now Bridge Magazine wants to instill more fear just like the good liberal news soldier does.

Anonymous
Mon, 11/02/2020 - 7:00pm

Things like religious rights for genital mutilation of babies?

LmV
Mon, 11/02/2020 - 3:29pm

Cases. How many are positive out of all the cases. It is never mentioned. Cases is another word for testing. A test in process. I commented to the MDHS the same question. And guess what?...no reply.

Sue P
Mon, 11/02/2020 - 7:01pm

Last I heard permit sales are down. Less people enjoy killing animals.