Anatomy of a super spreader: Harper’s outbreak a caution for college bars

Harper’s owners say they’ve commissioned a new “virtual line” app to discourage large crowds from congregating while awaiting entrance to the East Lansing bar. This photo is from March at the beginning of the pandemic. (Bridge photo by Riley Beggin)

As Michigan State University students return to campus this fall, a popular East Lansing restaurant, bar and club hopes to reopen after closing them last month following a COVID-19 outbreak linked to 188 infections. 

But Harper’s Restaurant and Brewpub owners promise things will look very different: No more dancing, loud music or bar service. Instead, masks will be mandatory, doors hands-free, social distancing enhanced and lines managed by an app that will include contact tracing features to help public health officials track the virus in the event of another exposure event. 

“If you get up” from a table to go anywhere other than the bathroom or to leave, “you’re going to be escorted out of the building,” owner Pat Riley told the Michigan Liquor Control Commission on Thursday during a remote meeting by Zoom. “It’s just going to be that simple.”

Commissioners, who have the power to revoke Harper’s liquor license, grilled Pat and Tricia Riley for more than two hours in what could be a test case for how the state treats bars and restaurants that fail to adhere to new COVID-19 safety rules. 

Authorities say the bar did not enforce social distancing or mask rules designed to protect employees and staff. 

To date, 144 patrons – average age 21 – who visited Harper’s from June 12 to June 20 have tested positive for COVID-19, according to Ingham County Health Director Linda Vail, who said that eight-day span qualified as a “super spreader event. Another 44 people caught the virus from those patrons later on, she said. 

Under an agreement reached Thursday, Harper’s will be required to submit safety plans to both the county health department and the Michigan Liquor Control Commission for review and approval before reopening. 

“We do not want the super spreader story to get any worse, for the Rileys or for us or for the young people, mainly 18 to 29, that are all now COVID-positive,” said Pat Gagliardi, who chairs the state liquor commission. 

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer closed bars and restaurant dining rooms in March as the coronavirus slammed Michigan but allowed them to resume in-person service on June 8, provided they adhered to new safety rules. Since late April, residents have also been required to wear masks in enclosed indoor spaces, a rule Whitmer tightened July 10 by adding penalties.

Bars and restaurants are now limited to 50 percent of their normal capacity and are required to maintain social distancing between seated parties. Whitmer orders also direct them to provide physical guides, like signage or floor tape, to ensure that “customers remain at least six feet apart in any lines.” 

Ingham County, home to Michigan State University and dozens of other college bars, has taken additional precautions. Under a local order, bars can only allow a maximum of 125 patrons. 

Harper’s, which operates out of a large facility with multiple spaces and an outdoor patio, is typically allowed to serve up to 950 customers at a time. But it was only allowing 250 people inside at a time when it reopened on June 8. 

Riley said the bar took extra precautions at the time but was not prepared for the swarm of college students that descended on the bar during what would have typically been a quiet Monday. 

Video footage from opening night showed long lines with little social distancing, a crowded dance floor with few masks as customers leaned in to talk over loud tunes. 

“We did not advertise and tell people we were opening on that day,” Riley said. “But as college students are wont to do, they have social media at their fingertips, and the word got out and spread that we were actually open.”

Harper’s had put tables on the dance floor in order to discourage large crowds, but that strategy proved ineffective, Riley said. The bar had tried to follow state rules and federal guidelines, but found no recommendations for how to regulate “common areas, people mingling, or dancing or anything of those natures,” he told commissioners.

Riley acknowledged the bar did not require customers to wear face masks in June. While the bar posted signs and provided free masks to those who wanted one, he said ownership was not aware they had the authority to deny entry to those not wearing one. 

“We thought people had the freedom to deny wearing a face mask,” he said. “We had them at the front door. We wanted them to wear a face mask, but we weren’t going to fight with them at the time.”

The testimony raised questions about how and if other college bars will handle large student crowds this fall. 

“Do you think some of these establishments are too big to have the proper control?” Gagliardi asked Jeff Spitz, a community safety coordinator and liquor liaison officer for the East Lansing police department. 

“My personal opinion on that is, and this comes from over 23 years of dealing with a lot of intoxicated college students, is it is very difficult for an organization that has limited staff members out there trying to control several hundred intoxicated subjects,” Spitz said. 

“It’s a real challenge.”

Harper’s has about 100 employees, and would typically have about 50 to 60 employees working customer-facing jobs on a busy night, Riley said. 

If and when the bar does re-open, a disc jockey will not be among them. 

“Having hindsight, I wish we didn't have the DJ and I wish we had not had any dancing,” Riley acknowledged. “We're going to eliminate loud music so that social distancing measures can be utilized.”

 

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

middle of the mit
Thu, 07/23/2020 - 6:37pm

Once again, business said they didn't need to be talked down by the Governor like children because they know how to run their business and keep customers safe.

Then we get snippets like this : [[[Harper’s had put tables on the dance floor in order to discourage large crowds, but that strategy proved ineffective, Riley said. The bar had tried to follow state rules and federal guidelines, but found no recommendations for how to regulate “common areas, people mingling, or dancing or anything of those natures,” he told commissioners.

Riley acknowledged the bar did not require customers to wear face masks in June. While the bar posted signs and provided free masks to those who wanted one, he said ownership was not aware they had the authority to deny entry to those not wearing one.

“We thought people had the freedom to deny wearing a face mask,” he said. “We had them at the front door. We wanted them to wear a face mask, but we weren’t going to fight with them at the time.”]]]

The Governor didn't tell us we could enforce masks in OUR FACILITY! The Governor didn't tell us how to control our clientele! The Governor wasn't there PERSONALLY to stop our customers from being jerks and not caring about an infectious disease!

Are you going to fight with your customers that still don't want to don a face mask? Maybe this is why you were asked to close in the first place? Because you can't control your clientele!

https://politicalwire.com/2020/07/21/scott-wants-schools-open-but-not-fo...

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/florida-children-test-positive-coronaviru...

https://www.freep.com/story/news/politics/2020/07/12/betsy-devos-chris-w...

But you know so much more than the health experts.......don't ya?

Kevin
Thu, 07/23/2020 - 8:40pm

Thousands of high school classes packed with 30+ 17-18 year old seniors coming to a neighborhood near you.

CharlieD
Fri, 07/24/2020 - 8:22am

So how many people actually died from this "event"? Because it looks like all of these people are in the 0% risk category. If that is the case, then how is this even news?

Jake
Fri, 07/24/2020 - 2:17pm

Agreed, Charlie. I no longer pay attention to the daily covid stats, because I just don’t care...and I’m in the high risk age group. I monitor my local environment closely and match my behavior to the risks at hand. I live without fear because I have a God who will take care of me regardless. I can easily imagine a future in which we’ll be subject to quarantine and contact tracing for every common cold, virus, influenza and other transmittable illnesses. WHY?

Al
Fri, 09/18/2020 - 11:48am

This is mid September and I haven't heard of a single death from this "incident."

Guess what? Now all these kids who got the virus can safely interact with their grandparents! That's great news!

Ouchez
Fri, 07/24/2020 - 9:45am

Except for 3 Michigan restaurants I have been in Covid safety precautions are NOT being followed!! I have basically stopped eating out again. Bars should NOT be open and Restaurants should not be allowed to serve alcohol. Greed on the part of restaurant bar owners and the Whitmir administration will keep this disaster going far longer than it has too!! Deputize people like me to go around and ticket these bars and restaurants when we see these gross violations and results will soon be seen. As of now, it is all a bad joke. :(

A. Bellows
Mon, 07/27/2020 - 8:16am

I haven't heard that alcohol causes covid. This is news.

John
Fri, 07/24/2020 - 10:10am

VAPING!
I personally know a patron who was at Harpers that week. Luckily she tested negative. She confirmed that many many patrons were vaping in the bar. The vaping pipes are routinely passed around and shared with the group. I can not think of a better way to spread any respiratory virus. Could this be the cause of the super spreader event? Maybe the Governor should look into banning vaping instead of closing down every bar in the state?

A.R.Eynon
Fri, 07/24/2020 - 11:00am

Hundreds of college-age patrons descended upon a venue and no on asks where they went next that night? I vaguely recall being in that age group. Sharing drinks and kissing each other was sort of common. I've heard that young people today even pass joints around just like they did in the good old "it's illegal" days. And then we have "hook-ups"--which is where many of those patrons went next that night.
So, I cannot head down to the Gaelic League and have a pint while listening to a live performer because Whitmer and her ilk don't want to even acknowledge that controlling the social and sex lives of young adults is impossible without closing each and every public space? Even the USSR and Eastern Communist Block countries were unable to exert that level of control over the drive to procreate.
Instead, Whitmer legally whips adults trying to make a living or just enjoying a pint and some no-contact company at a social club. How long is it until we can replace that self-appointed Queen? What will be left of our public spaces?

open your eyes
Fri, 07/24/2020 - 1:30pm

Harper's told the LCC yesterday how their door guys are the best in the business. LOOK AT THE DOOR GUY IN THIS PHOTO! Gloves on to check ID's but NO mask. Was the door guy COVID-positive? Were the bartenders wearing masks? Were any of them COVID-positive? Was Harper's asked about their knowledge of COVID-positive employees? Or how many days they may have stayed open with such knowledge?

A. Bellows
Mon, 07/27/2020 - 8:13am

Will Tinder require masks?