Michigan budget breakthrough in works as Gretchen Whitmer, GOP near deal


The bills come after weeks of back-and-forth between Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and GOP leaders. (Bridge photo by Dale G. Young)

LANSING – A months-long budget standoff could be nearing an end, as Michigan lawmakers moved bills Wednesday to reappropriate some $573.5 million of the nearly $1 billion Gov. Gretchen Whitmer line-item vetoed from the state’s 2020 budget.

Millions of dollars would be returned to programs that fund rural police patrols, charter schools, isolated school districts, county jails, autism programming and rural hospitals, among others. The bills would also reverse millions of dollars worth of transfers Whitmer made using a rare maneuver with the State Administrative Board in October. 

The bills passed unanimously in the Senate and nearly unanimously in the House. One notable absence from the deal is funding to continue the Pure Michigan advertising campaign.

“While this does not restore all of the governor's vetoes and transfers, it is a good first step in the right direction,” said Senate Appropriations Chair Jim Stamas. “It is my hope this is the last time any of these programs are caught in the political crossfire.”

Amber McCann, spokeswoman for Senate Majority Leader Mike Shirkey, said the proposals were shaped with input from both GOP leaders and Whitmer. The more than $400 million left over from Whitmer’s cuts would likely be reappropriated early next year.

“This is an important, bipartisan step forward for our state to ensure we are providing essential services to Michigan families and (Whitmer) is hopeful we can finalize it next week,” spokeswoman Tiffany Brown said in a statement Wednesday evening.

Both chambers approved identical versions of the legislation, and it must be approved by the other before being sent to the governor and could be changed before then. 

They also moved two bills that would affect the budget process: One would require the Legislature to send the budget to the governor by July 1 each year, and the other would restrict the powers of the State Administrative Board. 

Top aides for the GOP leaders said the bill containing board changes is a “shell bill” that doesn’t represent final policy — the bill is expected to be changed next week when GOP leaders reach an agreement with Whitmer.  

“I think the fact that we’re moving on bills suggests that there is significant progress than we’ve seen previously, but it is still an evolving negotiation,” McCann said. 

Both Republicans and Democrats are getting some of their preferred programs back under the supplemental spending bills.

Among the GOP-favorite programs that would be restored: $7 million for isolated school districts; $1.25 million for Autism Navigator, which provides resources for families with autism; nearly $22 million for rural hospital and ob-gyn services; $13.1 million for secondary road patrols; $5 million for summer school reading programs; $10.5 million for early childhood reading coaches; $10 million for school safety measures; $35 million for charter schools; and $27.4 million in funding for counties that house public lands.

Several other items were included at the governor’s request: $2 million to help the Secretary of State’s office implement the independent redistricting commission; $13 million for urban public transit systems; $10.5 million for training new corrections officers; $4.5 million to replace GPS trackers for parolees; $4.5 million for lead paint abatement; $3.9 million to implement new Medicaid work requirements; $3.2 million for implementing the no-fault auto insurance package; $15 million for IT upgrades; and $10 million for 2020 Census support among others. 

The bills come after weeks of back-and-forth between Whitmer and GOP leaders. 

Republicans were incensed by Whitmer’s use of the Administrative Board to shift $625 million within departments, which they perceived to be a violation of the separation of powers. She said the transfers were necessary after the Legislature passed the budget without her input, itself a rare move. Republicans contended she walked away from negotiations.

Whitmer and Chatfield appeared to reach a deal three weeks ago, but it fell through when Shirkey insisted a restriction on the Administrative Board’s powers be codified in law. 

That’s the element of the deal that remains the most fluid: The top aides to GOP leaders said Wednesday the final agreement will be negotiated over the weekend and likely finalized next week.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


J. Katakowski
Thu, 12/05/2019 - 6:48am

Absolutely no money to charter schools. $35 million appropriated for the charter school industry..... the largest of, all in the budget. Gov. Whitmer this should be a stopper no more money to charter schools when the GOP has seized so many funds from our public schools already. We need to make all public schools great again. We have wasted far too much money on these laboratory charters to fill the pockets of private industry and Betsy DeVos and family.

Fri, 12/06/2019 - 8:27am

3 questions to clarify your position.

What evidence do you have that Betsy DeVos received one cent of money that went to charters?
Would it make any difference if a charter school were to be organized as a non-profit entity?
What public school do you work for?

J. Katakowski
Sat, 12/07/2019 - 9:43am

Betsy DeVos has supported privatization for a long time both charter and religious education. If you need proof go search for it yourself.
If the charter school was monitored by a public school totally. Not a private or public college miles away with no direct supervision ( too many ripoffs and persons getting caught with monies that never went to our youngsters ) . I do not work for a public school as of present. Hope that clarifies your concern Matt.
Not sure how that is relevant unless you are one of those folks that think that most teachers go into the profession to become $$ millionaires and they only work as glorified babysitters for their total summers off.

Mon, 12/09/2019 - 8:25am

YOU have stated Betsy DeVos received payments somehow from the charter schools!!! READ YOUR POST!!! WHERE IS YOUR EVIDENCE???? Or is this just MEA crap?
So being nonprofit only matters if the public school somehow has its hooks in them? As if they have any better clue what the problems and solutions are?
Obviously you are getting some benefit by forcing every school/student to be beholden to the public schools here, so it's reasonable for you to answer the question, what public school (or teacher union) do you work for?

Tue, 12/10/2019 - 1:08pm

DeVos is just trying to get rid of Title IX, teach children about God and protect them from potential grizzlies. She likes Jesus Camp.

Jon c
Sun, 12/08/2019 - 1:34pm

Ridiculous comment. Charters are saving the kids of detroit from the nasty bigoted teacher unions and their allies who have destroyed millions of young poor minority kids futures. Vitti wil wash out in a few more years....there are rumors he ahs already put feelers out ther but hes got the union on his side with the pay raises. The only thing saving publicly funded education in mi is the charters and a few distrocts with a high number of well educated stay at home moms who keep these union teacher miscreants somewhat honest.

Bob Dunn
Thu, 12/05/2019 - 8:46am

I do not see any money generated to fix the roads. Instead of just giving money to charter schools we need better policies regarding these for-profit businesses. I would suggest you start looking at what Massachusetts is doing as a starter.