Michigan lawmakers jump to head of COVID vaccine line, as seniors scramble
As thousands of seniors scramble for the coronavirus vaccine, some politicians in southeast Michigan are jumping to the front of line with the help of their local governments.
Oakland County and Detroit have offered the vaccine to politicians, with Oakland offering it to state legislators and county commissioners and Detroit offering it to legislators and city council members. Macomb County allows elected municipal leaders to sign up as well.
That decision appalls state Rep. John Reilly, R-Oakland Township, who was offered the vaccine by Oakland County officials. At 63, he’s not old enough to be part of the current priority.
He’s healthy and declined the offer because thousands of older constituents qualify for the vaccine and still can’t get it, Reilly said.
“Why would the county be doing such a thing?” Reilly asked during a House Oversight Committee hearing Thursday morning.
- As Michigan scrambles for COVID vaccines, what to do about line cutters
- Michigan isn’t sure who’s getting the COVID vaccine. That’s a big problem
- Michigan makes gains on COVID vaccines at nursing homes; other seniors wait
- Five ethical questions raised by COVID vaccines in Michigan
- Six things to know about the safety of the leading COVID vaccines
The decisions to prioritize public officials appear in conflict with established priority groups that currently favor people 65 years old and older — or a liberal interpretation of “frontline workers.”
Oakland County confirmed it had offered the vaccine to state representatives, senators, and county commissioners, saying they were part of the “vital public interest during the pandemic.”
“Our lawmakers at the state and county level need to remain healthy so they can convene and vote on measures that support COVID response, vaccinations, and other key issues,” the county said in a statement released by spokesperson Bill Mullan.
A spokesperson for Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan offered a similar rationale for vaccinating state legislators and City Council members.
“City, state, and federal employees who live or work in Detroit and whose jobs result in frequent contact with the public, including state legislators whose duties entail extensive public interaction, are eligible to schedule appointments,” the spokesperson, John Roach, said in a statement to Bridge Michigan.
Michigan gives counties and municipalities some discretion in administering the vaccines, so there’s nothing illegal about giving it to politicians before some seniors.
But it strikes many as wrong, and some lawmakers want state health officials to crack down.
“I think that’s got to be addressed at some point,” said state Rep. Steve Johhnson, R-Wayland, the chair of the House Oversight Committee. “I think there should be strings attached.”
Other states have prioritized legislators, including Missouri, Illinois and Colorado, and the U.S. Congress was offered vaccines as well to allow for the “continuity of government.”
Officials for other Michigan counties, including Kent, Ingham, Washtenaw and Calhoun told Bridge Michigan they didn’t prioritize elected officials.
“No elected official has been offered a vaccine by the Kent County Health Department, based solely on the fact that they are an elected official,” said Steve Kelso, a spokesperson for Kent County.
The county has hired an ethicist to help make sure its vaccine rollout is equitable among demographic groups, Kelso said.
In Wayne County, the vaccine was offered to elected officials including judges, commissioners and countywide officeholders — but they had to be 65 or older, spokesperson Bill Nowling said.
Macomb County, the state’s third most populous county, has “not prioritized state representatives or elected officials,” spokesperson Scott Turske told Bridge. But municipal elected officials, as city, village and township employees, would be eligible, Turske said, because of their frequent contact with the public.
Elizabeth Hertel, new director of the Michigan Department of Health and Human Services, told state representatives Thursday the state wants local vaccine providers to follow the priority lists the state has established, which currently call for healthcare workers, those over 65 and some essential workers like teachers to get the vaccine.
“Our hope is that they’re not doing whatever they want,” Hertel said.
But there is wiggle room for local officials. Lynn Sutfin, a state health spokesperson, said the state has “encouraged providers” to follow the guidelines that focus on people 65 and older.
Yet, “local health departments have the option to prioritize the groups within the guidance they feel are most at risk and at highest need of vaccination,” she said in a statement to Bridge.
In recent weeks, the vaccination distribution has prompted debate about “line cutting” to get a vaccine that has been relatively scarce.
Michigan, despite having one of the better records of vaccinations, has still only seen just over 8 percent of its population get at least the first of the two required doses.
Thousands are frustrated daily by Internet and telephone appointment systems as they scramble to get the vaccine for the virus that has left nearly 14,800 dead in Michigan since last March.
Over 77 percent of those who have died are 70 and older.
Even with 50,000 vaccines a day being administered, Hertel told the committee that many people who aren’t in the first priority groups won’t be vaccinated til the end of the year.
State representatives asked Hertel if the state could do anything to prevent a healthcare provider from going outside the existing priority system. She did not directly answer that question.
See what new members are saying about why they donated to Bridge Michigan:
- “In order for this information to be accurate and unbiased it must be underwritten by its readers, not by special interests.” - Larry S.
- “Not many other media sources report on the topics Bridge does.” - Susan B.
- “Your journalism is outstanding and rare these days.” - Mark S.
If you want to ensure the future of nonpartisan, nonprofit Michigan journalism, please become a member today. You, too, will be asked why you donated and maybe we'll feature your quote next time!