Michigan’s Republican Legislature sends budgets to Whitmer — vetoes expected

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer has roughly a week to decide whether to pass the budget priorities of the Republican-led Legislature, or veto proposals on roads, schools and voting matters that she strongly opposes. (Bridge file photo by Riley Beggin)

Update: Michigan government won’t shut down, state tells workers

The Michigan Legislature voted Tuesday to pass the majority of the state budget to Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, who is expected to veto portions of the  GOP-crafted plans before the end of the fiscal year on Sept. 30.

The budgets — largely opposed by each chamber’s Democratic minority — include multiple items likely to come under scrutiny from Whitmer, including reduced funding for a new state redistricting commission and a plan to withhold portions of jail funding to counties with “sanctuary” policies. 

Related: Michigan GOP budget contains 7 big surprises for Gov. Gretchen Whitmer

The largest outstanding question is whether Whitmer will choose to veto $400 million of additional one-time funding earmarked for fixing the state’s crumbling roads and bridges. The $400 million includes $132 million accelerated from a 2015 road funding plan, $25 million dedicated to the local bridge program and $243 million dedicated to other bridge projects ($68 million of that is earmarked for four specific bridges in Dearborn, Ferrysburg, Harrison Township and Lansing.)

The hike to the transportation budget falls far short of the $2.5 billion annually Whitmer sought to add for state infrastructure fixes, a total in line with the estimates of independent experts. Her differences with Republican legislative leaders led to a breakdown in talks with the GOP earlier this month. 

House Speaker Lee Chatfield said the budgets passed Tuesday reflected a willingness “to put people before politics,” and in a jab at Whitmer, he added: 

“Even though the governor chose not to be a part of the process and hasn’t put in any work on the budget in weeks, representatives and senators from both parties banded together to do the right thing for the people we represent and get this done.”

Whitmer, in turn, called the budgets sent to her desk “a total mess.”

“Michiganders deserve better. It’s time for Republicans to stop playing games and put a real road funding solution on the table that keeps drivers safe, ensures our roads get fixed with the right materials and mix, and makes road repairs now so costs don’t keep going up over the long run,” she said.

Since announcing her own budget proposal last March, Whitmer has been pushing a 45-cent-per-gallon increase in the state gas tax, which she said would raise the $2.5 billion experts agree is necessary to fix state infrastructure. 

But that plan proved dead on arrival at the Republican-led legislature. Senate Majority Leader Mike Shirkey and Chatfield balked at the tax increase, which would make Michigan’s fuel tax the highest in the nation. The three were in a stalemate until early September, when Whitmer agreed to table talks about road funding until after the overall budget was passed, in a bid to avoid a government shutdown

Whitmer has opposed the one-time funding for roads included in the current budget; one-time funding only makes long-term funding more challenging because it prevents adequate planning, she said earlier this month

Shirkey and Chatfield have said they’re still committed to a long-term funding plan and that one-time funding wouldn’t prevent them from continuing to seek solutions after the Sept. 30 deadline. 

Shirkey has said he knows that line-item vetoes from the governor are likely to come, but told the Lansing-based subscription political news site Gongwer over the weekend that certain big-ticket vetoes would hurt their relationship and could hamper negotiations going forward. 

Whitmer must also decide whether to strike other controversial parts of the budgets, including a major cut to Democratic Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson’s general fund budget, which in turn would reduce expected funding to a still-to-be-created statewide redistricting commission approved by state voters in November. The commission will replace the state’s current method of drawing state and congressional political boundaries in Michigan in which the political party controlling Lansing draws the lines, which for many election cycles has been Republicans. Funding for the commission is tied to Benson’s budget in the state constitution.

In the budget passed Tuesday, Republicans also included a requirement that Democratic Attorney General Dana Nessel — who has been particularly litigious against President Trump’s administration since entering office — go before the Legislature to explain why she decided to enter or file suits against the federal government, as well as a requirement that county jails in counties with “sanctuary” policies be denied reimbursement for housing felons that would otherwise go to state prison. 

Last week, the Legislature also passed an education budget to Whitmer that would add $30 million more for special education students with surprise help from House Democrats, who broke with the governor to approve the plan. That budget, however, did not add more money to help low-income and other vulnerable public school students across the state, as Whitmer has demanded. 

Whitmer is allowed to line-item veto most portions of the budget. Any vetoes can only be overridden by a two-thirds vote of the state legislature. Republicans do not have a supermajority that would allow them to override vetoes without the help of Democrats.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


You're Right
Wed, 09/25/2019 - 8:38am

I say shut down the government. It's time for the GOP to stop treating our country like a Banana Republic. We don't want to turn our roads back to gravel, especially in Macomb County. Now we know why they won't fix the roads. Their plan all along was to return them to gravel. That's what you get when the legislative leadership of our great state comes from two small towns in northern Michigan. As long as the narrow main thoroughfares in their districts are paved, to hell with the commuters in the major cities stuck in constant traffic. Well, we are the main source of revenue for the roads, in every respect, and the revenues are not divided fairly. Lastly, when we go to spend our hard earned money up north, it irritates the hell out of us that we waste a good hour or more in traffic trying to leave the cities because the roads are so bad. Please show some gratitude for your tax base provided by the large metropolitan areas.

Mike Watza
Wed, 09/25/2019 - 10:24am

The governor has been put in an impossible situation, having been offered a political hatchet job instead of an actual budget that could have dutifully fulfilled the expressed will of the people as of our last election. Instead of working toward solutions for all of Michigan, she is stuck wrestling with a legislative majority, which holds that majority only because of its own unlawful gerrymandering over the last several decades.
It is most telling that at the core of this legislative slight of hand, the proposed budget again rejects the expressed will of the people by defunding and interfering with formation of the voter approved commission tasked with ending that same gerrymandering.
Sad. Very sad.

middle of the mit
Tue, 09/24/2019 - 10:16pm

Shame on you Bridge! Why did you not report that Mike Shirkey says he want's Michigan to go gravel?


Michigan Senate GOP leader: Time to return some paved roads to gravel

And then Republicans want to steal money from other road and bridge repairs to fund their budget?

You can not trust these people.

They don't care.

Wed, 09/25/2019 - 6:38am

If she doesn’t, Michigan will be trapped in the same place it has been for over a decade.
Time to do what is right....Fix the damned roads!

Jack Johnson
Wed, 09/25/2019 - 8:48am

This budget is a joke. Veto it, please.

Gary Lea
Wed, 09/25/2019 - 9:47am

I applaud three commenters here; You're Right, middle of the mit and Jack Johnson.

Wed, 09/25/2019 - 10:15am

The people of Michigan are paying attention now and understand how an illegal legislature has been in control for the past ten years. The Republicans have twisted the truth so much, they don't even know what it is anymore.

Make no mistake about it. The Republicans have taken the state of MI down to the level of southern states (think Alabama and Mississippi) in regards to funding for schools, roads and quality of life in a short ten year period.

The people have spoken on gerrymandering and this budget will not fund the process because they know once the districts are drawn in a fair and independent way, the real voice of the people will be expressed. Continue to pay attention taxpayers!!