As Mackinac Island empties for winter, COVID arrives for a stay

In July, business “began to boom and it didn’t stop,” said carriage driver Heather Alzner. (Bridge photo By Robin Erb)

MACKINAC ISLAND — Michigan’s Mackinac Island locked down its 2020 tourism season on Sunday under steely cold skies. 

And though the season was largely successful despite pandemic disruptions this spring and early summer, the island is hanging onto an unwelcome inhabitant: the novel coronavirus.

After skirting large outbreaks through the heart of summer, COVID-19 cases climbed to 53 Friday among the island’s year-round residents and what’s left of its seasonal workforce. On this small island community, which has a year-round population of roughly 500, the numbers are ominous. 

Related stories:

“I never knew a soul from the health department,” Tim Hygh, executive director of the Mackinac Island Tourism Bureau, said of the virus. “Now I talk to them at least once a week.


In retrospect, it’s “amazing” that the island, which draws more than a million visitors a year, escaped a surge this long, said summer resident Melanie Libby, who opened a small business in June, Great Turtle Brewery and Distillery, with co-owner Ira Green. 

“We knew it was out there, and when we have hundreds of thousands of visitors each summer, I’m sure one or two of those folks had COVID, and maybe they didn’t even know it,” Libby said.

Keeping the island COVID-free, she said, “can be a goal and a hope, but it was probably unrealistic.”

Autumn alerts 

Mackinac remained relatively COVID-free until fall. 

But in a series of alerts in late September, the four-county LMAS District Health Department found COVID exposure at several island sites: on ferry trips and a handful of shops and restaurants. Officials released no details about the cases, leaving Mackinac’s regulars to wonder whether those infected were island visitors, workers or year-round residents. 

Health authorities said they were not able to trace infections to a single event or person. Rather, Mackinac Island was the victim of "community spread" that was probably linked to growing "pandemic fatigue," as island residents and guests set aside social distancing and other safety protocols.

“It’s not that people were forgetting, they were just tired of it,” said Carlos Villegas, 28, a barista at the Lucky Bean Coffeehouse.

By mid-October, there were 26 cases among temporary and permanent residents on the island, before jumping to 53 confirmed infections Friday, LMAS spokeswoman Kerry Ott said.

Mackinac may be an island, but it was not immune to trends in the wider region. The four counties covered by the health agency (Luce, Mackinac, Alger, Schoolcraft) had seen infections climb 167 percent between Oct. 1 and Friday, to 358 cases. 

For island residents, the timing is not fantastic. The virus is surging just as ferry service scales down on Sunday, and as the island’s only medical clinic cuts down to part-time hours on weekdays only.

If Mackinac’s first goal — to remain COVID-free — seemed unrealistic, the second is just as nerve-racking for those whose businesses, like Libby’s, survive or perish based on how they perform in the six-month tourism window. 

“The second goal was ‘Let’s make it to 2021,’” said Hygh of the tourism bureau. As COVID-19 bore down on the state, he said, “we had no idea what was in front of us.”

Would there be a summer? 

Early this spring — a time when merchants are usually cleaning and stocking up for summer — island business owners and managers were in lockdown like the rest of Michigan. All but essential businesses were shuttered as COVID-19 ripped through southeast Michigan then spread through the state, ultimately killing thousands, triggering an ugly and angry political divide, and disrupting the economy.

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer announced in May that bars and restaurants in northern MIchigan and the Upper Peninsula would be able to open on Memorial Day weekend. Great news, though some folks on Mackinac wondered: Would anyone even come?

Weekend tourists boarded ferries Sunday at Mackinac Island, some wearing hats and gloves. The iconic Michigan destination was packed in the final summer months, but remained relatively COVID-19 free until the past month. (Bridge photo By Robin Erb)

Spring school tours to the island had been canceled. Tour groups of retirees dried up. Weddings and convention business – gone.

“Going into the season, there was a lot of uncertainty. It was scary,” said Dominick Miller, marketing manager at Mackinac State Historic Parks.

Under the new summer rules for northern Michigan, dining rooms were limited to half capacity and tables were to be spread out to ensure at least 6 feet between parties. Masks were required.

“We’re a secluded island with limited medical resources, and we didn’t know how tourists would react to the rules in place,” Miller said. “We didn’t know if they’d even come. We’d lost almost two months of revenue.” 

“April, May, June — all disasters,” said Chris Shepler, a third-generation member of the popular ferry service, now in its 75th year. Shepler’s unveiled its newest fleet member this year, the $4.5 million, 210-passenger, jet-powered vessel called the William Richard.

But with COVID?

“I said, if we are still here in 2021, it will be a success,” he said.

But by July Fourth, cooped-up, pandemic-weary Michiganders were on the move again, and Mackinac offered just what they needed: family-friendly, wide-open spaces.

“We had full boats coming over every single day,” said Todd Callewaert, owner of several restaurants and island fudge shops.

Business owners put out calls to locals, such as Heather Alzner, 29, who drove horse-drawn carriages this summer, and plans to stay through the year. 

“It began to boom and it didn’t stop. It didn’t matter if you worked in a bank, or what, they were ‘We need you,’” she said.

On Sunday morning, as some of the season’s last guests wandered past “closed for the season” signs and end-of-season sales, Alzner hauled final loads of customer luggage from the island. By next weekend, most island workers will be gone as well. 

An island transformed   

Even as the sun shone warm and bright this summer, visitors arrived to a different Mackinac.

Plexiglass shields separated tour groups. There were fewer horse-drawn carriages and bike racks on the streets to allow visitors to space out as they wandered off sidewalks.

Masks were required nearly everywhere in public, as they were elsewhere in Michigan.

In keeping with the horse-drawn carriage theme, signs reminded guests to “wash your hooves.” 

Behind the scenes, the island’s ubiquitous rental bikes were wiped down each time they were returned, and then again when they went out, said Green, who is also in the bike shop business. 

Hotels invested in cleaning equipment – special electrostatic disinfectant sprayers that cost nearly $1,000 each, Libby said. Business leaders and community health leaders were in regular communication. 

The pandemic also aggravated worker shortages. 

Before the Fourth of July rush, businesses had been unable to hire a full staff. With the uncertainty of businesses opening and closing, employers found it difficult to woo seasonal workers to northern Michigan. 

Those workers traditionally lived in dormitories where they often lived two or more in a room. But to limit the spread of COVID, Miller said, each staff worker had to have his or her own room, adding to business costs. 

The parks system cut staff by about 40 percent. The iconic Grand Hotel cut its capacity to just 50 percent, said Hygh at the tourism bureau.

The cozy, 80-seat Winchester’s, a Main Street restaurant owned by Libby, remained shuttered. Cozy is usually a lure for visitors.  

But “no one wanted quaint this summer,” Libby said.

There were a few tense moments. 

Shepler said there was an occasional ferry customer that didn’t want to wear a mask. Shop owners had similar tales. “We’d get someone unhappy every day about having to wear a mask, and they’d just walk out,” said Greg VanDusen, who owns three island souvenir and clothing shops. 

His stores, packed with T-shirts, stuffed animals, trinkets and people, made some employees nervous. One quit, saying it was simply too much.

mackinac masks

Visitors found a different Mackinac Island this year — plastic dividers, social-distancing protocols, mask requirements. Longtime shop owner Greg VanDusen sold masks, even as the occasional customer walked out in frustration over the rules. (Bridge photo By Robin Erb)

But for the most part, guests followed social distancing and other safety protocols without complaint, VanDusen and others said.

Green said his bike shop business had fewer customers for much of the summer, but guests kept their bikes longer. Open spaces and quiet, he said, offered a reprieve from the anxiety of the pandemic. 

“I think we might have saved a lot of marriages,” he quipped.

The tourist resurgence in the second half of the summer helped boost visitors to more than 70 percent of a normal year, Hygh estimated. But anxiety was never far from the surface. 

Musician Mark Bowen, 45, said business owners did their best to enforce rules and guests, for the most part, were agreeable. Still, he was nervous.

“I was leery about working over there this summer, but the money is good, so it’s hard to say no,” Bowen said.  

He was routinely tested for COVID and they always came back negative. But in late September, Bowen said he started “feeling weird.” He tested positive Sept. 30. 

Callewaert, owner of the restaurants and fudge shops, had kept two of his eateries closed through the season, unable to hire enough staff. On Oct. 11 he said he was forced to close another after a worker was infected with COVID-19.

A more distant island 

On Sunday, the sun laid low — a toggle switch of sorts on the island.

The last large batch of seasonal workers were leaving; the two main ferry services wrapped up their weekends.

Many of the hotels, restaurants and fudge shops — businesses that rely on warm-weather tourists — were locked away, as were the Fort Mackinac Visitors Center and dozens of other island mainstays — some had closed early after the pandemic canceled traditional Halloween bashes.

What happens now is unclear.

As tourism and summer commerce dry up, island residents hope COVID transmission will fade with it. But those remaining will now have less readily available transportation off the island as the lakes freeze, locking boats into place. The island’s medical clinic will be open for limited weekday hours.

The nearest hospital is in St. Ignace, accessible in the dead of winter only for emergencies. There’s an airport or rescue boat in those cases. A ferry boat transported an ambulance to the island last spring — before the tourist season — for a patient struggling to breath from COVID-19, Shepler said.

Bowen, the musician, said he never became seriously ill from the virus, but he’s fatigued these days and sometimes experiences “brain fog.” 

From the warmth of the Lucky Bean coffee shop, Villegas said that he is not overly worried about what will come. He’s from southern California, but said he will remain on the island this year — his first winter.

During a deadly pandemic, why not? 

“I figure,” he said, “what better place to get away from it all than a frozen island?” 

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


Biden Harris 2020!
Mon, 10/26/2020 - 12:31am

It didn't have to be this way.

Mon, 10/26/2020 - 1:19am

Absolutely stunning the lack of empathy and knowledge. Wish I could have been spared from covid19. Completely healthy until virus was essential worker and got covid19. Now had heart stent put in , stage 3 kidney disease and Lund scarring. Will probably be disabled for life. Wear a mask , you have no right to take a chance on shortening or ending another American citizens life because of a freaking mask

Mon, 10/26/2020 - 5:59pm

come on, sounds like a few pre existing conditions or life habits just waiting for a disaster because the effects and symptoms are not those listed for this virus. Maybe you are shooting for social security disability? These days you won't need all those reasons just mainly a desire not to work, like some of my neighbors.
I'm sorry your in such bad shape. Others seem to do just fine, for them it's just a bad respiratory virus and others a simple head cold and for some nothing at all. Very few die or experience what you are saying, like 1.4% I read on worldometers something like that, good luck though. We just got to hope not to many are like you or lose their jobs or places to work because who will pay for all the people not working?

Mon, 10/26/2020 - 3:56am

Completely unsurprising that there are that many cases. When my husband and I stayed on the island in mid October we were shocked at the recklessness of workers and guests considering it's the middle of a pandemic. We took Sheplers ferry and on both trips we noticed not only were guests not wearing masks properly if at all but the staff were not as well. We took taxis all of two times to get to and from our Airbnb, opting to not use it the last time back to the ferry home due to the fact that they were packing ten guests onto a taxi ment for nine people. After reading this article I'm extremely glad we chose to walk the two miles instead.

Linda Kantz
Mon, 10/26/2020 - 7:56am

Unbelievable! Instead of wearing masks he thinks we need to learn to live with the virus? And to think we elect morons like this to govern us. Instead of wearing masks, we could die from this virus and if we don't who knows what the long term affects will be. Oh, maybe he thinks he knows.

Sandy P
Mon, 10/26/2020 - 2:46pm

I pray we have a blue tsunami on the federal and the state levels. Our votes are the only way to change things. We need to vote in every election. There are too many crazy trumpists/extremists in power.