Michigan coronavirus caseloads haven’t budged in months. Why that’s not bad.

Nearly every day, Michigan reports about as many new coronavirus cases as there were in mid-May, when much of the state was shut down, schools were closed, hospitals were swamped and funeral homes were overrun.

 

Colleges are battling outbreaks as they open, and counties like Macomb in metro Detroit are amid spikes in cases.

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer on Thursday cited the caseloads and risks of outbreaks among students in extending her state of emergency until Oct. 1

Time to panic? Not at all, public health officials tell Bridge Michigan.

In fact, the numbers instead suggest that increased testing has changed the arc of the pandemic and is finding more asymptomatic patients, say epidemiologists and health officials who prefer a glass-half-full view of elevated caseloads.

Compare, for instance, the first two weeks of May (when there were 600 cases per day) to the past two weeks of August and September (when there were 670 per day.): 

  • In early May, hospitals treated 1,875 people daily for COVID-19, and 1,036 died in the first two weeks of the month. Statewide, 13,000 people were tested per day and 7 percent were positive.
  • In the past two weeks, daily hospitalizations are down a third to 633, and there are six times fewer deaths, 164. Testing averages 29,000 per day, and the positive rate is just above 3 percent, a metric Gov. Gretchen Whitmer has often cited as a guide for reopening parts of the economy.

Understanding the numbers is important because they undergird so many policy decisions as classes resume at school districts and colleges statewide and Whitmer considers reopening more of the economy.

In the early days of the pandemic, Michigan had among the highest caseloads nationwide, but it now is 18th nationwide among states with about 115,000 confirmed and suspected cases.  

Whitmer has moved slower than peers nationwide, saying she is guided by science and numbers (which she hasn’t always made clear) and on Thursday ordered the reopening of gyms in lower Michigan, one of the last segments of the economy to remain closed. 

How to view cases

At its peak in late March and early April, the pandemic brought more than 1,300 cases per day to Michigan in late March and early April, before numbers began to fall. 

They declined to an average of 300 cases or fewer for much of June before lurching back up again as the lockdown eased. Since July 1, the state has averaged just over 630 cases per day. The current seven-day avage is 650.

That’s a two-month plateau despite modest swings. Good news or bad?

 

“When I look at this information, I’m looking at trends: Are we going up or going down?” said Derel Glashower, senior epidemiologist of the Ottawa County Health Department,  who spoke to Bridge about trends before Whitmer extended the emergency.

By that measure, the relative stability of the numbers is positive, he said. If there are quick spikes, that can indicate community spread — the biggest fear of public health officials because it can require dramatic responses like March’s stay-at-home order.

Though the state has seen coronavirus case counts remain steady, Derel Glashower, senior epidemiologist for Ottawa County, says there are positive signs. (courtesy photo)

But cases alone do not tell the entire story. It also matters who they are, where they are, and the rates per 100,000. 

Early in the pandemic, the highest number of cases were in metro Detroit, and struck two groups particularly hard: African Americans (more than 40 percent of cases) and the elderly (1 in 3 deaths are in nursing homes).

Now the disease is found throughout the state, from the bigger cities to the sparsely populated counties in the Upper Peninsula. And increasingly, it’s infecting younger people who are typically more resilient to the disease.

In the first three months of the pandemic, 36 percent of the infected were over 60 years old and just 8 percent were under 30. 

Since then, just 17 percent are older than 60, while 43 percent are under 30.

“It’s younger, more spread out than it used to be,” said Dr. Matthew Sims, the director of infectious diseases research at Beaumont Health, the Southfield-based health system that is Michigan’s largest.

Those changes in who’s getting infected and where they live changes how to view the total number of cases. 

Glashower said “700 cases in April would be an eyebrow raiser.” 

Now, it is not.

How to view hospitalizations and deaths

Those geographic and demographic changes have had a positive effect on outcomes.

Matthew Sims, director of infectious diseases research at Beaumont Health in metro Detroit, said Michigan residents should remain cautious and practice social distancing, mask wearing and good hygiene. (courtesy photo)

On April 9, at the height of the pandemic’s rampage in southeast Michigan, Beaumont Health had 1,206 COVID-19 patients. On Aug. 31, that number was 177 and as of Tuesday, there were 617 across the state.

Looking back at April, Sims said the impact on Beaumont was incredible. 

“It was hell. We had high deaths and we had high admissions rates.”

Those bad days receded as the stay-at-home order had an impact, minimizing contact among people and, therefore, transmission. 

By June, admissions were rare. Now, the overall patient numbers are lower than April but a few are admitted every day at a steady, though low, rate.

“It’s not like it was in April but it’s not like it was in June,” Sims said.

 

Without a vaccine or known therapeutic treatment to assist those who fall ill, Michigan, like much of the world, locked down large parts of the economy.

The goal was to “flatten the curve,” to create the “possibility of our health-care organizations to be able to meet demand,” Glashower said.

That’s largely happened: There is plenty of space in most Michigan hospitals and COVID-19 census counts have stabilized. In Ottawa County, for example, fewer than 5 of the three hospitals’ 206 beds are currently occupied by a COVID-19 patient, data shows.

 

The disease is still deadly, however, and it was blamed for 286 deaths in August. That’s less than 10 percent of the 3,500 who died in April from COVID-19. 

But it would still equal over 3,400 a year, much higher than the number of deaths caused by pneumonia or the flu every year, which are classified as the same and are the ninth leading cause of death with 1,700 and 1,900 deaths annually from 2015 to 2018.

Overall in 2020, COVID-19 has been blamed on 6,500 deaths statewide, which would make it the No. 3  cause of deaths after heart disease and cancer.

How to view testing

Early in the pandemic, it was hard to get a test. You had to have symptoms — and have known contact with someone who had the coronavirus because there were so few tests available.

But now, it is far easier to get a test across the state. Most counties are testing at rates that would allow public health officials to quickly identify an outbreak.

The large volume of tests has also come as the rate of positive tests has fallen and stayed at roughly 3 percent statewide for over two months.

“I think the test positivity is a really great metric,” said Glashower.

 

In Ottawa County, Grand Valley State University reported this week that 123 students and staff tested positive, just over 2 percent of the more than 2,200 people who were teste. Hope College had earlier said 38 students or staff had tested positive.

 But Glashower said many of those infected are asymptomatic and have been quarantined away from others.

And the county’s overall test-positive rate is still below 2 percent.

“I’m not concerned about the increase in cases because I don’t have evidence of wider transmission,” he said.

Both Glashower and Sims stressed Michigan remains vulnerable, despite some encouraging signs. Some populations are still getting hard hit, people are still dying and there is no cure or vaccine yet.

Caution remains important, they said, as only known defenses against the spread of the coronavirus are social distancing, facial coverings, hand hygiene and cough etiquette.

Sims said he finally got a vacation to west Michigan a few weeks back after many seven-day weeks and long hours. 

He was surprised how many people were not wearing masks, not following the common-sense approach that has been almost universally accepted.

“It was frightening,” he said.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

EB
Fri, 09/04/2020 - 10:57am

My northern Michigan county turned orange today, meaning we have a higher risk of infection than most surrounding counties. Disregard for the masking requirement is common here.

Protecting oneself is possible however. Walmart's online ordering and pickup service is a very safe option for groceries and other household items. Menards is strict about masks and seems a safe shopping place for other merchandise needs. We'll shop other places, but reluctantly and we're in and out ASAP.

We no longer go to church services. We no longer socialize indoors and when socializing outdoors it's at a safe distance. Life is different, but, staying safe in northern Michigan is doable.

David Agnew
Fri, 09/04/2020 - 1:26pm

It's good that it is being reported that we have been looking at this wrong. Cases aren't the whole picture.
The problem is that this article still isn't getting it right. But i applaud the progress.
The fact is, deaths are the most important data to look consider. They have been flat, under 20 per day, since May 29.
The main contributing factor is the average age if those becoming infected. When you compare deaths with age, over 95% are over age 65.
I point this out to say that the still current executive actions concerning this epidemic are clearly not in line with the risk. People who are vulnerable should be taking precautions. People who work with them as well. However, those who are not vulnerable should not have to take any precautions other than normal everyday healthy behaviors.
The negative ramifications of the continued executive actions will far outweigh the benefits. What I mean by that is, those suffering economic hardships, mental stress, abuse, and more because of the actions, should be considered.

Mark Higbee
Sun, 09/06/2020 - 3:25pm

Mr. Agnew, your conclusion that "those who are not vulnerable should not have to take any precautions other than normal everyday healthy behaviors" and that therefore the Governor is being too restrictive with her public health order, overlooks a vitally important fact: those people most at risk of dying & serious illness from the virus, the elderly, are NOT isolated from other people. Grandkids risk bringing the disease to grandma, and if case you haven't noticed, lots of grandparents live in the same home as their grandkids. Similar facts carrying real risks extend throughout the society; public health professionals consider these risks even if you ignore them and therefore imagine that the pandemic isn't so threatening.

Allen Gabrielson
Fri, 09/04/2020 - 6:29pm

Here’s what I don’t understand: the State is supposedly testing over 20,000 people a day (650 daily cases @ 3% positivity). Where are the lines of people getting tested? The article references 1 college testing 2200 over 1 week so that’s about 300 per day. Where are other 19,700 tests being conducted at? Where are the lines at hospital testing sites? Where is the lab capacity?
Are we sure these “cases” aren’t being manufactured by contact tracers?
Hospitalizations were 680 on July 17 and 616 on Sept 3. So the State has allegedly tested about 1 million people in that time span recording about 30,000 cases with virtually no change in hospitalizations. Anyone under 50 currently hospitalized? How about under 60? This is another area where the State needs to be more transparent and provide local school districts that type of information. Unfortunately, that is highly unlikely.

Anonymous
Sat, 09/05/2020 - 8:38am

Too bad that these reporters don't understand laboratory medicine; every test has an attached "sensitivity and specificity" and these associated with Bayesian analysis would uncover the fraud underlying the recent "surge" and the futility of mass testing.
Simplifying; there is an admitted 3% false positive rate in the usual RT/PCR covid-19 testing. So if you do 20,000 tests on folks who have no symptoms of the disease, you will generate 600 false positives. Period.

JH
Sun, 09/06/2020 - 11:02am

Do you have a source? False negatives could be a problem, but it's my understanding false positives for RT-PCR tests are highly specific and false positives are rare--nowhere near 3% .

George Hagenauer
Sun, 09/06/2020 - 10:31am

Deaths are not the only issue- one that is slowly becoming more visible is post infection long term problems with other organs - kidneys, lungs etc. . In other words we still do not know all the risks involved. There probably needs to be more data on symptomatic ersus asymptomatic cases.

JH
Sun, 09/06/2020 - 10:51am

Why haven't masks reduced the number of cases? Could they simply reduce the severity?

What percentage of cases are symptomatic? What percentage of cases were identified by contact tracers?

George Hagenauer
Sun, 09/06/2020 - 2:59pm

Anther thing to remember is that false positive tests tend to be followed up on and often with a retest or tracking of symptoms.

Katherine Carrigan
Wed, 09/09/2020 - 1:32pm

In one of the Enbridge articles it stated that 554,000 gallons of natural gas and oil travels from Wisconsin to Ontario but later said it was propane for the UP. We were told before that raw oil from Canada was transported to the Gulf States for refining and sale . Which is it? As a 31 yr resident of Marquette, I have followed and fought the pipeline since we were made aware of it. Possible contamination of fresh water, drilling the rockbed below the Straits, air pollution from 2,000 semis, destruction of our compromised roads and bridges across the state, destruction of forests and farmland for a possible 200 jobs is troubling. Developing better means of producing energy would mean more jobs In Michigan and a cleaner world.