Questions about Michigan coronavirus school closings? We have (some) answers

Much uncertainty remains about Michigan’s three-week school closures that begin Monday.

March 30: Whitmer to end Michigan school year; seniors graduate, others move up
March 20 update: Will Michigan classes stay closed, and other coronavirus impact on schools

The closure of all Michigan K-12 schools for three weeks starting Monday raises a lot of questions for families and school administrators. Let us know your questions by sending them to rfrench@bridgemi.com and we’ll try to get answers. 

My child receives free breakfast and lunch at school. What happens during the break?

More than half of Michigan students get free breakfast at school, and 7 in 10 get free or reduced-price lunch. School officials say that, for many low-income students, free school meals are their main source of nutrition.

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s administration officials told Bridge a top priority is finding a way to get those free meals to students during the three-week school closure.

The Michigan Department of Education requested and received a waiver from federal regulations Friday, allowing school meals to be distributed to families outside of school cafeterias.

Parents need to check with their own school district or charter school, but a number of districts, including Detroit Public Schools Community District, the state’s largest, have set up distribution points for “grab-and-go” meals.

The meals are free, and must be taken away from the distribution centers to eat.

In Detroit, “select buildings will be partially open, after a 72 hour period and deep cleaning, for students to quickly pick up breakfast and/or lunch in the morning and afternoon Monday through Friday,” Detroit Superintendent Nikolai Vitti told Bridge in an email statement. “Students will not eat at the building but simply pick up food. DPSCD will also deliver meals to its medically fragile students at their homes.”

Also, there are reports of some restaurants around the state offering free meals to children. Two examples: Domino’s on Harper Avenue in St. Clair Shores announced it is offering a free large, one-topping pizza for families in need during the school closure, and Palm Palace in Ann Arbor is offering free children’s meals, with no purchase necessary.

RELATED:

What if my school’s spring break was scheduled to begin April 6, the day schools are supposed to reopen. Is my school off four weeks?

Again, that’s a decision that will be made by local school districts. Many schools in Oakland, Kent and Ottawa counties, for example, have spring breaks scheduled April 6 to April 10.

Ron Koehler, assistant superintendent at Kent Intermediate School District, said he doubted schools would reschedule spring break, in respect to families who have made travel reservations. Also, dates of spring break are in teacher contracts, so changing the dates would have to be negotiated, which would be difficult on short notice.

So, in effect, some schools will be off for three weeks, and some for four weeks. 

Will my child have to attend school later in June to make up for the break?

By state law, Michigan schools must be in session for 180 days. Schools are allowed to take six snow days during the year without having to make up those days in the spring.

A three-week state-mandated closure would mean schools would likely have to extend school into the summer by at least two weeks to meet that 180-day requirement.

Nudging the school year into the summer could also raise some thorny contract issues. For example, would teachers and staff, who are being paid during the school closure, be paid extra for working those weeks?

There’s no decision yet. But recent history would suggest it is unlikely schools will have to make up the coronavirus break days.

Last year, the Legislature forgave four days that Michigan schools were closed from Jan. 29 to Feb. 1, when Whitmer declared a state of emergency because of frigid temperatures.

A similar action to forgive school days lost during the coronavirus closure is likely, said state Sen. Dayna Polehanki, D-Livonia. “I have requested a bill that will forgive school days lost as a result of the governor’s closing of K-12 schools due to the coronavirus,” Polehanki said Friday.

I don’t have high-speed Internet at my home. Will my kid fall behind?

Michigan’s public universities halted in-person classes, but are still attempting to hold classes online. Unlike the state’s universities, K-12 schools are officially closed.

Many schools sent home packets of study materials with students, and many offer online learning opportunities. But not all students have access to high-speed Internet or have computers in their homes.

In rural Michigan, 37 percent of homes do not have broadband Internet, and 14 percent of homes have no Internet at all.

Comcast, one of the state’s major Internet providers, announced it is offering 60 days of basic Internet service free to low-income families in response to the coronavirus crisis.

So while many Michigan teachers are attempting to keep their students engaged academically during the break, classes will pick up where they left off when schools closed.

Could third -graders still be retained because of low reading skills?

As of now, the M-STEP, the state’s standardized test, is still scheduled to be given in Michigan schools in April.

In most grades, M-STEP results have no bearing on student grades or advancement. But this year for the first time, reading scores on the M-STEP will be used to flag struggling third-grade readers for retention.

Third-graders who are more than a year behind in reading will be recommended for retention. The Michigan Department of Education estimates that 5 percent of third-graders (about 5,000) will be flagged.

There are numerous exemptions for students (English-language learners and those who’ve already flunked a grade, for example), but there still likely will be many more students flunk third grade than in the past.

When third-graders return April 6, they will just weeks away from that high-stakes test, having missed three weeks of reading instruction.

This week, the U.S. Department of Education gave waivers that allow states to not give federally-mandated standardized tests this school year, meaning Michigan has the option of dropping M-STEP this spring.

As of Saturday, M-STEP was still scheduled to be given to Michigan students in April.

Friday, MDE sent a memo to schools saying the department knew that school closure “has created significant concerns about test preparation test administration, and potential student results.

“Top department leadership has conveyed these concerns to the U.S. Department of Education and will advocate for maximum flexibility,” the memo continued.

Polehanki, the Democratic senator from Livonia, told Bridge Friday she is advocating in the Legislature for a postponement of M-STEP and the third-grade read-or-flunk law until next year.

 Is there a chance the three-week break will be extended even longer?

There aren’t plans to extend the school break at the moment. Then again, there weren’t plans to close the schools at all a week ago. With coronavirus cases expected to increase in the near future, nothing is ruled out.

Some institutions are already extending their coronavirus precautions. For example, the University of Michigan and Michigan State University have halted all in-person classes through the end of the semester April 21. Final exams will be online-only, and the schools canceled their spring commencements.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Arjay
Sun, 03/15/2020 - 4:01pm

The CDC, as reported by Bridge on March 13th, says that closing schools for 3 weeks may not be enough to make a difference. Most likely the discrepancy between that article and this article is due to the fact that Corona Virus is so new that all the facts about it are not known. A little common sense may be better than some of the knee jerk reactions taking place.

Jennifer G
Tue, 03/17/2020 - 9:21pm

While closing schools was the prudent thing to do in this time of crisis, not extending the school year would be very irresponsible. While closed businesses don't have the advantage to make up the lost time or money, schools do. We keep hearing how important education is , but every time we have a blip that disrupts the norm we never seem to err on the side of education. It's all about teachers contracts and politics. Schools have the ability with spring breaks, summer break, winter break, PD days, etc to go the required number of days no matter what happens during the year. We need to make our educational system accountable to this and our lawmakers need to lead that charge. Teachers and administrators are paid a salary to work x number of days, let's make sure that happens -because it for the kids. At least its always for the kids when they need a raise or anything else that benefits them personally. This doesn't need to be lost instructional time, we have the ability and the time to educate our Michigan children.

Eric
Wed, 03/18/2020 - 9:21pm

I’m a teacher and I’m all for adding days to the school year. I am a salaried employee with a contract. Schools have funds to pay their hourly employees for 180 school days. So do you suggest that these people who need this money to feed their own kids make no money now, or work for free in the summer?

Jennifer G
Thu, 03/19/2020 - 5:40pm

They are being paid now and NOT working, so yes, they would not be compensated if school was extended and they were required to work to make up the time . They typically don't get paid for the summer anyway. We're just shifting when they get paid and when they work. If business owners elect to pay employees while they are off, good for them, it's their money. But state employees should not be entitled to paid time off unless they use any accumulated sick, vacation, or personal leave. Schools and governments have what is basically self funded unemployment so there is no financial advantage in asking employees to file for benefits, which isn't even permitted during break times for school employees anyway. I just feel with state tax money hourly people should be compensated for working, not just compensated because they are employed by a school or government agency. Same with teachers- 185 days of pay for 185 days worked, not just employed, but worked in the classroom teaching kids. If you were ordered by the Govenor to work an additional 10 days, would you not expect additional compensation? But you're okay taking full pay when ordered to not report to work for 3 weeks?

Anonymous
Tue, 03/31/2020 - 6:28pm

Hourly workers in other industries also "need money to feed" their families, but are currently being laid off or worse. Why should hourly school staff be entitled to pay for hours they did not work?

Robert Tulloch
Wed, 04/01/2020 - 9:32pm

Or teachers for days they did not work.

Nick H
Thu, 03/19/2020 - 8:42pm

A virus of this magnitude comes around every... not so often. If one year of a child's school life is shortened for the betterment of everyone so be it! I think it's not fair that of what you are proposing because parents with young children plan their lives in years not just weekly or even monthly schedules and people in certain industries(this guy right here) isn't making any money during the mandatory quarantine and to extend the school year 3 weeks-1 1/2 months would cost me in excess of $1000 which again I don't have!!! Thanks for your consideration of the kids though! I agree that the children are are future and their education is of the utmost importance!

Nancy
Mon, 03/30/2020 - 12:33pm

Very well said

Nancy
Mon, 03/30/2020 - 12:33pm

Very well said

Robert Tulloch
Wed, 04/01/2020 - 9:28pm

Why should teachers be paid when schools are closed? Are they "better" than non-government workers?

middle of the mit
Thu, 04/02/2020 - 9:52pm

You want snark? Or do you want conservatism?

I am going to give you both.

Screw the kids!

Parents should have seen or expected something like this and prepared for it. If they didn't, that was a PERSONAL choice. Parents made that choice for the kids. And now conservatives are telling you that their kids education in a Public School is more than they can handle at home! But public school teachers suck none the less! and are unworthy of teaching their kids even though those same parents now want the public school teachers salary for educating THEIR KIDS AT HOME!, Because you know, why should any parent have to educate THEIR KID AT ALL! Does personal responsibility ever enter your lexicon when it doesn't involve you getting a benefit?

Pay for your PUBLIC EDUCATION! The STATE is tired of doing it for you! TAKE some PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY AND DO IT YOUR SELVES!

Lamarr Martin
Sun, 04/05/2020 - 12:15am

What about kids that are expelled and are trying to ge into a online school