‘Dehumanized’ by police at 16, Garlin Gilchrist seeks Michigan reforms

Gilchrist protest

Michigan Lt. Gov. Garlin Gilchrist II speaks during a march through Detroit and Highland Park on June 4. (Executive Office courtesy photo)

LANSING — Sixteen-year-old Garlin Gilchrist was two blocks away from Farmington High School when a police officer pulled him over “for going 24 in a 25” mile per hour zone and interrogated him about who he was, what he was doing and where he was going. 

Nevermind the backpack on his passenger seat, which told the clear story of a junior on his way to class. 

More than two decades later, Michigan’s first African-American lieutenant governor remembers the traffic stop well — and viscerally recalls the sinking feeling of being singled out by law enforcement in the suburb where he lived, which was overwhelmingly white. 

“I really felt dehumanized by that experience, because I didn’t think I deserved to be questioned like that,” said Gilchrist, now 37, whose parents moved from Detroit to Farmington in 1989 to give him access to better schools. “I wasn’t breaking any laws.”

The encounter and others like it explain some of the anxiety that many people of color carry from a lifetime of interactions with police, Gilchrist told Bridge Magazine in an interview on Monday as nationwide protests over police brutality continued following the deaths of George Floyd in Minnesota, Breonna Taylor in Kentucky and others before them. 

“It’s been a generational issue,” he said. “We have a generational opportunity to fix it.”

Amid a nationwide reckoning over institutional racism and a global pandemic that has exposed systemic inequities leading African Americans to die at greater rates, Gilchrist has stepped into the spotlight as a prominent voice for criminal justice reform and racial equity, issues he discussed Sunday night in a nationally televised appearance on MSNBC

Gilchrist had never held elected office when now-Gov. Gretchen Whitmer tapped him as her running mate in 2018. An unknown across most of Michigan whose selection surprised even some Democrats, he was promoted by party leaders as a rising star after giving up a software engineering career for political activism.

Now, with Whitmer still getting mentioned as a possible Democratic vice presidential nominee, Gilchrist could be in line to be Michigan’s next governor should Joe Biden pick her and defeat Republican President Donald Trump in November. 

“It’s true,” Gilchrist said, laughing briefly as he acknowledged the scenario before praising Whitmer for remaining “responsive to the people of Michigan” despite the national attention, speculation and Twitter attacks from Trump and his allies.

“If I’ve learned anything in the last three years of my personal and public life it’s that anything can happen, but what you can control is how you spend your time and energy, and what outcomes you choose to focus on,” Gilchrist said. “... If something happens in that regard for Gretchen Whitmer, I’m certainly humbly ready to serve the people of Michigan.”

Disconnected policy

Gilchrist, who marched with Whitmer at a recent protest through Highland Park and Detroit, is playing a prominent role in the administration's response to the national push for police reforms. 

While lieutenant governors sometimes toil in obscurity, Gilchrist has been tapped by Whitmer for high-profile positions as chair of the Michigan Coronavirus Task Force on Racial Disparities and as co-chair of the Michigan Joint Task Force on Jail and Pretrial Incarceration.

He joined Whitmer in announcing an initial round of policy proposals and on Wednesday will stand — socially distanced — beside state lawmakers, police and sheriffs to announce a new “transparency collaborative” designed to increase public accessibility to police “use of force” data. 

Experts say it’s a public role he is uniquely qualified for as the first African American elected to Michigan’s executive office. By voting for him in 2018, Michiganders showed they were ready for “representative leadership,” Gilchrist said. 

“I think it matters that the public servants who are looking to make choices now, that they’ve had these life experiences,” he said. “We get disconnected policy when you get people who are governing over experiences they’ve never had. And unfortunately I, as both a black teenager [and now] a black man, have had these kinds of interactions with law enforcement.”

Whitmer and Gilchrist have publicly backed legislation that would require new police officers to undergo implicit bias and de-escalation training, while encouraging law enforcement agencies to adopt “duty to intervene” policies that would require officers to stop a colleague they see doing something inappropriate or illegal. The governor last week also added civil rights voices to the Michigan Commission on Law Enforcement Standards.

More policy proposals are coming, said Gilchrist.

Because of Whitmer’s emergency powers during the pandemic, Gilchrist’s coronavirus task force has been able to produce immediate results by crafting recommendations that helped shape the governor’s executive orders, he told Bridge.

Its members have, for instance, pushed to expand testing criteria and boost access for low-income residents, including deployment of mobile units that can “get testing to where people are” and connecting them with a healthcare “navigator” for future care, Gilchrist said. 

The task force has also warned medical providers against “implicit bias” in testing and treatment decisions. Dr. Joneigh Khaldun, the state’s chief medical officer, in April sent doctors a letter asking them to be aware of how their own "subconscious biases may impact their practice.” 

That was an important step, Gilchrist said, because “one of the first ways you deal with that kind of medical bias is to name it, and have people be mindful of it.”

The bipartisan task force on jail and pretrial Incarceration in January released 18 policy proposals to shrink the state’s county jail population, recommending the state reduce driver’s license suspensions, shorten probation terms, cut fines for civil infractions and stop requiring inmates to pay for their own incarceration, among other things, to reduce poor people being jailed for, essentially, being poor.

That seems like “eons ago,” but the recommendations also ended up informing Whitmer’s pandemic-related executive orders recommending early release for pretrial inmates jailed for traffic violations, license suspensions and nonviolent offenses, Gilchrist said, noting longer-term legislation has been introduced to codify some of the task force proposals. 

“As we think about why people are demonstrating in streets across the state and across the country, they're demonstrating because the communities, the black community in particular, has not felt an experience of public safety,” Gilchrist said. “They have not necessarily felt like law enforcement was always on their side.”

Basketball and computers

Gilchrist had two passions as a child: basketball and computers. The former took him to courts across Detroit, where his parents insisted he continued to spend time to maintain a close connection to the city even after they moved to Farmington. The latter took him to the University of Michigan, where he double-majored in computer engineering and computer science. 

After college, Gilchrist passed up an opportunity to stay in Michigan and work for General Motors and moved to Seattle to work for Microsoft, which he has described as a better fit professionally. He missed home, however, and from Seattle launched an effort called “Detroit Intern” to encourage talented young Detroiters to stay in the city rather than leave like he did after college. 

He also grew more political in Seattle, where he helped start a blog called The Super Spade that focused on “black thought at the highest level” and worked as a Washington state social media manager for President Barack Obama’s 2008 campaign. 

In 2009, a week before Gilchrist married his wife, Ellen, they moved to Washington, D.C., where he began work as a community organizer for the Center for Community Change. Two years later, he went to work for MoveOn.org, one of the country’s largest liberal advocacy groups.

Gilchrist was a "political neophyte" when he took office alongside Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, shown with him at a recent protest, but has impressed political insiders. (Courtesy photo)

His ties to MoveOn made him a target for Republicans in the 2018 election. When Whitmer announced him as her running mate, a super political action committee backing Republican nominee Bill Schuette immediately blasted the pairing as the "most liberal ticket ever."

And when Gilchrist was cited for a blight violation for "excessive weeds or plant growth" outside a vacant Detroit building he said he had intended to renovate, Schuette called on him to withdraw from the race, saying his "extreme views and incompetence make him unqualified to be lieutenant governor." 

But Gilchrist defends his work at MoveOn, where he helped organize gun reform campaigns in the wake of Florida teen Trayvon Martin’s death and a mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut, both in 2012. One of his biggest projects for the advocacy group involved urging states to support legislation that would prohibit employers from firing workers because of their sexual orientation or gender identity.

Gilchrist recalled that project Monday as he celebrated a U.S. Supreme Court decision guaranteeing workplace protections for gay and transgender Americans. He told Bridge he had spent his morning texting leaders he had worked with years earlier. 

“It's extraordinary,” Gilchrist said. “This is like the biggest civil rights ruling for LGBT people since marriage.”

A political newcomer

Gilchrist was relatively quiet his first year in office and conducted few media interviews. But he turned heads — and garnered national attention — last summer with an impassioned speech minutes before a Democratic presidential primary debate in Detroit. 

Gilchrist was a "political neophyte" when he took office but has impressed, said Adrian Hemond, a Democratic political consultant with the Lansing-based Grassroots Midwest firm.

The lieutenant governor's role is essentially "whatever the governor says," and Whitmer has given Gilchrist room to lead, he said.

“Garlin Gilchrist appears to be a little bit more in the mold of a Lieutenant Governor Brian Calley,” Hemond added, referencing Gilchrist’s immediate Republican predecessor. “He's been a little more active" than some lieutenant governors and has been "given a couple of specific writs by the governor to really make a deep dive into."

Whitmer faced significant pressure to pick an African-American running mate in 2018 to help the Michigan Democratic Party avoid an all-white slate at the top of the statewide ticket, which featured herself, Secretary of State Jocelyn Benson and Attorney General Dana Nessel. 

The Gilchrist pick proved fortuitous, said Jonathan Kinloch, a Whitmer ally and chair of the 13th Congressional District Democratic Party. 

"At the time he was selected, no one could have ever imagined where we would be today," he said

"What greater voice could we ask for, other than the governor herself, than to have the lieutenant governor actually be a black man. He's sitting at the table at this moment, and that is absolutely a wonderful thing to have."

Gilchrist and his family moved back to Detroit in 2014, when he went to work for Detroit Mayor Mike Duggan as the city’s first director of innovation and emerging technology.While Gilchrist spent part of his childhood in the suburbs and left the state as a young professional, Kinloch challenged those who would argue he is not an authentic representative for Detroit and its people.

"When you're black, there is a common thread that goes through your experiences," he said. "That experience is real, no matter where you live in the state, no matter where you live in this country."

He lost his first political campaign in 2017, falling to longtime Detroit City Clerk Janice Winfrey by about 1,400 votes. He briefly worked as executive director for U-M’s Center for Social Media Responsibility before Whitmer tapped him as her running mate in 2018. 

Gilchrist now lives with his wife and their three young children in Detroit’s Corktown neighborhood, where they’ve had a direct view of protesters marching along Michigan Avenue into the city’s downtown business district. 

While his twins are only 6 years old, he’s explained to them that demonstrators “want to have good relationships with the police and they want the police to help them and not be afraid of them,” Gilchrist said. 

“That’s been a really important conversation, and I think a lot of parents are having these conversations.”

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


David Waymire
Tue, 06/16/2020 - 7:59pm

Was fortunate to meet Lt. Gov. Gilchrist several years ago, before his run for clerk. Watch him. Listen to him. More likely you find him listening attentively and learning about you. He’s a leader of the next generation, one who might be able to save our state from its 20 year decline into mediocrity.

Wed, 06/17/2020 - 10:01am

I had the good fortune to attend a few events where Lt.Gov. Gilchrist spoke. He’s an eloquent speaker, but most importantly, beyond that, WHAT he was saying about our improving our State, criminal justice reform, the environment, education, was practical and well thought out. Each time I hear him or read about what he’s concerned and working on, I’m more impressed. Michigan is lucky to have him take up the mantle of service for our State.

Thu, 06/18/2020 - 10:47am

Oh great, another victim.

What ever happened to his task force that was supposed to identify and resolve the racial disparities of COVID-19? It's been over 2 months and ZERO reported progress. Did they decide this wasn't important anymore or did the findings not support the current talking points?

The state needs people who know how to run businesses and create jobs in leadership positions. Not community activists who only know how to point out alleged "injustices" or "deep thinking" pseudo-intellectuals who's bright ideas involve destroying the basic values that govern a safe and civil society.

Yes, it is
Thu, 06/18/2020 - 8:53pm

If Business people is all that was needed to fix things, the dams NEVER would have failed, would they? Are you saying a business person wasn't in charge of those dams?

If running a city was like running a business, would a business poison people to save money? Do you know what Super Fund sites are?

Enough is enough!

Put the people first!

The Bible says when a King is good, the people are happy, when they are bad the people are oppressed. I get it. You are oppressed because you are asked to wear a face mask to protect you and others. That is not oppression. And if you think it is..............you are the one that is special. And everyone else just wants to be treated the way you are, but somehow..........that means they want special rights.

Sat, 06/20/2020 - 5:50pm

You mean the dam who's owners were sued into increasing the water level by another career twit who's only claim to fame is "fighting for justice"? The dams should be state owned and operated by people who know what they're doing.

Same thing for the city who's dumb ass city council voted themselves to switch to a cheaper water source and then tried to pin the blame on everyone but themselves. Again, if someone with a clue was running the place instead of career politicians or professional welfare recipients, there wouldn't have been a crisis to whine about.

I'm not deeply religious, nor have I studied the Bible but I'm pretty sure it says 1) to treat others as you'd want them to treat you and 2) don't expect to live off handouts from others.

middle of the mit
Mon, 06/22/2020 - 3:46am

Who sued the dam owner to raise the level more than the legal amount set by the State, which republican regulators gave a 3 paragraph OK on? The current AG? NO. She sued to raise the level from an 8 foot drop to a 3 foot drop. What you need to understand is that the lakefront owners pushed for the lake level to be raised to the FULL LEGAL SUMMER LEVEL, and the State and County courts had no other option but to obey the law, absent a statutory and full inquiry of said dam. And that was just a few weeks away, but you give the owner FULL recompense for not obeying Federal or State statuettes. Must be nice.

Also, way to put the blame on a city council that was over run by an Emergency Financial Manager.

Do you know what those last few words of that last sentence mean? That means whoever put that Emergency Financial Manager TOOK OVER CONTROL OF THAT CITY. That means from that point on, Rick Snyder and those he appointed were in CONTROL OF THE CITY AND IT'S FINANCES. If that wasn't true, what would be the point in appointing them EFM?


And to your third point about Christianity.............that is who Christians are called to look out for. The needy and forgotten.

#Proud Sheep Nation!

#Matthew 25

jesse atwell
Sat, 06/20/2020 - 10:45am

So you've held a grudge for 24 years now.....Just how is it that I'm now responsible for a perceived slight or insult some 24 years ago?....By the way, I'm white and was also pulled over by police when I was young ...sometimes it was deserved and others not so much....but was treated to some probing unnecessary questioning also..and although I still do remember that the police intimidated me too.. my parents told me that if I'm not doing anything to just shrug it off and continue going on my way....that the cop that was rude when he pulled me over would eventually be weeded out by his superiors....because they didn't want to be seen as overbearing either. For the most part, I think they were probably right....but there will always be a bad actor in every police force I think...regardless of how many laws are passed to try to limit their participation.....Human beings will never be perfect...Tragedies are always possible....More laws will not make any of them perfect.

Mon, 06/22/2020 - 9:17am

The difference is that those tragedies are MORE LIKELY experienced by black families. If you read the article: Lt. Governor Gilchrist says that he is teaching is 6 year olds that they too should be able to go to the police and feel safe.

Stop thinking only about your self.