With ‘school policy in chaos,’ coronavirus delays debate in Michigan Senate

Michigan Senate Majority Leader Mike Shirkey, R-Clarklake, canceled session and committee hearings for the week after a colleague tested positive for COVID-19. (Shutterstock)

LANSING — Michigan lawmakers debating how schools should reopen amid the coronavirus pandemic are grappling with their own shutdown after a Republican senator contracted COVID-19.

Senate Majority Leader Mike Shirkey and House Speaker Lee Chatfield on Monday canceled sessions and committee hearings for the week following a positive test for Sen. Tom Barrett, a Charlotte Republican and critic of Democratic Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s pandemic orders.

The temporary shutdown will postpone Senate consideration of House-approved legislation that would require schools to offer in-person instruction to students in kindergarten through fifth grade this fall. 

With school restart dates fast approaching, Shirkey, R-Clarklake, had hoped to complete negotiations and send the legislation to Whitmer by Thursday. Instead, a week after Barrett attended committee hearings in Lansing, Shirkey wants lawmakers to stay away from the Capitol and get tested for COVID-19. 

“Work will continue on the legislation, but any contemplated floor action will be delayed,” Shirkey spokesperson Amber McCann told Bridge.

Michigan schools have started to announce restart plans and do not need the Legislature to overhaul education policy. However, school administrators are asking for new flexibility to meet state mandates amid the global pandemic. 

It’s not clear if the Republican-led Senate will support the House provision requiring districts to offer an in-person instruction for all K-5 students. McCann did not respond when asked if Shirkey supports that provision, but the majority leader said last week he was “dismayed” Grand Rapids Public Schools does not plan to resume classroom instruction this fall. It is among large districts, including Ann Arbor and Lansing, planning to begin the year with remote learning and online-only classes.

Critics of the House legislation contend Barrett’s positive test is a cautionary tale. 

If a single case of COVID-19 can shutdown the Legislature, what happens when students or teachers catch the virus this fall?

“This is the exact reason why school policy is in chaos,” said Sen. Jeremy Moss, D-Southfield, who got a COVID-19 test on Monday morning because he interacted with Barrett less than two weeks ago. “If one student tests positive, you’ve interacted with people who have interacted with that person, who have interacted with that person.”

Public education advocacy groups are almost uniformly opposed to the House legislation. They’re asking lawmakers to help clarify pandemic policies — not impose new requirements — for districts that are already developing plans for multiple COVID scenarios, as required under an executive order Whitmer signed in late June.

“The last thing any school needs is the Legislature coming in at the 11th hour and making some fundamental policy shifts in terms of what schools even need to do to reopen,” said Robert McCann, executive director for the Tri-County Alliance for Public Education, a group of superintendents from districts in Macomb, Oakland and Wayne counties.

“The best thing [lawmakers] could do at this point is just stay home, quite frankly, if they’re not going to provide schools financial answers,” McCann added.

Beyond questions over restart policy, schools are preparing to begin the academic year without certainty on how much funding they will receive from the state, which faces a projected $3 billion budget shortfall for the fiscal year that begins in October. 

Whitmer and GOP legislative leaders used federal pandemic funding to avoid major spending cuts in the current fiscal year. But without more assistance from Congress, the state may soon be forced to scale back spending on schools and other budget priorities this fall. 

Officials in May predicted School Aid Fund revenue will decline by $1.2 billion, or about 7 percent. 

“This is the most uncertain time we’ve ever had, particularly from a budget perspective,” said Peter Spadafore, deputy executive director for external relations at the Michigan Association of Superintendents and Administrators. “We don’t have any guidance from the Legislature on what per-pupil funding is going to be.”

Schools need policymakers to give them flexibility on how to count pupils this fall and conduct daily attendance during a pandemic, Spadafore said. It’s possible that Whitmer or the Michigan Department of Education could address those issues on their own, but public education advocates had hoped for legislative action this week. 

“The Legislature has made the right call in preserving health and safety guidelines” by cancelling session this week, Spadafore said. But that “further underscores the point of how tenuous opening plans are going to have to be about the firm line in the sand about in-person instruction,” he added.

The Senate Education and Career Readiness Committee had been scheduled to take up the House GOP’s “return to learn” proposal on Wednesday, which would have set up possible floor votes on Thursday.  

Barrett is the first Republican lawmaker to contract the virus in Michigan. Two state House Democrats tested positive in March and April. A third, state Rep. Isaac Robinson of Detroit, died from what his family suspects were complications from COVID-19.

Senate Republicans, who have a sizable majority in the upper chamber but not enough votes to require immediate effect on legislation, are debating the House package and whether to ease the requirement for schools to at least offer in-person classes to elementary age students.

Sen. Ken Horn, R-Frankenmuth, conducted an informal poll on his Facebook page last week and said he heard a variety of parental preferences, ranging from those who want in-person instruction without masks to those who want online-only learning.

“School needs to start on time, and I’d like to see it in person,” Horn told Bridge. “Kids are less likely to transmit the virus, and they’re less likely to get sick from the virus, but it’s the teachers I really have concern for.”

School-age children can contract COVID-19, but early studies suggest they do so at lower rates. And those who do test positive tend to have no symptoms or only mild ones.

However, a recent study from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention points to the continued risk of outbreaks. More than 230 youths who attended an overnight summer camp in Georgia contracted the virus, according to the CDC. Fifty-one of the attendees were between the age of 6 and 10, while 180 were between the age of 11 and 17. 

"Correct and consistent use of cloth masks, rigorous cleaning and sanitizing, social distancing, and frequent hand washing strategies, which are recommended in CDC's recently released guidance to reopen America's schools, are critical to prevent transmission of the virus in settings involving children and are our greatest tools to prevent COVID-19," the CDC said in a statement. 

Whitmer this summer released a 63-page “return to school roadmap” that proposed rules and recommendations for the fall. She’s signalled a willingness to work with GOP leaders on school policy but has criticized some aspects of the proposal approved by the House last month.

“Some of the work that’s coming out of the Republcan-led Legislature has merit,” the governor said last week. “Other pieces of it are modeled after the [U.S. Education Secretary Betsy] Devos plan to force schools to put kids back in the classroom.”

Sen. Wayne Schmidt, a Traverse City Republican who chairs the K-12 budget committee, said Monday he will oppose any effort to tie classroom funding to in-person instruction but believes a return to classrooms is the best-case scenario for students who already fell behind when Whitmer closed school buildings in March. 

Schmidt would like to see “adjustments” to the House plan to ensure it gives schools “flexibility” to utilize in-person instruction, online learning or some combination of the two, he said.

“I certainly want to encourage students to go back to the classroom, of course with as little risk and as many protocols in place,” he said. “That’s balanced with what is most prudent based on what health officials are saying. We continue to weigh that out.”

Policymakers need to consider the health of teachers, not just students, according to Horn, who said he is concerned about the safety of older teachers and those with pre-existing conditions making them more susceptible to the virus.

Still, he said, schools could be creative. For instance, educators who face a greater risk from COVID-19 could use video technology to instruct students gathered in physical classrooms, Horn suggested. 

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


MI GOP Worthless
Mon, 08/03/2020 - 9:13pm

GOP legislature in Michigan is messed up AF. The poop is hitting the fan and what do they do? THEY GO ON VACATION.

Mon, 08/03/2020 - 9:19pm

Seriously, can anyone imagine what our state would be like if these Bozos had more say in all of this? Thank God for the state of emergency law that gave Whitmer the power to act without them. We would be a lost cause if the Republicans had their way. They literally are on the wrong side of history regarding EVERYTHING!

Mon, 08/03/2020 - 9:21pm

Michigan Republicans=Bumbling Idiots

Tue, 08/04/2020 - 8:36am

Wait, ONE legislator tests positive and the entire legislature has to shut down, but for schools it's ok to move ahead?

GOP Hypocrites
Tue, 08/04/2020 - 4:43pm

To be fair, that ONE is like a child in his comportment, but yes, it's proof you can't trust kids when they gather for school or legislating.

Tue, 08/04/2020 - 8:48am

Do we blow things up in the short term because we cannot wait 4-6 months for a vaccine and/or effective treatments? NO! Americans must learn to be patient if we want to save lives and not overwhelm our hospitals and health care workers.

Trump love
Tue, 08/04/2020 - 6:05pm

That or we can attack Fauci or Birx, you know, the bearers of truth that we don't like to hear.

Tue, 08/04/2020 - 9:31am

Trump and the republicans are out to kill as many Americans as they can or their boss Putin!!!

Seems that way
Tue, 08/04/2020 - 6:16pm

Yes, I think we can all agree that only Putin wanted us to believe this was just seasonal flu. After all, Trump's buddy Putin even put a bounty on our soldiers and Trump did NOTHING to retaliate. Seems obvious Trump and his supporters, from the beginning, have been rooting for Russian white supremacy and dominance over our country. I never thought they'd have so many plants in Michigan. Makes me wonder if all these local Republicans are married to Russian mail-order brides. It was quite popular for a while along with Russian adoptions. We know Trump doesn't just love Putin. There has to be some kompromat or the promise of a Trump Tower Moscow. Sucker doesn't realize Putin has no intention of delivering. Only time will tell if we don't get knocked off by Trump temper-tantrums. Sadly this unhinged Russian friend does control the nukes...... and he doesn't seem to know who our enemies are.

George Hagenauer
Tue, 08/04/2020 - 10:23am

What the pandemic has shown is that the Republicans from the President down are good at creating chaos- quite a difference from the Republicans of the past . Dispersing chaos seems like an odd political strategy and is probably the result of an election financing system that allows a small number of people including those with severe mental problems to have a larger than needed impact on political discourse.

Chuck D.
Thu, 08/06/2020 - 1:03pm

Sorry - Check your facts. Gretchen Whitmer is one of the most chaotic and divisive political figures we have ever seen in this state.
You are not self aware. Very sad.

I call BS
Mon, 08/10/2020 - 5:46pm

What about the article? No, comment! LOLs

Bob Balwinski
Tue, 08/04/2020 - 10:55am

"If a single case of COVID-19 can shutdown the Legislature, what happens when students or teachers catch the virus this fall?"
Republicans don't want to be a Petri dish.......our kids being in a Petri dish at schools? No problem!!

Wed, 08/05/2020 - 12:12pm

The difference is that if the legislature shuts down, nothing changes, no loss, but if a student infects a teacher, all the students have to stay home for two weeks and possibly infect their own families missing valuable education. The GOP legislature has no value, provides no legislation that we need.

Tue, 08/04/2020 - 11:02am

I’d say this is karma time for Senator Tom. I of course don’t want his case to be fatal, but maybe a couple of weeks of being sick as a dog and a couple of months’ recovery time will help him and his fellow republicans to take this pandemic seriously. You do know that the majority of Senate and House republicans refuse to mask up while inside the capitol?
What. is. wrong. with. these. people.
How anyone can vote republican any more is beyond me.

Tue, 08/04/2020 - 11:23am

Kevin Grand, where are you?


Tue, 08/04/2020 - 11:47am

Cut Kevin Grand a break, his work is a real burden trying to defend these elected Republican do-nothing clowns. He doesn't even have the support of the usual peanut gallery aka: duane, Marlena, Jason, Michigan Observer, Jackie C, Hank, John, Kirk, Frank, Robinson, James, CharlieD, Todd, Becky, etc.

Tue, 08/04/2020 - 2:54pm


Inquiring Minds
Tue, 08/04/2020 - 4:52pm

I'd REALLY like to hear a Republican perspective on this article. Jonathan Oosting: Can you please talk to Tim Skubick about interviewing a high profile Republican like Chatfield or Shirkey this week on "Off the Record"? PLEASE PLEASE

I miss all the Republicans who normally post here, but have turned into crickets.

Good pay, no work
Tue, 08/04/2020 - 6:02pm

Maybe they don't do a lot, but together Shirkey and Chatfield remind me of 1960's Batman and Robin (the Boy Wonder), very entertaining undercover elites. Maybe they do stuff and we just don't know about it?

Big guns, littl...
Tue, 08/04/2020 - 4:59pm

"The temporary shutdown will postpone Senate consideration of House-approved legislation that would require schools to offer in-person instruction to students in kindergarten through fifth grade this fall."

Those cowards don't want to vote on that! Aren't these the same DO-NOTHINGS that refuse to meet online with Zoom-type software?

Republicans complain tuition should be lower if online. What about the cost of paying them to do nothing and go on vacation on our dime?

Machiavelli says they should postpone their vote until Whitmer takes action. Such cowards don't want to be on the record voting to send kids back to school while they are too afraid to meet.

middle of the mit
Wed, 08/05/2020 - 9:20am

Isn't if funny or not, to see them actually BE the ones that ARE leading from behind?

Wed, 08/05/2020 - 12:23pm

Mitt, to put it nicely, they ARE behinds. You know things are bad when they don't even have talking points to spread. They are completely silent. Mitt, enjoy the calm before the next storm of feigned GOP outrage over whatever the rant of the day will be concerning Whitmer's actual leadership. Your work is paying off. Big blue wave for our country. They hate Biden, but when the Dems take over, it will be Bernie they have to fear! America is so done with the continued rehashing of Reagan deregulation and Ayn Rand crap, now that the middle class is almost completely gone. Besides most of know Putin and Russia are our enemies, even Reagan preached THAT.

middle of the mit
Wed, 08/05/2020 - 7:06pm

I feel ya. but a calm before the storm? When has the storm stopped? They just avoid areas they don't like. Confuses them. This isn't work, it's fun! I like using my previous life of being one of them, and giving them everything they used to believe in.........and making them feel....well...a little cognitive dissonance. They are numb by now, but it still hurts!

Jackie C.
Thu, 08/06/2020 - 12:34am

Politicians need a dose of school reality. Politicians need to substitute teach in elementary, middle school and high school at least one full day each year.