What Gov. Gretchen Whitmer's budget cuts and shifts mean to Michigan residents

Whitmer Kolb Gilchrist

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer announces changes to the state budget on Tuesday, as she is flanked by Chris Kolb, state budget director, and Lt. Gov. Garlin Gilchrist. (Bridge photo by Jonathan Oosting)

Have a question about the budget?

Do you have a question about the Michigan budget? Email Capitol reporters Riley Beggin at rbeggin@bridgemi.com or Jonathan Oosting at joosting@bridgemi.com 
and it could be the basis of a future story.

LANSING – Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer used a historic maneuver Tuesday morning to shift $625 million within state departments to reflect her priorities. 

The dizzying changes could affect everyday Michiganders in ways large and small, from easing the transition to Medicaid work rules to providing more money for testing of lead pipes and buying better in-car cameras for the state police.

The changes come atop line item vetoes Monday that reduce spending on schools and roads by more than $500 million; eliminate the popular Pure Michigan tourism advertising campaign and include deep cuts for rural hospitals.

There’s no guarantee the changes will stick, following Whitmer’s unprecedented use of a board comprised of her appointees to dramatically repurpose a budget approved last week by the Republican-controlled Legislature. Former Gov. John Engler pioneered the strategy but didn’t actually use it.

The moves came after weeks of impasse between the first-term Democratic governor and GOP lawmakers, who passed 16 state budget bills without her input. 

Whitmer signed the budgets on the last day of the fiscal year Monday night, avoiding a government shutdown and announcing she’d axed nearly $1 billion of the $59.9 billion budget through line item vetoes.

She waited until Tuesday morning to detail the changes. 

Whitmer called GOP budgets sent to her on Friday "fatally flawed" arguing they used restricted funds inappropriately and included a "record number of unenforceable and unconstitutional boilerplate language."

"I had to use the powers of my office to clean them up," Whitmer said.

"I do not relish using these powers, but they are absolutely necessary."

In all, Whitmer issued 147 line-item vetoes and declared 72 budget provisions constitutionally unenforceable, while the Administrative Board – comprised of her and her department heads – approved 13 transfers within department budgets.

The funding that was eliminated from the budgets can be renegotiated with the Legislature on how to spend it, opening the door for further discussions on big-ticket spending for things like roads and K-12 schools. 

Republican leaders Sen. Mike Shirkey of Clarklake and Rep. Lee Chatfield of Levering weren’t pleased with the changes, which Whitmer has invited them to discuss on Thursday in a closed door “quadrant” meeting.

Chatfield blasted Whitmer on Twitter for rejecting one-time road funding dollars, arguing that “when the governor says she wants more revenue, what she really means is more of your money via taxes!”

Shirkey said Whitmer’s vetoes won’t lead to future policy agreements with his chamber and that he’s “in no rush to participate in Governor Whitmer’s ‘tug of war.’”

Here’s a rundown of what she changed: 

Using the Administrative Board

Big shifts in Department of Health and Human Services

  • Added $6.1 million for publicity about new rules requiring Medicaid recipients to prove they are working or looking for a job come Jan. 1. Republicans had eliminated funding for the rollout altogether last week 
  • $9 million was redirected to support the implementation of the new Medicaid work rules requirements from the Department of Labor and Economic Opportunity, including eliminating an earmark for the Van Andel Institute in Grand Rapids. Whitmer has criticized GOP lawmakers for not funding their own requirement. 

Attorney General

  • Moved $90.9 million from 43 line items to the Attorney General’s Office to shore up operating funds. Nessel said during the board meeting that the budget passed by the Legislature was “an administrative nightmare.”

School funding

  • Moved $314.8 million from reserve funds to the department’s operating budget. “This move is critical if the department is going to carry out its mission of educating our children,” said Budget Director Chris Kolb.

Network security 

  • Moved $20 million to upgrade IT systems within the Department of Technology, Management and Budget
  • Moved $2.1 million to speed up forensic analysis of evidence and $2 million to enhance in-car cameras in the Michigan State Police budget. 

Water tests

  • Moved $7.5 million from private well testing and gave it to lead and copper rule implementation in the Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy. She also added $1.5 million for home testing. 
  • Moved $4 million in general fund dollars from a farm grant program and gave it to five programs, including $1.5 million to replace restricted funds and pay for the Pesticide and Plant Pest Management program. Other funds go to emergency management, animal disease prevention, a forest program and a program for minimizing pollution in agriculture. 
  • Moved $18.1 million general fund dollars to the department that certifies and regulates health care providers and community programs to support community mental health. 
  • Moved nearly $300,000 out of wildlife management within the Department of Natural Resources, including wildlife, fisheries and deer habitat research. 
  • Moved around $66.6 million within the Department of Transportation, including $13 million for urban transit to unlock federal fund matching and nearly $40 million to a passenger rail fund. 

Using line-item vetoes

Whitmer issued 147 line-item vetoes Monday night, including cutting $375 million in one-time funding for road repairs and $128 million in what she called “pork barrel spending” in the budget that goes to K-12 schools. 

This money goes back into an unspent fund that can be renegotiated with the Legislature on how to spend it.

The Legislature can override these vetoes, but it would require a two-thirds majority in each chamber — meaning state Republicans couldn’t do it without the help of their Democratic colleagues. 

Among the many items Whitmer nixed: 

  • Funding for a program that reimburses county jails for housing felons that would otherwise be held in state prisons, and with it a requirement that county jails lose that reimbursement for housing prisoners if the counties have “sanctuary” policies. 
  • $15 million in grants for monitoring PFAS at municipal airports. 
  • Around $234 million in spending within the Department of Health and Human Services, including $16.6 million in funding for rural hospitals, $129.5 million in increases in hospital Medicaid rates, and $10.7 million in pediatric psychiatric care provider rate increases. 
  • $37.5 million for the Pure Michigan tourism campaign. 
  • $37.3 million for Going Pro, a campaign to “elevate the perception of professional trades” in Michigan. 
  • $38 million in tuition grants for the state’s colleges and universities.
  • $128 million in mostly earmarks within the School Aid Budget, including $4 million for online math and literacy tools, $9.2 million for diagnostic tests, $7 million for career and technical education and $15 million for summer school literacy grants. 
  • $375 million in one-time funding for road and bridge repairs, including $243 million restricted for four bridges in Dearborn, Ferrysburg, Harrison Township and Lansing. 

Declaring unenforceable 

Whitmer is not allowed to veto boilerplate provisions that don’t have money attached to them, but she can declare them “unenforceable” if she contends they’re unconstitutional or conflict with existing law. Her predecessors of both parties (former governors John Engler, Jennifer Granholm and Rick Snyder) have regularly used this power and experts say it’s never been successfully challenged in court.

Here’s a few of the provisions she said were unenforceable: 

Balance of power

  • Provisions in multiple budgets that prohibit agencies from punishing an employee for communicating with a member of the Legislature or their staff.
  • A provision that would reduce a department or agency’s funding by 5 percent if they miss a due date to provide information requested by the Legislature. 
  • A requirement that the auditor general have access to confidential information within the governor’s administration.

Attorney general

  • A requirement that Attorney General Dana Nessel submit a cost estimate and go before the Legislature when planning to file or join a lawsuit against the federal government.
  • A requirement that she “not enter into any lawsuit that is contrary to the laws of this state” and a requirement that she “enforce the laws of this state.” Those requirements may have been a response to Nessel’s statement earlier this year that she wouldn’t enforce the state’s existing ban on abortion if Roe v Wade is overturned.

Education

  • The Legislature’s plan to dole out funding to the state Department of Education in four installments, which Whitmer called “a violation of the separation of powers.” That included sections requiring the Legislature’s approval to spend three-quarters of its budget. 

Business and economy

  • A provision barring the Department of Environment, Great Lakes and Energy from creating rules that would “have a disproportionate economic impact on small businesses” if it doesn’t offset that impact. 
  • A requirement that the Department of Technology, Management and Budget propose funding increases for a public-private partnership program if it is found to be insufficient.
  • A requirement that all contractors for the Department of Transportation verify their workers are legally authorized to work in the United States. 
  • A provision that would have undermined new road building labor contracts by prohibiting state awards to contractors who signed agreements mandating that subcontractors pay into a union fringe benefit fund even if they do not use union laborers.

Health and welfare

  • Requirements that the state Department of Health and Human Services seek approval with the Legislature before spending certain money, including on IT and submit a spending plan before replacing the child welfare system that was the subject of a scathing review for having issues that could harm children. 
  • A requirement that judges overseeing foster care cases must request input from foster parents.
  • A requirement that residential rehabilitation programs treatment requirements “be based on the least restrictive settings and must not exceed national standards for levels of care.”
  • A requirement that the Department of Licensing and Regulatory Affairs produce reports at the request of local governments on the marijuana industry’s effect on the community and, if there’s been a negative effect, work with them to create a plan to improve it.
  • A provision prohibiting the Michigan State Police from requiring officers to issue a certain number of vehicle violations and evaluating them based on whether they make those quotas.

Like what you’re reading in Bridge? Please consider a donation to support our work!

We are a nonprofit Michigan news site focused on issues that impact all citizens. In an era of click bait and biased news, we focus on taking the time to learn both sides of a story before we post it. Bridge stories are always free, but our work costs money. If our journalism helps you understand and love Michigan more, please consider supporting our work. It takes just a moment to donate here.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Hopeful
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 8:16am

Now let's see if everyone can play nicely. No one should take their marbles and go home.

Jacob
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 9:24am

Unfortunately that sounds exactly like what the GOP intends to do.

Anonymous
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 9:31am

No, she just needs to leave the office, she is one of the worst governors I have ever seen. Taking away from roads and schools, what a joke!

Duh
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 10:11am

Guess Engler gave her too much power!

Alligator Tears
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 10:15am

So sad Bill Schuette lost. NOT

Whitmer creamed him statewide and without help from foreign governments. Plus, she's beautiful. Get over it.

Matt
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 10:17am

Remember this precedent. The Gov has the right to use line item vetoes, no argument, but they can't then take those funds and shift them to other spending items, not approved by the legislature (of any party). This should and must be taken back to court, (previous court decision (wrong), notwithstanding).

Chuck Fellows
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 10:53am

Republicans now getting a taste of their own medicine. About time.

Kathi Geukes
Sun, 10/06/2019 - 8:51am

Amen!!!!!!

Richard Scott
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 12:36pm

As a retired physician in Northern Michigan I. Have been outspoken in discussions with our local legislators or their assigned delegate to town halls. Closure of rural hospitals but more importantly lacking support for difficult obstetrics, mental illness, hospice care is a major issue. That the legislature takes no action despite our representative being speaker of house suggests any speaking out against the budget cuts is not motivated by care for the rural needing care.

James Roberts
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 1:15pm

Cool. Governor Whitmer and her allies are going to hold us rural voters hostage until she gets her gas tax, which also hits us rural rubes hardest. Should play well in 2020. thanks for the commercials ammunition gang.

Jim tomlinson
Wed, 10/02/2019 - 6:20pm

Dems are better at governing

Negotiate
Thu, 10/03/2019 - 8:45am

She's just calling the boys back to the table to negotiate, like men. They can't act like there never was an election. Everyone has to show respect. The days of complete Republican control are coming to an end, along with gerrymandering. We the People have spoken.

Steven W Kluesner
Thu, 10/03/2019 - 10:42am

Hopefully this might lead to a model of State GOVERNANCE with a more appropriate aim/focus toward better (REAL) service to the interests of people throughout the state . The Republicans constantly complain about someone else trying to run government program (s) as coming after "you" for tax dollars ; when all to nearly every mode of (dys) function they seek to promote &/or carry-out is nothing more than an attempt to use a "governmental" construct/fassad for use as their own CASH COW to collect funds (taxes) which they redirect to their own pockets while they improve on nothing (quite the opposite) through JOINED EFFORT as government should rightly hope to accommodate. If this is the "best" they can do (example of the worst of POLOTICS) we should be ousting many more of them come next election.