Ron French (left) and Mike Wilkinson.
A Bridge series revealing Michigan’s long-term substitute teachers crisis won a national award for education reporting Tuesday from the Education Writers Association.
The series, reported and written by Ron French and Mike Wilkinson and which you can read here, revealed that Michigan schools were increasingly relying on untrained, uncertified long-term substitute teachers to lead classrooms, hobbling state efforts to improve the state’s mediocre academic outcomes.
The series earned the top prize for Single Topic News for newsrooms with under 25 staff members in the Washington D.C.-based EWA’s National Awards for Education Reporting contest.
A judge’s comment on the series: “Bridge’s data-driven reporting uncovered a startling increase in the number of uncertified long-term subs in Michigan’s classrooms. Ron French and Mike Wilkinson examined the issue from many angles, and provided families with a searchable database to look up how many long-term subs are in their schools.”
Bridge found that more than 2,500 classrooms had been led by long-term substitutes who weren’t certified teachers in the 2018-19 school year – a 10-fold increase in just five years.
Students who need good teachers the most — low-income and academically struggling students — were the most likely to be stuck with long-term substitutes, who aren’t required to have a four-year degree or any teacher training.
Interviews with more than three-dozen school officials, education leaders, teachers and long-term substitutes described a well-intentioned, stopgap measure designed to fill a few slots during a statewide teacher shortage that has metastasized into a policy that has seen some schools staff more than half their classrooms with long-term substitutes.
Bridge chronicled the stories of a former wedding planner and assistant basketball coach who led classrooms, and a girl who, after three years of classes led by long-term substitutes, was on track to flunk third grade.
The series culminated in a summit in which state school leaders warned that the state faced an education crisis unless steps were taken to address a growing teacher shortage.
“Mike and Ron identified a trend that will almost certainly have ramifications for the state’s ability to raise student achievement if it is not addressed,” said Bridge Editor David Zeman.
To date, state officials have taken no action to directly address the long-term substitute crisis. Policies have been tweaked to make it easier for nontraditional teachers or teachers-in-training to lead classrooms.
Some school officials worry that the long-term substitute problem could be exacerbated in the coming school year by the coronavirus pandemic, if more than the typical number of teachers leave the profession in response to fear of the deadly virus.
Ron French is project editor and senior writer for Bridge, having helped launch the nonpartisan, nonprofit publication in 2011. He previously reported for The Detroit News.
Mike Wilkinson is Bridge’s computer-assisted-reporting specialist. Wilkinson joined Bridge in 2013 following award-winning stints at The Detroit News and Toledo Blade.
This is French’s second EWA national award, and Bridge’s third.
All of the stories in this series:
- Michigan leans on long-term substitutes as its schools struggle
- How a wedding planner became an uncertified Michigan teacher for $15 an hour
- An Up North charter is 44 percent subs. You can’t tell difference, supt. says
- Expert: Michigan’s reliance on long-term subs ‘should concern all of us’
- Alarmed by long-term subs, Detroit raised teacher pay and offered bonuses
- Michigan school leaders decry explosion of untrained teachers in classrooms
- Michigan schools say they can’t find enough substitute teachers
- Taught by substitute teachers, Michigan students relied on YouTube for lessons
- Fewer Michigan college students want to be teachers. That’s a problem.
- Experts: Pay teachers more to curb Michigan’s long-term substitute ‘crisis’
- After 3 years of substitute teachers, this Michigan girl may flunk 3rd grade
- Michigan residents say they oppose uncertified teachers leading classrooms