Environmentalists outraged Michigan warning about PFAS went unheeded

Sticky foam rings a public beach near on Van Etten Lake near the shuttered Wurtsmith Air Force base. State environmental officials said it resembled foam that has tested positive for high levels of toxic perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances. (Bridge photo by Jim Malewitz)

July 31, 2018: Updated Michigan PFAS map

After more than three decades at the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality, Robert Delaney thought he “would ride quietly off into retirement.”

So much for that.

The Superfund specialist — an expert in how contaminants move in the environment — has been a source of consternation for Gov. Rick Snyder’s administration since October, when he told a radio program that his grave concern about the public threat of chemicals known as PFAS drew a tepid response from his bosses.

Officially called perfluoroalkyl and polyfluoroalkyl substances, the group of chemicals had been used to manufacture everything from Teflon and Scotchgard water repellent to firefighting foam. Early research suggests a link to a litany of health conditions from the chemicals that don’t break down in the environment.

Now a national concern — particularly at military bases –  PFAS has been detected at 31 sites in 15 Michigan communities and counting. In some cases PFAS has seeped into drinking water.

Michigan has ramped up its PFAS efforts over the past year, drawing kudos from some scientists and environmentalists. But an MLive report Tuesday that Delaney first documented concerns in a 2012 report — long drawing inaction — has unleashed a torrent of criticism from environmentalists and folks living in PFAS-tainted communities.

“The state sat on a public health crisis warning for over five years,” Anthony Spaniola, a Troy attorney who owns a cottage on Van Etten Lake in Oscoda, told Bridge Magazine.

“In reacting, the state was unprepared, made serious mistakes, and continued to keep the public in the dark as much as possible,” Spaniola added.

Oscoda, a northeast Michigan tourist destination, is where PFAS from fire suppressants at the shuttered Wurtsmith Air Force base has leached into drinking water and bubbled into toxic foam that’s washed onto beaches.

Robert Delaney, Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Superfund specialist, raised concerns about PFAS dangers as far back as 2012.

Delaney told Bridge Magazine that, while he has been frustrated with the DEQ’s pace, he appreciates the state’s recent progress.

“You’re the first guy out crying wolf. You just have to build and build and build knowledge until there’s enough people that know,” he said during a brief interview at a public event in Oscoda on June 27. “So we finally reached a critical mass.”

“Nobody goes into politics because they’re concerned about the environment,” he added, referring to the state’s elected leaders.

“So it’s always a learning experience for them. It’s not that they’re bad people.”

READ DEQ EMAILS ABOUT PFAS DANGERS HERE

Snyder, a Republican, formed a multi-agency “Michigan PFAS Action Response Team (MPART) in November, and the Legislature appropriated more than $23 million for the PFAS response a month later.

And the DEQ started testing all public water systems and schools that tap well water for the chemicals.

Michigan also sued Wolverine Worldwide, known for its Hush Puppies shoes, following revelations that toxic chemicals leached from the dumping sites in Kent County. The state has also provide alternate water supplies in some communities.

“The State of Michigan takes this issue seriously and is one of the first states in the nation to establish a clean-up standard for PFAS in groundwater used for drinking water,” a state website says.

‘A clear failure of government’

Critics wonder where that urgency was when Delaney first raised alarms as early as 2010, shortly after he learned of the PFAS threat at a U.S. Department of Defense training session.

In an email to a former DEQ division chief that year, Delaney said PFAS would likely be a "very important and problematic contaminant" in Michigan, according to the MLive report.

Delaney noted research linking exposure to neurological problems in animals, and suggested Michigan should track PFAS research statewide, the news report said.

In 2012, Delaney teamed with Richard DeGrandchamp, a toxicology and epidemiology professor at the University of Colorado, to author a 93-page report to then-DEQ Director Dan Wyant called “Michigan’s Contaminant Induced Human Health Crisis: Addressing Michigan’s Future By Facing the Challenge of the Evolving Nature of Environmental Contamination.”

“Not only are human populations exposed to these contaminants, but also there is widespread exposure to the nation’s and to Michigan’s ecosystems by these chemicals,” the researchers wrote.

Contaminants from the PFAS family “are contained in the blood serum of virtually every Michigan citizen,” the report said.

In his report and elsewhere, Delaney offered more than 30 recommendations. "Virtually all" have been addressed in some way, said Scott Dean, a DEQ spokesman. Critics note many of those actions came only recently — largely over the past year. 

The DEQ didn’t post Delaney’s 2012 report online until after MLive requested it through the Freedom of Information Act, and the agency did so quietly.

Just weeks before Snyder launched his response team, Delaney, sitting beside his lawyer, discussed his PFAS research on the air with Steve Gruber, a conservative radio personality based in Lansing.

"I don't know what happened to the report afterwards,” he told Gruber. I gave him the report. I did learn later he distributed it to other upper managers at DEQ."

Environmentalists are outraged.

“The fact that this report was withheld from the public for six years is completely unacceptable and a clear failure of government,” Lisa Wozniak, executive director of the Michigan League of Conservation Voters, said in a news release.

“‘Forever chemicals’ like PFAS are a silent epidemic of major proportions in the Great Lakes state and have put countless families’ health at risk.”

Gretchen Whitmer, a Democratic candidate for governor, called the state’s PFAS response “a failure of leadership that has endangered the lives of Michiganders.”

Related: Here’s where Michigan governor candidates stand on funding toxic cleanups

Dean said "Michigan has moved faster than any state in addressing PFAS contamination."

"We moved quickly to protect people from potentially unsafe drinking water in communities with known PFAS contamination from historic industrial or military activities," Dean said.

“We remain focused on being a national leader in public health by focusing on the important work (the PFAS team) is doing to protect people's drinking water and keep people informed as state and independent scientists continue to learn more about this nationally emerging contaminant.”

Dean added that Michigan is ready to assist local governments in investigating PFAS and will take action against polluters. 

"We have also pressed federal agencies like the EPA to accelerate rule-making and standard setting for this emerging class of contaminants," he said.

‘Extraordinary times’

Delaney’s radio interview appears to have complicated his life at DEQ.

The agency subsequently curtailed his accessibility to the media — initially turning down Bridge’s interview request before a reporter talked to him at a public event.

“This has been a very awkward time for me because of the way things played out. After a 33 year career working for the Department, I kind of thought I would ride quietly off into retirement,” he wrote to DEQ director Heidi Grether in January, correspondence that Bridge obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request and was not previously reported.

“I guess we live in extraordinary times.”

Delaney was responding to an email from Grether that summarized the agency’s response to the 2012 report.

“A number of recommendations contained in your report are not within DEQ’s authority to implement, but state government all the way up to the Governor is engaged and actively working to identify and mitigate potential threats to public health,” she wrote.

In his response, Delaney said he was “just brainstorming” in offering the recommendations and agreed that “many of the ideas might be impractical or as you point out, not within the authority of DEQ.”

“I want to say, I am so very impressed by the thoughtful approach the state agencies and the Governor’s office have brought to the issue,” Delaney wrote.

Delaney told Bridge that a bureaucratic squabble isn’t the most important narrative associated with PFAS.

The biggest story, he said, is that America hasn’t learned from its environmental sins decades ago.

“We didn’t learn what we needed to learn,” he said. “So that’s kind of the transformation for me. And that’s the same transformation a lot of people are going through.”

Like what you’re reading in Bridge? Please consider a donation to support our work!

It takes time, money, and hard work to inform Michigan readers and leaders with substantive, in-depth, future-oriented news and analysis. If you value our journalism, please consider a one-time donation or a monthly contribution. It takes just a moment to donate here. Please join the thousands of Bridge readers who are helping grow and sustain our nonprofit, in-depth public service journalism in Michigan.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Lori
Fri, 07/13/2018 - 9:01am

I'm sure it's a complete coincidence that the entire state will need to buy bottled water from nestle .

glynn
Fri, 07/13/2018 - 9:01am

So what new Snyder the sanke hates Michigan and is out to destroy our state like he did Flint!!!!

Dendra Best
Fri, 07/13/2018 - 9:41am

Kudos to Garret Ellison (2017 MI Press Journalist of the Year) of the Grand Rapids Press mLive for his amazing, persistent reporting on this issue.
https://www.mlive.com/news/index.ssf/2018/07/meq_pfas_delaney_2012_repor...
All of Garret Ellison’s articles can be viewed here - http://connect.mlive.com/user/gellison/posts.html
and the recording of a recent PFAS presentation where he was a co-presenter can be viewed here: https://wateriswater.adobeconnect.com/p7l2bi50emjz/
This New York Times article by Nathanial Rich from 2016 details the story of how all of this PFAS stuff came to light. Not a pretty tale but an interesting one. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/01/10/magazine/the-lawyer-who-became-dupont...
And an interactive map site - http://sorenrundquist.com/PFAS

John S.
Fri, 07/13/2018 - 10:23am

Almost always, it's the political appointees who are ethically challenged. The political appointees put the public image of the governor and his party ahead of public health. It's see no evil, hear no evil, speak no evil. The report should have been posted to the DEQ website immediately.

Joan Black
Fri, 07/13/2018 - 12:33pm

So much for the “Pure Michigan” ad-phrase.

Paul Jordan
Fri, 07/13/2018 - 1:07pm

From its inception, the Snyder administration has not hidden the fact that its priority is to promote the interests of corporations. They cut revenue sharing while cutting business taxes, which has hurt every local government--and every resident--in Michigan. In Flint, the state's priority was to risk residents' health in an attempt to save a little money, while DEQ's priority was to pretend that everything was okay and the folks in Flint were nuts. And now, we learn that (the same administrators at) DEQ knew six years ago that there was another danger lurking in the groundwater--but ignored it.
It looks like the main mission of the DEQ throughout the Snyder administration has been to cover up for industry while lying to the public.

Rob
Fri, 07/13/2018 - 2:46pm

Please do tell us which company Snyder or the state was trying to help by switching Flint's water source, or whose money would've been saved.

False narrative.

Chris S.
Mon, 07/16/2018 - 10:37am

KWA Bondholders (Snyder backers) stood to lose a boatload if Flint didn't sign on to the KWA.

Randy
Mon, 07/16/2018 - 10:43am

Continued malfeasance in office by the Governor.