Feds demand answers from Gov. Whitmer on Michigan nursing home deaths

Nursing home residents comprise nearly 1 in 3 Michigan COVID-19 deaths, and Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s policies requiring some homes to accept recovering patients have proven controversial. Whitmer slams the request as blatantly political.(Shutterstock)

LANSING – The U.S. Department of Justice announced Wednesday it is seeking data from Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and three other Democratic governors who "issued orders which may have resulted in the deaths of thousands of elderly nursing home residents."

Much of the data is already publicly available, but the department is evaluating whether to investigate Michigan nursing homes for possible violations of a federal law protecting the rights of "institutionalized persons," Assistant Attorney General Eric Dreiband told Whitmer in a letter. 

At least 2,083 nursing home residents have died from COVID-19 in Michigan, accounting for nearly 1 in 3 deaths attributed to the novel coronavirus here since March. 

Related stories:

Whitmer issued a joint statement with New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who received a similar demand from U.S. attorneys, that called the request a  “transparent politicization of the Department of Justice in the middle of the Republican National Convention.” 

“At least 14 states — including Kentucky, Utah, and Arizona — have issued similar nursing home guidance all based on federal guidelines – and yet the four states listed in the DOJ’s request have a Democratic governor,” the statement read.

Dreiband, nominated by Republican President Donald Trump, sent similar letters to Govs. Phil Murphy of New Jersey and Tom Wolf of Pennsylvania. 

Like Michigan and New York, those states were hit early and hard by COVID-19 and implemented policies designed to prevent hospital overcrowding by returning “medically stable” seniors to the nursing homes they lived in. But critics contend the policies may have exposed vulnerable residents to the virus.

Whitmer's April 15 order required nursing homes to readmit seniors who had been treated for the virus, but only if the facilities had set up dedicated isolation units and had appropriate personal protection equipment, which was in short supply across the country in March and April. 

COVID-19 has recently surged in Republican-led southern states including Florida and Texas, which now report more total nursing home deaths than Michigan but also have larger populations. As of Aug. 9, Michigan ranked 12th among all states for nursing home deaths per 1,000 residents, according to federal data

Whitmer's nursing home policies have sparked controversy, a partisan congressional inquiry and bipartisan action in the state Legislature, which in June approved a measure that would have created COVID-only facilities to house infected nursing home residents. 

Whitmer vetoed the bill, calling it a "a political game that would relocate vulnerable seniors without any requirement for consent, doctor’s approval, or notification to patients and their families."

The Department of Justice letter includes a request for data on the number of persons who were admitted to nursing homes from a hospital or other medical facility "after testing positive for COVID-19 during the period the guidance or orders were in effect."

That information is available through the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. As Bridge has reported, by July 5 Michigan nursing homes reported they had collectively admitted or readmitted patients previously diagnosed with COVID-19 more than 2,750 times.

Most of the other Michigan data Dreiband requested — including nursing home deaths and case counts — is also on the state health department's website. He also asked for any state-issued guidance, directives, advisories or executive orders on nursing home policy, as well as the number of nursing home guests and visitors who contracted COVID. (Whitmer closed nursing homes to all visitors on March 13, two days after the state confirmed its first two cases of COVID-19.)

Dreiband told Whitmer the department has not yet "reached any conclusions" about Michigan nursing homes and whether to launch an investigation. 

“Protecting the rights of some of society’s most vulnerable members, including elderly nursing home residents, is one of our country’s most important obligations,” he said in a statement. “We must ensure they are adequately cared for with dignity and respect and not unnecessarily put at risk.”

After weeks of delays, Michigan began publishing public data in June on deaths and cases for both residents and staff of the state’s 400-plus nursing homes. At one point, health officials said releasing the data would cause “undue stress” on homes. 

Unlike other states, Michigan still does not release data on COVID-19 deaths and cases in long-term care facilities such as adult foster care, homes for the aged and unlicensed assisted-living centers. Experts have said cases in those facilities  may exceed nursing homes.

Whitmer’s administration also has yet to release data on COVID-19 outbreaks at 14 schools statewide.

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.

Comments

Anonymous
Thu, 08/27/2020 - 4:52am

I heard they're having a Republican convention this week. So Trump is trumping up investigations of Democratic governors, while ignoring the plague and making no mention of the nightmare brewing in the gulf. Please God make this BS end soon. We are sorry. Give us a competent leader of our country.

Mabelle Kirk
Thu, 08/27/2020 - 9:48am

Why are the Feds only requesting nursing home data from Democratic governors and not others like FL and Texas with higher death rates? Looks politically motivated.

Louise
Thu, 08/27/2020 - 9:56am

Who put the elderly and adult disabled in nursing homes to their deaths is the first place most likely court appointed guardians had something to do with it from the get go nationwide.

Trump's asinine
Thu, 08/27/2020 - 10:23am

Shame on her for following Trump's CDC guidelines. She should know he's incompetent and dangerous. Now he says stop testing if you were exposed to someone positive, but asymptomatic. We should respect Trump's desire to keep the numbers down, so he can be reelected for more years or as he likes to say "12 more years", "just to irritate us".

Fran
Thu, 08/27/2020 - 11:25am

Nursing Homes are for the most part privately owned, for- profit businesses; how can the Federal Government hold State Governors liable when half the citizens protested masks, business shut downs, and social distancing?

William C. Plumpe
Thu, 08/27/2020 - 11:56am

And Whitmer in turn should at minimum sue or indict Trump for failing to exercise
leadership and proper diligence in the first weeks of the virus outbreak. Trump initially denied the virus was a threat even calling it a hoax and trying to happy talk it away. Decisive action not ignorance on Trump's part would have saved thousands of lives and trillions of dollars. Trump finally found a challenge in the virus he couldn't bullshit away with slick sales talk and Trump failed costing almost 200,000 lives and trillions in economic damage. Trump should not be rewarded for his abject failure with another term.

Full Disclosure
Thu, 08/27/2020 - 12:51pm

From the author - "After weeks of delays, Michigan began publishing public data in June on deaths and cases for both residents and staff of the state’s 400-plus nursing homes."

"Unlike other states, Michigan still does not release data on COVID-19 deaths and cases in long-term care facilities such as adult foster care, homes for the aged and unlicensed assisted-living centers. Experts have said cases in those facilities may exceed nursing homes."

Election year or not, the people of Michigan have a right to know the circumstances of their loved ones' deaths and to assess the degree of on-going risk posed to those in group homes. You can't say we're relying on data and science while refusing to release the data to the public.

Anonymous
Fri, 08/28/2020 - 2:49pm

What's the fuss? Trump said covid disappeared on Easter. I guess seasonal flu will disappear after the election, according to Trump's buddies at Qanon.

Jonah212
Thu, 08/27/2020 - 2:34pm

Maybe US Justice Department should investigate the role that Trump played in allowing the coronavirus to grow exponentially while he did nothing other than to minimize the virus as he continues to do so. Oh, that's right, Barr is his toady.

Under the circumstances, Gov. Whitmer did the best she could under the circumstances. Just look at the failures of Republican Governors in Texas, Florida, Georgia, Alabama and Mississippi.

mw
Fri, 08/28/2020 - 1:37pm

Before the anti-Whitmer Trump brigade shows up, from the previous article Bridge did on this story:

"Neither elder care advocates nor the state health department say they are aware of any nursing home that was forced to admit a COVID-positive resident against its will. "

Greg
Sat, 08/29/2020 - 6:52am

We'll find out that Whitmer and Cuomo were responsible for the majority of NY and Michigan's deaths. Still have to keep the gyms closed though. They are "superspreaders"
She needs to be recalled.