Whitmer faces some backlash over Benton Harbor High closing

Gov. Gretchen Whitmer speaks this month to residents of Benton Harbor who are upset over plans to close the city's high school over low performance.

Update: New Michigan school superintendent: Keep Benton Harbor High open
Update: Gov. Whitmer to Benton Harbor High: Raise scores, balance books or close
Update: Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, Benton Harbor reach tentative deal to save high school

[This article has been updated]

A decision to try to close Benton Harbor High School is causing Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer to face some harsh blowback from her political base, the majority-black community of Benton Harbor where she earned 95 percent of the vote in the 2018 election.

In a demonstration Tuesday in Lansing, Benton Harbor Mayor Marcus Muhammad and other speakers expressed frustration regarding Whitmer’s proposed plan to close the community’s only high school. The closing would send students to 10 other high schools in surrounding communities.

“We are here today to appeal to Gov. Whitmer,” Muhammad said. “We’re not here to be rabble-rousers. We’re here to seek justice.”

The Benton Harbor School Board has until  June 14, to either approve or reject Whitmer’s plan to dissolve Benton Harbor High School. The board, which has said it will not even vote on the plan, risks dissolution of the entire school district.


Administration officials have maintained that dissolving the district, such as happened with Inkster and Buena Vista in 2013, would require a vote by the Legislature. But at least one expert suggested that Whitmer appears to have a much easier path to blowing up the struggling district, if she so chooses.

A district can be dissolved through the approval of just two people ‒ the state schools superintendent and the state treasurer, according to a law the Legislature passed in 2013 that was used to break up Inkster schools in Wayne County and Buena Vista in Saginaw County. If applied to Benton Harbor, that would mean Whitmer’s appointed treasurer, Rachael Eubanks, and the state superintendent (either Interim Superintendent Sheila Alles or incoming superintendent, Michael Rice, named by the Democratic-majority state school board).

“The authority to dissolve districts under the School Code resides with the state superintendent and the treasurer,” Craig Thiel, research director for Citizens Research Council, said in an email to Bridge. “(There is a) lot of misinformation going around … Amazing that the State Board was led to believe it is the lawmakers call on dissolution.”

A 2013 legal analysis of the law, sent to then-Supt. Mike Flanagan and Treasurer Andy Dillon, said in part:

“.... a school district shall lose its organization and shall be declared dissolved if, after consultation with the intermediate school district in which the school is located, the Superintendent of Public Instruction and the State Treasurer jointly determine that the factors of Section 12(1)(b) of 2013 PA 96 apply to the school district.”

You can read the letter here.

But Whitmer's office disputed that the law applies to the situation in Benton Harbor.

A district must meet six factors to the satisfaction of the treasurer and state superintendent before the 2013 law can be invoked. Benton Harbor's struggles likely meet five of those factors: it's made poor progress in eliminating debt; its debt is growing; a case can be made it is not financially viable, it has student enrollment between 300 and 2,400 and hasn’t consolidated with another district.

But Zach Pohl, communications director for Whitmer, noted in an email to Bridge that Benton Harbor does not meet a sixth factor: a 10-percent decline in enrollment in its most recent school year. Benton Harbor's enrollment dropped 9.3 percent from 2017-18 to the current school year.  

Marty Ackley, director of public and governmental affairs for the Michigan Department of Education, had told Bridge the law was still in effect, and that it could be considered if all factors are met, but is considered a “last resort.”

Instead, according to Ron Leix, communications officer at the Department of Treasury, “in the case of Benton Harbor Area Schools, the state of Michigan has offered the school district a proposal that preserves the school district by closing the high school and converting the district to a K-8 district.

Rice, the current superintendent of Kalamazoo Public Schools, will take over as state superintendent July 1.

At minimum, such an interpretation of the dissolution law would give Whitmer more leverage in negotiations with the district, Thiel said.

Whitmer has said her plan is meant to address both high debt and low academic performance in the district.

“There are problems (in Benton Harbor schools),” Muhammad acknowledged. “But allow for us to solve our problems. Don’t come in with a sledgehammer. Come in with an open hand to support the district – the only black (majority) district in the entire Berrien County.”

The Benton Harbor School Board proposed a plan of its own Monday night, which is set to be presented to the governor on Wednesday. Muhammad says he supports this alternative, which he did not outline to the media Tuesday. He said he hopes to “to see Governor Whitmer work with the school board.”

Pastor Carlton Lynch of Pilgrim Rest Baptist Church in Benton Harbor, who also spoke at the event, cited Whitmer’s 2017 visit to Benton Harbor when she was campaigning for governor. Lynch said she then laid out an educational plan for the city’s struggling schools that “had nothing to do with shutting down the school” but rather to “strengthen that which remained.”

“It frustrates our community, especially a predominantly African-American community that has supported Democrats,” Lynch said. “And it almost makes us believe that this candidate, who is now our governor...has taken advantage of the black vote. And now our heart is broken.”

Whitmer defended her plan Tuesday. “We put a thoughtful solution on the table,” Whitmer told the Michigan Legislative Black Caucus, according to The Detroit News. “If someone has a viable alternative that [The Michigan Department of] Treasury and MDE [Michigan Department of Education] feel addresses the outcomes for kids as well as the debt, than I’m certainly interested in considering it.”

Joining the protests Tuesday were other Democrats.

“Never did I imagine that after eight years of Rick Snyder dismantling public education that his policies would find life for a third term under the new (Democratic) governor, Gretchen Whitmer,” said state Rep. Isaac Robinson, D-Hamtramck. “Public opinion is clear: We don’t want to close that high school. Gov. Whitmer has a choice, and let’s hope that she can work it out.”

Robinson also criticized Whitmer for another decision she made in office: the recent no-fault auto insurance deal forged with a Republican-led Legislature.

“Gov. Whitmer and the legislature sold us out by not addressing redlining and letting survivors down when they did the car insurance deal in the middle of the night,” Robinson said. “No more broken promises...I’m tired of talking points saying you ended redlining. I’m tired of the campaign statement you sent out to Benton Harbor saying you’re going to stand with the public schools, but then you come out here and stand with the DeVos privitizers.”

Lily Schulting, who is from Grand Rapids and ran for a position on the state Board of Education last year, said she attended the demonstration as an “ally” for the Benton Harbor community.

“I think everyone is astounded that this is happening,” Schulting said. “Even friends who are traditional Democrats and very middle-of-the-road are surprised. They’re the biggest Whitmer supporters and they were surprised that this is happening under Whitmer.”

Despite being adamant about keeping Benton Harbor High School open, Muhammad expressed hope for a compromise.

“We’re asking for the governor, her staff and the legislators to be restorative, not punitive,” Muhammad said. “We want to work with the governor ... We’re hopeful for the best. We want the governor to be successful. But not at the expense of the City of Benton Harbor and Benton Harbor High School.”

Facts matter. Trust matters. Journalism matters.

If you learned something from the story you're reading please consider supporting our work. Your donation allows us to keep our Michigan-focused reporting and analysis free and accessible to all. All donations are voluntary, but for as little as $1 you can become a member of Bridge Club and support freedom of the press in Michigan during a crucial election year.

Pay with VISA Pay with MasterCard Pay with American Express Donate now

Comment Form

Add new comment

Dear Reader: We value your thoughts and criticism on the articles, but insist on civility. Criticizing comments or ideas is welcome, but Bridge won’t tolerate comments that are false or defamatory or that demean, personally attack, spread hate or harmful stereotypes. Violating these standards could result in a ban.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
This question is for testing whether or not you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.


Kevin Grand
Wed, 06/12/2019 - 8:24am

"“There are problems (in Benton Harbor schools),” Muhammad acknowledged. “But allow for us to solve our problems. Don’t come in with a sledgehammer. Come in with an open hand to support the district – the only black (majority) district in the entire Berrien County.”"

So, exactly what does being "black" have to do with the fact that the students aren't learning?

Only 3% of 3rd Graders in BHAS can read at grade level according to last year's numbers.

Absolutely no 11th Graders were college ready for five years running.

Considering how long the truckloads of money being dumped into the district have yielded these criminal results, to cite a tired racial trope as your only defense only strains the credibility on Benton Harbor's willingness to act.

Chuck Jordan
Wed, 06/12/2019 - 2:38pm

What I don't understand is "if truckloads of money have been dumped into the district," why haven't they been able to hire certified teachers for every grade? Why can't they even have a library with books in it? Why is it that poor, mostly minority districts cannot provide the kinds of technology and classes and teachers that are just across the river? And you don't think racism has anything to do with it? Bus all the kids to St. Joseph. See what happens.

Kevin Grand
Wed, 06/12/2019 - 8:48pm

Did you totally miss the part about the test scores?

Care to venture a guess as to why they are so bad?

Care to add anything regarding why parents haven't complained over all these years about why their child(ren) cannot perform at grade level?

When you only care about what happens only after the state threatens to cut off your funding once and for all...something is very wrong here.

Wed, 06/12/2019 - 9:25am

Everyone needs to start asking Benton Harbor elected officials and the school board. Where do you send your kids/grand kids to school? Not one of them go to Benton Harbor. There is more to this story also, kids are not getting the education to pass or graduate. There has to be security and armed cops in the school at all times. Why?

Wed, 06/12/2019 - 9:56am

Was not Benton Harbor taken over by one of Snyders EM who sold every thing the city own then walk away leveling Benton Harbor Millions in depth like he did the DPS and Flint?

Wed, 06/12/2019 - 3:50pm

No, the EM got the city out of a deep financial hole. Once the city manager (EM) got the city council out of the way (for a while) he cut off much of the patronage and terminated contracts that benefited family more than the city.
The plan for BH schools was the same, but the law allowing it was spiked. Same situation...if you can get the board out of the way for a while real progress can be made to eliminate unqualified and over-paid employees, hire decent administrators, then get some full-time teachers and fire the poor performers. With Herrera leaving none of this will happen when the current board is in calling the shots.

Wed, 06/12/2019 - 6:45pm

How about if they dissolve school of choice? Then Benton Harbor Schools would get the state moneys for the students that live in the Benton Harbor district. That way the school would have more funds to look at better teaching staff and programs.

Thu, 06/13/2019 - 2:58pm

I stand in solidarity with the Benton Harbor community, their Mayor, and the school board. Governor Whiner, preserve the only Benton Harbor High School, and fine a solution, instead of a desolutuon! Do not allow the black community to experience another "land grab!"

Pepe the Frog
Tue, 06/25/2019 - 1:29am

What's the average IQ of students in the Benton Harbor school district?

Washington, DC public schools spend six times as much money per student as public schools in Vermont or West Virginia, and their graduates still get 400-500 points lower on SAT scores on average.

Only in Clown World would public officials be encouraged to virtue-signal by shoveling trillions of dollars of the people's money down that particular bottomless rathole, when we can't even fix the roads. At least it's always entertaining to watch the Dunning-Kruger Effect in action.

Honk honk, fren.